BBC Homepage
  • Skip to content
  • Accessibility Help
  • Your account
  • Notifications
  • Home
  • News
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • iPlayer
  • Sounds
  • Bitesize
  • CBBC
  • CBeebies
  • Food
  • More menu
More menu
Search BBC
  • Home
  • News
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • iPlayer
  • Sounds
  • Bitesize
  • CBBC
  • CBeebies
  • Food
Close menu
BBC News
Menu
  • Home
  • InDepth
  • Israel-Gaza war
  • War in Ukraine
  • Climate
  • UK
  • World
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Culture
More
  • Tech
  • Science
  • Health
  • Family & Education
  • In Pictures
  • Newsbeat
  • BBC Verify
  • Disability
  • Trending

#BBCtrending: Garner decision widely condemned

  • Published
    3 December 2014
Share page
About sharing
Undated photo of Eric Garner.Image source, AP
ByBBC Trending
What's popular and why

News that New York Police officer Daniel Pantaleo will not be charged for the death of Eric Garner was greeted with condemnation across the political spectrum on Wednesday afternoon.

"It seems like the only people who didn't think the cop who killed Eric Garner should have been indicted [charged] were on that grand jury," tweets, external the Washington Post's Matt O'Brien.

After being confronted by police for selling untaxed cigarettes, officers attempted to arrest Garner. Mr Pantaleo placed him in a chokehold and wrestled him to the ground, while three other officers attempted to put him in handcuffs.

Garner, gasping that he couldn't breathe, went into cardiac arrest and died in an ambulance on the way to a hospital. A coroner's report found that his death was the result of compression of the neck and chest, complicated by pre-existing health conditions.

Commentators were quick to offer sharp words on political websites and through social media.

"As it stands, there is no amount of force an officer can use that isn't unjustified, regardless of the situation," tweets, external Slate's Jamelle Bouie.

The Federalist's Sean Davis points to, external the video of the incident, filmed by a bystander, as nearly irrefutable evidence that Garner's death was "completely unnecessary".

"He wasn't a mortal threat to anyone," Davis says. "He carried no weapons. He did not shove or attack any police officers in such a way to be considered an imminent threat to their health and safety."

Davis looks at New York's laws governing second-degree manslaughter -"recklessly" causing the death of another person - and opines that Mr Pantaleo appears "at least" guilty of that charge.

The failure to indict is a shocking example of the criminal justice system's failure to provide oversight of the nation's police, writes, external Leon H Wolf of the RedState blog.

"I understand the vast majority of cops are good at their jobs and conscientious about protecting the civil rights of citizens," he says. "But there are without a doubt bad cops who make bad decisions and when they do so from a position of authority the damage they can do is exponentially worse."

Vox's Amanda Taub writes, external that the bigger scandal is that current legal standards make prosecuting police violence almost impossible.

"The set of situations in which police officers are allowed to use force is narrow in theory but broad in application," she says.

Other commentators wonder whether the results in the Garner case reveal that the recent drive to equip police officers with body cameras will do anything to solve the perception of unaccountable law enforcement.

"What good will body cameras do when an unarmed black man is RECORDED being killed and the officer STILL gets away with it?" tweets, external Fast Company editor JJ McCorvey.

For now the reaction to the Garner decision stands in sharp contrast to the months long debate over the police shooting of Michael Brown in Ferguson, Missouri, which had exposed sharp political and racial divides across the US.

That may not remain the case for long, however. Salon's Joanna Rothkopf was quick to criticise, external conservative commentators for glossing over race and police brutality issues and focusing on the cigarette taxes, external that the New York police were attempting to enforce.

"It's not the officer's fault for using an illegal chokehold on a non-violent asthmatic man," she writes. "It's the tax's fault for existing."

Politics never rests for long.

Reporting by Anthony Zurcher, external

You can follow BBC Trending on Twitter @BBCtrending

All our stories are at bbc.com/trending

More on this story

  • No charges in NY chokehold case

    • Published
      4 December 2014
    Demonstrators rallied against police brutality in memory of Eric Garner in New York on 23 August 2014
  • Protest over New York choke death

    • Published
      24 August 2014
    Demonstrators protest over the death of 43-year-old Eric Garner in New York (23 August 2014)
  • Daughter: 'I was so distraught' Video, 00:01:26Daughter: 'I was so distraught'

    • Published
      3 December 2014
    1:26
    Erica Snipes

Top stories

  • Live. 

