Sentences for killer ex-partners 'still not enough'
- Published
Government plans to increase sentences for jealous ex-partners who kill or strangle their victims do not go far enough, a campaigner has said.
Hetti Barkworth-Nanton's friend, Joanna Simpson, was killed by her husband in 2010.
Ms Barkworth-Nanton said the changes were the right "direction of travel" but did not address the disparity between starting sentences for homicides committed inside and outside the home.
A spokesperson for the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) said the Law Commission was reviewing the sentencing framework for murder, and the law of homicide.
"Sentencing for domestic murder is a complex issue which requires wholesale reform rather than piecemeal change," they said, adding that the killing of Ms Simpson was "abhorrent".
The starting sentence for murder is a minimum of 15 years in prison.
Following the murder of Ben Kinsella in 2010, the government changed the sentence starting point for murders committed with a knife or other weapon taken to the scene with intent to 25 years.
But because homicides that take place in a home often use a weapon that was already at the scene, domestic homicides generally do not qualify for the higher starting point, according to the MoJ, external.
Ms Barkworth-Nanton said that was something she wanted to see change, and was worried the aggravating factors of the homicide involving strangling or the end of a relationship would not be sufficient to close the gap.
Ms Simpson, 46, was bludgeoned to death by Robert Brown in Ascot, Berkshire, in October 2010.
He buried her body in a pre-dug grave in Windsor Great Park before confessing to the police the following day.
He was found not guilty of murder after a jury was told the couple's bitter divorce proceedings had placed him under stress.
'Even playing field'
Ms Barkworth-Nanton said Brown's actions were "not some spur of the moment thing" just because he used a weapon that was already in the house, and said the sentencing system needed to be simplified.
"If someone murders their partner or ex-partner... then their starting point should be 25 years," she said.
"We've just got to get an even playing field."
Get in touch
Do you have a story BBC Berkshire should cover?
You can follow BBC Berkshire on Facebook, external, X (Twitter), external, or Instagram, external.
- Published6 December
- Published21 October
- Published12 October 2023