Differing views as devolution plans progress

The new combined authority will take in Southampton, Portsmouth, Hampshire and Isle of Wight councils

Discussions have begun ahead of the biggest transformation of local government in southern England in decades.

With this month's elections cancelled, attention has turned to the devolution plans for a new combined authority taking in Hampshire and the Isle of Wight and led by an elected mayor.

Alongside devolution is local government reorganisation. With district and borough councils set to be scrapped, council leaders are deciding the future layout of the remaining local authorities.

Opinion is divided among local politicians. For some, devolution means more powers and funding under local control, while others see it as costly and bureaucratic.

The region's council leaders have differing views on devolution and council reorganisation

Portsmouth and Southampton city councils, along with Hampshire County Council and the Isle of Wight, voted to accept the government's offer to create a combined mayoral authority earlier this year.

Devolution has been central to the Labour government's plans for local government with Prime Minister Kier Strarmer promoting it as allowing "those with skin in the game - those that know their communities - to make much better decisions".

Phil Jordan is the Independent leader of Isle of Wight council and favours devolution as potentially beneficial to the island.

"Decisions made up in Westminster in London will be passed down to us," he said.

Nick Adams-King, Conservative leader of Hampshire County Council, said the financial gains of devolution "might not be much initially".

"But whenever government has money to give out it's the combined authorities which get it first and we need to be part of that."

But concerns have been raised by some leaders of other local authorities.

The leader of Basingstoke and Deane council, Dr Paul Harvey, said he was worried the mayoral election could become a "personality contest".

"We don't want a presidential style election, we need to know what the potential candidates are promising on transport, economic development, real political issues."

The leader of Gosport Borough Council, Peter Chegwyn, said he thought the public would not support another level of bureaucracy.

"It's not really devolution because that would bring decisions nearer to the people and this doesn't, it's just another layer of government."

'Turkeys voting for Christmas'

Council leaders and chief executives are currently working out how to create new, larger local authorities, each serving about 500,000 people.

An interim report submitted to the government in March suggested four mainland councils based around the centres of Basingstoke, Winchester, Southampton and Portsmouth.

Final proposals on reorganisation need to be submitted by September.

Steve Pitt, leader of Portsmouth City Council, has written to the government insisting his authority is financially sustainable and does not want to be part of reorganisation.

"The government isn't just asking us to be turkeys voting for Christmas, it's asking us to make the stuffing and put the dinner on," he said.

Mr Chegwyn also raised concerns about finances.

"Hampshire County Council has huge debts and if you create new authorities without sorting finance for social care and children with extra needs, the new councils will be bust on day one".

Jill Cleary, leader of New Forest District Council, said the process was being "rushed"

In some rural areas, leaders have voiced concern about being "swallowed up" by cities.

Jill Cleary, leader of New Forest District Council, said the process was a "back-of-a-fag packet idea".

"If this has to happen, we need to merge with like-minded 'green' councils with national park, housing stock of their own and rural businesses. Cities are different."

On the Isle of Wight, Mr Jordan said he had asked for the island to be an exceptional case and retain its unitary status.

"We don't save any money sharing services across the Solent," he said.

"Our bin lorries collect waste here and take it to recycling plants or landfill on the Island. There's no benefit to any merger".

Speaking at a meeting in Southampton last month, devolution minister Jim McMahon said the process needed "clarity and pace".

"Local people need to see the improvements to services this will bring," he added.