    Starmer says Britain must defeat rising antisemitic hatred after two killed in Manchester synagogue attack

    • 31477 viewing31k viewing
  • What we know about Manchester synagogue attack

    • Published
      1 hour ago
  • What footage tells us about Manchester synagogue attack

    • Published
      1 hour ago

More to explore

  • What we know about Manchester synagogue attack

    Worshippers gather near the scene of the attack
  • What footage tells us about Manchester synagogue attack

    Two police officers are seen pointing their weapons at a man lying on the ground who is blurred
  • How Taylor Swift made herself too big to fail

    Side-by-side portraits of Taylor Swift at different times in her career, under a 'BBC InDepth' logo. On the left, she has straight hair and wears a sparkly pink outfit, looking left. On the right, she is younger, has curly hair and wears a black sequined outfit, looking right. The background features a vinyl record design with star decorations.
  • Dame Jane Goodall revolutionised our understanding of our closest primate cousins

    Jane Goodall appears amongs the leaves of the rainforest holding a pair of binoculars.
  • How much time could Diddy spend in prison?

    A sketch in copurt shows Sean "Diddy" Combs wearing glasses and a yellow prison jumpsuit. There is a police officer sketched behind him
  • Should I use olive oil for frying? How to choose the right cooking oil

    A stock photo shows a woman pouring a big bottle of sunflower oil into a deep wok pan on an electric hob with cooking ingredients all around her and her kitchen cabinets and oven in the background.
  • Why BBC sent undercover reporter into a busy London police station

    Rory Bibb, a young white man with dark, curly hair, dressed in the uniform of Metropolitan Police civilian staff, a navy zip-up top with a badge saying "designated detention officer" and royal blue epaulettes. He is standing against a blank white background.
  • Relief and new baby for asylum family of child suffocated in Channel crossing

    A newborn baby is carefully held up by his doting father, with mother in background
  • Why the US government has shut down and what happens now

    File image of the US Capitol building with a blurry sign in the foreground that reads "Stop Trump"
loading elsewhere stories

Most read

  1. 1

    What we know about Manchester synagogue attack

  2. 2

    Mum's anti-chemo views influenced daughter's death

  3. 3

    Say sorry to children for Covid errors, ex-children's commissioner tells ministers

  4. 4

    Heart surgeon's failures contributed to multiple deaths

  5. 5

    Hamas military leader in Gaza objects to ceasefire plan, BBC understands

  6. 6

    Peaky Blinders to return to TV with gang's new era

  7. 7

    Eyewitnesses describe Manchester synagogue attack

  8. 8

    Denmark loses £1.4bn tax fraud claim in UK court case

  9. 9

    Storm Amy upgraded to amber warning

  10. 10

    I'm not resigning, Met Police chief says after BBC investigation

BBC News Services

  • On your mobile
  • On smart speakers
  • Get news alerts
  • Contact BBC News

Best of the BBC

  • A heartfelt comedy exploring adoption and parenthood

    • Attribution
      iPlayer

    Added to Watchlist
    Trying has been added to your iPlayer Watchlist.
    Trying
  • Director Steven Spielberg shares the soundtrack of his life

    • Attribution
      Sounds

    Added to My Sounds
    Desert Island Discs has been added to your My Sounds.
    Desert Island Discs: Steven Spielberg
  • Unravelling the mysteries of the human brain

    • Attribution
      iPlayer

    Added to Watchlist
    Secrets of the Brain has been added to your iPlayer Watchlist.
    Secrets of the Brain
  • Paul Sinha is quizzed on crisps and cricket

    • Attribution
      Sounds

    Added to My Sounds
    Paul Sinha's Perfect Pub Quiz has been added to your My Sounds.
    Paul Sinha's Perfect Pub Quiz
  • Home
  • News
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • iPlayer
  • Sounds
  • Bitesize
  • CBBC
  • CBeebies
  • Food
  • Terms of Use
  • About the BBC
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookies
  • Accessibility Help
  • Parental Guidance
  • Contact the BBC
  • Make an editorial complaint
  • BBC emails for you

Copyright © 2025 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.