BBC Homepage
  • Skip to content
  • Accessibility Help
  • Your account
  • Notifications
  • Home
  • News
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • iPlayer
  • Sounds
  • Bitesize
  • CBBC
  • CBeebies
  • Food
  • More menu
More menu
Search BBC
  • Home
  • News
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • iPlayer
  • Sounds
  • Bitesize
  • CBBC
  • CBeebies
  • Food
Close menu
BBC News
Menu
  • Home
  • InDepth
  • Israel-Gaza war
  • War in Ukraine
  • Climate
  • UK
  • World
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Culture
More
  • Tech
  • Science
  • Health
  • Family & Education
  • In Pictures
  • Newsbeat
  • BBC Verify
  • Disability
  • Trending

Indian worker’s tearful plea to leave Saudi Arabia

  • Published
    19 March 2016
Share page
About sharing
Screen grab of video by Abdul Sattar MakandarImage source, Facebook
BBC Trending
What's popular and why

A video plea by an Indian man has once again prompted discussion about the issue of the working conditions for migrants in Gulf countries - although the facts of the case are heavily disputed.

Abdul Sattar Makandar was hired for a job driving trucks in Saudi Arabia via a recruitment agency in Mumbai. But now two years on, he says he's been denied leave to visit his home in India, and claims the company hasn't always paid him on time.

The company denies the allegations, and the case might have been an unnoticed dispute between employer and employee, had Makandar not taped an emotional video which he sent to an Indian activist, Kundan Srivastava.

After the activist posted it to Facebook, Makandar's tearful plea for help was watched more than one million times.

Under Saudi law, foreign workers can't leave the country without the permission of their employers - just one element of the Gulf system of kafala, which limits the rights of foreign workers, external.

Several recent cases - including the story of a domestic worker who had her arm chopped off - have prompted debate about working conditions for migrant workers in the Gulf.

James Lynch, deputy director for the Middle East and North Africa for Amnesty International, says many workers are fearful of speaking out.

"We have consistently seen migrant workers too scared to speak out because of reprisals from employers, such as refusing to give an exit permit, not paying wages that are due, or cancelling residency permits," Lynch told BBC Trending radio.

line

BBC Trending Radio

More on this story from the BBC World Service here.

line

In Makandar's case, his employer, the Al Suroor United Group, strongly denies his story. They say they he was eligible for leave after two years of service and that he's about six weeks short of that milestone. They also say he's been paid on time and even given a bonus, and that he could resign from his job at any time.

The company also responded by posting photos, taken two years ago, of other employees holding signs praising the group:

This migrant worker's sign thanks the company for helping him receive a mechanical engineering qualification.Image source, Facebook / Al Suroor United Group
Image caption,

This migrant worker's sign thanks the company for helping him receive a mechanical engineering qualification.

Makandar was recruited by Al Suroor through an Indian agency called Discomb Gulf Travels. Discomb's managing director Riyaz Batey told BBC Trending that they had not been aware that Makandar was unhappy until the video appeared online. He said that the driver should have contacted them for help first. But he added that he had bank statements which showed Makandar had been paid on time.

Makandar has been suspended from his job, and the video also seems to have landed him in jail. Earlier in the week he was detained under a Saudi law that forbids misrepresenting facts on social media.

Srivastava, the activist, took down the video and issued an apology after the company threatened legal action. But he has continued to post about the case and is hoping that Makandar will be allowed to leave Saudi Arabia - the worker's current whereabouts are unclear.

The Indian Embassy in Saudi Arabia did not to BBC Trending's request for a comment.

Reporting by Mai Noman and Anisa Subedar

Next story: Brazilians get that sinking feeling as crisis deepens

Brazil as TitanicImage source, Twitter/@paulinhaitu

The political crisis that has engulfed Brazil has prompted a tumultuous response on social media. READ MORE

You can follow BBC Trending on Twitter @BBCtrending, external, and find us on Facebook, external. All our stories are at bbc.com/trending.

