How can schools nationwide mimic London's improvement?
- Published
Newsnight's Sanchia Berg reports on why schools in London, some in under-privileged areas, where many pupils do not speak English as a first language, are out performing those outside the capital.
Sir Michael Wilshaw, Chief Inspector of Schools in England and head of education watchdog Ofsted, has told BBC Newsnight that schools and local authorities up and down the country should learn from London and "draw a line" below underperformance.
He said they should follow the example of London Challenge, the now defunct Labour policy which improved London schools, and get outstanding schools and heads working very closely with the less successful.
Little Ilford pupils benefit from Study Plus classes and more interaction between parents and teachers
For decades, London secondary schools had some of the worst exam results in the country.
Sir Michael was a teacher in the capital in the 1970-90s. He told BBC Newsnight that if someone had told him then that London would be doing much better than the rest of England, he would not have believed it.
He said the improvement was down to London Challenge, external - there was the "political will" to make schools better, adding that London Challenge bypassed local authorities.
Little Ilford School in Newham is one school where results have improved dramatically over the last 15 years.
In 1997, just 16% of its students got five GCSES at grades A-C, the league table measure then. Last year, 71% passed at least 5 GCSES at grades A*-C including English and Maths.
Supporting aspiration
Over half of the school's pupils are eligible for free school meals, and 88% speak English as an additional language.
Temoore Zulfiqar has been the opportunity to visit Oxford and Cambridge universities several times
According to the acting headteacher, Katy Episcopo, that change is down to improved teaching, and certain specific initiatives.
They have Study Plus classes, which help students who are behind in reading and writing, and that has had a significant impact. They work closely with pupils' parents. They build confidence and they support aspiration.
Although funding for London Challenge was cut two years ago, results have kept rising. It seems the improvement has developed its own momentum.
Not only are more students passing GCSEs, but more are achieving higher grades too. Temoore Zulfiqar, who is aged 16, has already taken three GCSEs, in maths and science. He got two A* grades and one A.
He wants to go to Oxford or Cambridge and thanks to his school, he has already visited both several times.
Regions falling behind
Students at Little Ilford see no bar to their ambitions. Tanvir, who is 15 years old, told me he wanted to be Britain's first Muslim prime minister.
Barnsley pupils praised the atmosphere of learning in the Newham school they visited
As London has rapidly improved, some other authorities have not kept pace. Barnsley in South Yorkshire has some of the worst GCSE results in England.
Simon Barber, headteacher of the brand-new Holy Trinity school, is determined to improve standards. Although almost all his pupils speak English as a first language, and only 16% were eligible for free school meals last year, 53% of pupils got five GCSES at grades A* to C, including English and maths, last year.
He told me he was keen to learn from other schools, especially those in London. He took a group of children to Newham last summer, to see the London sights, and to visit another school.
Some of the pupils who had gone on the visit told me the atmosphere was different at the Newham school - the children were more focused on learning.
"If you didn't look out the window, you'd never know it was a rough area," one young teenager told me. "The children looked so smart and ready to learn."
Legacy of unemployment
Sir Michael Wilshaw, Chief Inspector of Schools in England: 'What makes the difference, is the level of expectation of the school''
Mr Barber told me it was hard to overcome Barnsley's industrial past. The town was a mining community, but now unemployment is high, and he said it was hard to raise aspiration.
Sir Michael Wilshaw told BBC Newsnight that comparing Barnsley and Newham shows that "children are children, are children - what makes the difference is the culture of the school".
Ofsted is now turning its attention to local authorities. If it finds them failing, their role could be taken over by another body, possibly another local authority, or an academy chain.