Parking fine rises too harsh, deputies say

Deputies agreed in January to increase the minimum fine to £65

An attempt to limit an increase in parking fines will be debated by deputies.

Deputies David De Lisle and Chris Blin put forward an amendment after it was agreed earlier this year the lowest fine would go from £40 to £65.

They say the increase is "unfair" and puts pressure on people already struggling with rising costs.

The change had been approved by 34 to two in January.

The two deputies believe the fines should increase but should "remain fair and proportionate".

They propose the lowest fine, for Band A offences, including for failing to set your parking clock and for driving on a footpath, would be raised from £40 to £45.

Under their proposals Band B offences, including having no number plates, dropping litter and riding a bike without a bell, would increase from £70 to £80, instead of £95 as agreed.

The highest level of fines – Band C offences – including failing to wear a seatbelt and using a mobile phone while driving, were approved to increase from £100 to £125, which Mr De Lisle and Mr Blin say should instead be raised to £115.

Each year about 14,000 fines are handed out in Guernsey.

Fines should remain "fair and proportionate", deputies say

'Overly punitive'

The amendment states "an increase in revenue was not the driver for change".

They say increasing the fine for Band A offences by 61% is disproportionate and "will result in an economic burden on lower income islanders, leading to financial hardship.

"The proposed increased amounts are overly punitive fines which will lead to public resentment and loss of trust", the two deputies added.