Top stories

  • Famine confirmed in Gaza City is 'failure of humanity', UN chief says

    • Published
      1 hour ago
  • Home Office seeks to appeal against court ruling on asylum hotel

    • Published
      27 minutes ago
  • Live. 

    FBI searches home of Trump adviser-turned-critic John Bolton

    • 5785 viewing5.8k viewing

More to explore

  • 'My youngest child doesn't know what fruit tastes like': Gaza residents on famine

    A small crying boy, dirty with mud, holds a bowl up in search of food. Behind him more people are visible also looking for food.
  • The race for the two miles-a-second super weapons that Putin says turn targets to dust

    A treated image of a hypersonic missile North Korea claims to have test-fired
  • Are girls being left behind in school? Experts are sounding the alarm

    Photo shows three girls collecting their GCSE results. They all have long, dark hair and are smiling down at their results papers. One of the girls wears a t-shirt which says 'don't be jealous', one is a wheelchair user and one is wearing glasses.
  • Weekly quiz: Why was a Swedish church moved on giant trailers?

    Workers look on as Kiruna's old wooden church is moved on giant trailers.
  • Why Rugby World Cup 2025 will change game

    • Attribution
      Sport
    Natasha Hunt
  • Billy Connolly says Elton John inspired new artwork

    A photo of Sir Billy sitting next to the artwork. Sir Billy has a full grey beard and grey hair. He has round-rimmed glasses. He wears a patchwork shirt in shades of grey. He is sat in a floral armchair in front of picture on an easel. The picture shows a stylised piano with loads of striped lines in orange and yellow. A stylised performer in a stripy blue suit has one leg on the keyboard. Behind him sits an upturned stool.
  • Flower girls and bridesmaids – the dogs playing a starring role in weddings

    A dog surrounded by bouquets of white, pink and blue flowers, smiling at a camera. The dog is also further surrounded by three women in pink dresses and one woman in a white dress and veil.
  • Sikh owners, Sikh manager - what Morecambe takeover means to community

    • Attribution
      Sport
    Ashvir Singh Johal coaches from the touchline during a Leicester City youth fixture
  • 'Mum's wail is something I'll never unhear'

    Kelly Will and Marina Polito (pictured) remember their brother Daniele 10 years on
loading elsewhere stories

Most read

  1. 1

    British Airways attendant found naked and on drugs in onboard toilet

  2. 2

    UK agrees to pay Kenyans affected by military fire

  3. 3

    Prison conduct and contraband: Four things we learned from Erik Menendez's parole hearing

  4. 4

    Royal Mail and DHL halt some US deliveries over tariffs

  5. 5

    Russia trying to stop meeting on peace and prolong war, says Zelensky

  6. 6

    Are girls being left behind in school? Experts are sounding the alarm

  7. 7

    Brewdog co-founder leaves craft beer giant

  8. 8

    TikTok to lay off hundreds of UK content moderators

  9. 9

    Famine confirmed in Gaza City is 'failure of humanity', UN chief says

  10. 10

    Noel Clarke loses libel case against the Guardian

BBC News Services

  • On your mobile
  • On smart speakers
  • Get news alerts
  • Contact BBC News

Best of the BBC

  • Do estate agents treat customers fairly?

    • Attribution
      iPlayer
    Panorama: Undercover Estate Agent
  • More meddling and slapstick mayhem

    • Attribution
      iPlayer
    Mrs Brown's Boys
  • Freddie Mercury: from iconic shots to private snaps

    • Attribution
      iPlayer
    A Life in Ten Pictures: Freddie Mercury
  • Swedish detective Beck tackles more macabre crimes

    • Attribution
      iPlayer
    Beck
  • Home
  • News
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • iPlayer
  • Sounds
  • Bitesize
  • CBBC
  • CBeebies
  • Food
  • Terms of Use
  • About the BBC
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookies
  • Accessibility Help
  • Parental Guidance
  • Contact the BBC
  • Make an editorial complaint
  • BBC emails for you

Copyright © 2025 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.