Friend was 'convinced' fairy hoax photos were real

A black and white photo of a young girl with brown hair and a headband resting her hand on her neck and looking at the camera. In front are small dancing fairies. She is sitting outdoors with what appears to be a stream behind her. Image source, David Whittaker
Image caption,

Frances Griffiths was pictured with what appeared to be a band of fairies, in images that shocked the world

  • Published

A woman who "spent her whole life believing in fairies" was horrified to learn the world-famous Cottingley Fairies photographs were a hoax, her son has revealed.

The images, taken by Frances Griffiths and Elsie Wright between 1917 and 1920, apparently depicted the cousins surrounded by magical creatures in a garden in Bradford.

David Whittaker said his mother Mary Anderson had been given a set by best friend Frances and had been convinced they were real but wanted to throw them out when Elsie confessed they were fake in 1983.

However, he saved them and two of the five photos are due to go under the hammer in Louth, Lincolnshire.

A black and white photo of a young girl with long hair sat on grass with trees in the background. She is wearing a white dress and a dark hat with a flower on the side and smiling whilst looking at a small mythical creature with wings and its foot in the air.Image source, David Whittaker
Image caption,

A group of three photographs and archive of material related to the fairy hoax, sold as a single lot, is expected to make well into four figures

The pictures became a worldwide sensation when Sherlock Holmes author Arthur Conan Doyle published them in 1920, believing them to be authentic.

They had been examined by experts and one of them was commissioned by Bradford's Theosophical Society to produce a number of prints to be sold.

Frances passed a set to Mary, who "totally believed" they were genuine, said Mr Whittaker, adding that she showed them to neighbours and family members.

When Elsie revealed the fairies had been made out of paper cut-outs and hatpins, Mary "felt so let down", her son said.

"She brought out the photographs and the archive of material she had collected over the years and told us to throw it all out," said the 85-year-old, who lives in Saltfleetby.

"It was only because my wife intervened and offered to take care of it in case she changed her mind that it did not end up in the dustbin.

"Mother never did change her mind."

A man with grey hair, a purple and white square patterned shirt and navy tie is holding a black and white photo of a girl with fairies in front of her. Behind him are paintings on a wall. Image source, John Taylors Auction Rooms
Image caption,

Auctioneer James Laverack said John Taylors Auction Rooms was "delighted" to take the photos to auction

Though Elsie maintained none of the images were real, Frances insisted one was genuine and that the pair had seen fairies by the beck in Cottingley.

Two photographs in original wallets will go to auction on Tuesday, as well as a photo of Mary and Frances on an outing in the early 1920s.

An archive of material will also go under the hammer.

"We're not actually concerned about value, we are more concerned it will go to someone who will look after and respect them," Mr Whittaker said.

A black and white photo of a group of people on an outing sat on what appears to be a hedge next to a conifer. Two older woman have long coats on and hats and two young girls in the background also have scarves on and coats.Image source, David Whittaker
Image caption,

A photo of Mary Anderson with Frances Griffiths on an outing in the early 1920s will be part of the auction

Auctioneer James Laverack, from John Taylors Auction Rooms, said the "very rare" photos were "the first high quality prints to be made of the glass plate negatives."

He said the photographs were "wonderful things to have in the auction" and that they were "delighted" to take them to auction.

One of the lots is expected to fetch more than four figures, the auction house added.

Listen to highlights from Lincolnshire on BBC Sounds, watch the latest episode of Look North or tell us about a story you think we should be covering here, external.

Download the BBC News app from the App Store, external for iPhone and iPad or Google Play, external for Android devices

Related topics