Banks face threat to licences over Farage bank account row

Ministers are considering putting extra conditions on banking licences after a row over the closure of Brexiteer Nigel Farage's account at Coutts.

It follows reports that lenders could lose their permits if they cut ties with customers because they disagree with their political views.

Mr Farage has accused Coutts of lying about its decision, saying he was "cancelled" by the bank.

Coutts says decisions to close an account "are not taken lightly".

Government sources told the BBC that the possibility of putting conditions on banking permits was being explored, although no decision had been made.

Banks would also be required to explain why an account is being shut, and give a longer notice period, under tougher rules to be brought in.

According to the Times newspaper, licences could be stripped in order to protect customers' right to free speech.

The BBC understands that the Treasury is also seeking clarity on the handling of Mr Farage's accounts from Alison Rose, the boss of NatWest, which owns Coutts.

• Farage launches fresh attack over Coutts bank closure

• Bank account closures probe 'must be fast tracked'

It comes after Mr Farage obtained documents, which have been shared with the Mail newspaper, from minutes of a Coutts meeting where both "commercial" reasons and "reputational risk" associated with his political views are cited as reasons behind terminating his account with them.

The 40-page report mentioned Brexit and his alleged links to Russia.

Banks do have the right to what's known as "commercial independence" to make decisions about their company, and who their clients are.

For example, Coutts very openly advertises that it excludes anyone who is not a millionaire.

Dropping under the wealth threshold could prompt the bank to conduct a wider review of the customer's profile, including reputational and legal risk.

Banking commentator Frances Coppola said that, according to the report, Coutts did not feel Mr Farage's views were the issue, more his public behaviour and how it might reflect on the bank.

"Nigel Farage was very public about his relationship with Coutts. He has also made lots of controversial comments, and when you have a bit of loose cannon like that, they could bring you into disrepute, even though it's not intentional.

"That risk has to be very closely managed because it might come with a financial cost. If the returns on the account do not justify the costs, then the bank will see no point in carrying on the relationship."

'Uncomfortable'

The report stated that Coutts had been happy to carry on banking Mr Farage while he had a mortgage with them, but once he had paid it off they planned to terminate the relationship.

However, Angela Knight, former chief executive of the British Bankers' Association, told the BBC's Today programme she found what had happened to the firmer United Kingdom Independence Party leader "somewhat uncomfortable".

"It is somewhat uncomfortable to see a situation arise where because of somebody's legitimate views, even though you don't agree with them, it somehow has resulted in a service being withdrawn and they are not being told about it."

She added: "In this instance what seems to have happened is nothing was really said to the individual concerned and then when they put in an application [to the bank to see the evidence] they suddenly find that there's a whole series of reasons which seems to centre around what they have said."

On Thursday Mr Farage welcomed reports of a government crackdown, saying closing bank accounts for political reasons could stop people from going into public life.

"Refusal to open [accounts] and closures have happened to several members of my family... Which is perhaps, above all, what has made me angry, really angry and motivated me to [speak out]."

'Shocked'

On Wednesdday Prime Minister Rishi Sunak tweeted that shutting someone's account over their views was "wrong", calling free speech the "cornerstone of our democracy".

Meanwhile, Home Secretary Suella Braverman said elsewhere that the Coutts row "exposes the sinister nature of much of the diversity, equity and inclusion industry".

The BBC had previously reported Mr Farage had fallen below the financial threshold needed for an account at Coutts, citing a source familiar with the move.

The former politician accused the broadcaster of falling for "spin" and restated that he had been targeted for his political views.

He cited the report by the bank's reputational risk committee which states that the Brexiteer's views did not "align with our values".

"Apparently, I'm a risk to them. I have virtually no links of any kind to Russia whatsoever. This is political. There is no other way of looking at it," he said.

He later told BBC Newsnight he was "literally shocked" when he saw the report, which he described as a "personal hit job". "This bank is behaving now like a political campaigning organisation," he said.

Coutts has said it has offered Mr Farage an alternative account at its sister bank, NatWest and the offer still stands.

Anyone concerned that they have not been treated fairly by their bank can appeal to the Financial Ombudsman Service.

City regulator the Financial Conduct Authority is also talking to NatWest about the handling of Mr Farage's accounts, its boss told MPs on Wednesday.

Nikhil Rathi said that current rules made clear banks should not discriminate on the basis of political views.

Sign up for our morning newsletter and get BBC News in your inbox.