YouTube ordered to pay more for music by Europe

Lady Gaga is one artist who has criticised YouTube

Video sites such as YouTube will be forced to pay more to musicians and record companies under plans to reform European copyright laws.

The draft directive will also require publishers and producers to tell performers or authors what profits their works have generated.

The music industry has long criticised YouTube for failing to pay enough for content such as music.

News publishers will also be recognised as rights holders for the first time.

Under the directive, portals such as Google News would be forced to pay newspaper publishers a fee when using small extracts or snippets of news stories.

Carlo Perrone, head of the European Newspaper Publishers' Association, said creating a copyright for news publishers in Europe was a "significant and historic step".

Jean-Claude Juncker, president of the European Commission, said: "I want journalists, publishers and authors to be paid fairly for their work, whether it is made in studios or living rooms, whether it is disseminated offline or online, whether it is published via a copying machine or hyperlinked on the web."

The Commission has not detailed how it would force sites such as YouTube to pay more to artists.

The plans also call for easier access to online content across all EU countries and to reform copyright rules for research and education.

Andrus Ansip, vice-president for the digital single market, said: "Our proposal will ensure that more content will be available, transforming Europe's copyright rules in light of a new digital reality."

The proposals, which are likely to be challenged by lobbyists, must go to the European Parliament and EU states for approval - which could take years.

A Google spokesperson said: "We believe there's a better way. Innovation and partnership - not subsidies and onerous restrictions - are the key to a successful, diverse and sustainable news sector in the EU."

'Value gap'

More than 1,000 artists, including Lady Gaga and Coldplay, signed a letter earlier this year calling on the Commission to take steps to address the "value gap".

It said sites such as YouTube were "unfairly siphoning value away from the music community and its artists and songwriters".

YouTube, which carries videos as well as audio-only content, makes money by selling advertising and then divides profits among rights owners.

Its business model differs from music streaming sites such as Spotify and Apple Music, which pay record companies a small sum each time a song is played.

Craig David thinks YouTube will "line up with everything" in time

The body representing the UK recorded music business, the BPI, welcomed Brussels' recognition for the need for a level playing field for digital music.

Geoff Taylor, BPI chief executive, said it was unfair that platforms such as YouTube are "building huge businesses using music and other content while paying only a fraction of the royalties paid to artists and labels by services such as Spotify and Apple Music".

PRS for Music, which represents the rights of almost 120,000 songwriters, composers and music publishers in the UK, said it welcomed the move to ensure that searchable sites such as YouTube require a license from the rights holders.

"The European Commission's proposed new copyright directive provides the framework for this essential legal clarity," said chief executive Robert Ashcroft.

IFPI, which represents the international recording industry worldwide, said the proposals were a good first step towards better and fairer licensing for content in Europe.

Chief executive Frances Moore said: "Importantly, it confirms that user uploaded content services such as YouTube, which are the largest source of on-demand music, should not be able to operate outside normal licensing rules. However, there is a lot more to do to make this a workable proposal."

UK Music, which represents the British music industry, said this week that YouTube was still not paying artists enough for their music.

UK Music said the Google-owned site was "yet to deliver fair financial returns for rights owners and creators, artists, composers, songwriters and publishers".

The band Two Door Cinema Club said: "I don't think things at the minute are fair. YouTube don't pay a fair royalty."

Google says it has paid the music industry more than $3bn (£2.3bn) since 2007.

However, the Commission's proposals did not go far enough to prevent "geo-blocking" of online content, the European Consumer Organisation, BEUC, said.

'Punish millions'

It also criticised plans to force websites to automatically detect and take down videos that contain parts of copyrighted works.

"This would punish millions of consumers who share a self-made remix of a song, family videos or holiday pictures which contain parts of a music tune or video clip," BEUC said.

The Commission has also proposed an overhaul of EU telecoms rules to ensure much faster internet access across Europe.

It wants schools, universities, hospitals, transport hubs and companies that rely on digital technologies to have extremely fast connectivity in excess of 1 gigabits a second.

All homes - both rural and urban - should have broadband speed of at least 100 megabits a second.

Finally, the Commission calls for all urban areas, as well as major roads and railways, to have 5G wireless mobile data coverage. Each EU country should have 5G in at least one major city by 2020.