Housebuilder Persimmon's profits top £1bn

Profits have topped £1bn for the first time at housebuilder Persimmon, which was caught in a pay row last year and is under scrutiny over its continued involvement in the Help to Buy scheme.

Annual profits jumped 13% to £1.091bn, up from £966m in 2017.

The firm also said its interim chief executive, Dave Jenkinson, would now take on the role permanently.

Mr Jenkinson's predecessor, Jeff Fairburn, left last year following controversy over his £75m pay package.

"We are the first company to make over £1bn profit in this sector," Mr Jenkinson said. "The whole team are very proud."

The results come a day after shares in Persimmon fell 5% because of questions over its continued involvement in the Help to Buy scheme.

The firm sold 7,970 homes under the scheme in 2018, up from 7,682 in 2017.

At the weekend, a source close to Housing Minister James Brokenshire said the minister was "increasingly concerned" by Persimmon's practices, including its use of leasehold contracts, the quality of its buildings and its leadership.

He said this meant its inclusion in the Help to Buy scheme was under review.

Mike Amey, managing director of global investment management firm Pimco, told the BBC that profit per house at Persimmon had trebled since Help To Buy was introduced.

And housing expert Henry Pryor told the BBC: "There is no doubt that Help to Buy has been the crack cocaine of the housing industry. We've all got addicted to it and when we are weaned off it, it is going to be painful."

Analysis:

By Dominic O'Connell, Today programme business presenter

The Persimmon money machine rolls on, profits past the £1bn mark and £2.2bn returned to shareholders in the past seven years, with the promise of more - much more - to come.

Persimmon has been an astonishing success for its investors, and of course its executives, who are benefiting from a giant pay scheme agreed in 2012.

Sometimes, though, you can have too much success, particularly when you are a big beneficiary of a taxpayer-funded housing scheme, in this case Help to Buy.

Jeff Fairburn, the former chief executive, had to fall on his sword after public and investor opinion swung sharply against the size of his remuneration - £75m, although he gave some to charity.

The danger now is that a similar shift in sentiment undermines the company as a whole.

Politicians might decide that £1bn a year in profits, a 30% operating margin and giant dividends to shareholders are evidence the new-build housing market is no longer sufficiently competitive, and has instead turned into an oligopoly, a market carved up between a few big players.

There was a hint of that in weekend reports that Persimmon's participation in Help to Buy was under government scrutiny - a hint strong enough to send the shares down nearly 5%.

If the hint were to turn into reality, the Persimmon money machine would judder to a halt.

• Housing costs: Five surprises explained

• Reality Check: How does the government help first-time buyers?

• Persimmon boss retained £15m in bonus deal

Mr Jenkinson has been with the firm for 22 years and had been interim chief executive since November, following Mr Fairburn's departure.

He said: "2018 has been a year of disciplined high quality growth again for Persimmon Homes.

"We have a lower average selling price than our competitors, but that is a function of our desire to hit all parts of the market."

He added: "It is important for me as the new CEO to acknowledge that we still have work to do in customer care."

Chairman Roger Devlin said: "Persimmon is changing. In his short time as interim CEO, Dave Jenkinson has introduced new approaches to customer satisfaction and colleague engagement, whilst also ensuring that the group delivered another year of growth."

The company's total group revenue for the year increased by 4% to £3.74bn, up from £3.60bn in 2017.

Sophie Lund-Yates, equity analyst at Hargreaves Lansdown, said: "Conditions are about as good as they can be, with low interest rates, record low unemployment and helpful government schemes like Help to Buy all helping people get on the property ladder.

"With Persimmon's participation in the Help to Buy programme under heavy scrutiny, following its former use of controversial leasing fees, and poor quality builds, these conditions have to end at some point."

Looking ahead, the company said in its results statement: "Whilst sales expectations remain subject to a degree of uncertainty at the start of any financial year, the lack of clarity with respect to the UK's exit from the EU is currently creating additional unpredictability."

It added: "We have worked with our suppliers to identify any material supplies which may be exposed to some disruption to availability as a result of Brexit and we are working with them to adopt appropriate mitigating measures."