Summary

  • Eluned Morgan is quizzed by opposition party leaders and other MSs during First Minister's Questions.

  1. Hwyl fawrpublished at 14:18 British Summer Time 20 May

    Eluned Morgan’s twenty-eighth session as first minister comes to a close.

    Eluned MorganImage source, Senedd Cymru
    Image caption,

    Eluned Morgan

  2. Illegal high-speed electric bikespublished at 14:16 British Summer Time 20 May

    Labour's Jenny Rathbone asks "what work is the Welsh government doing with relevant stakeholders to crack down on illegal high-speed electric bikes?"

    Eluned Morgan replies "we recognise the danger illegal high-speed e-bikes pose to vulnerable road users and riders, and are committed to keeping public spaces safe. While road traffic law is not devolved, we are working with road safety partners and the active travel board to find effective solutions."

    Jenny Rathbone adds, "the police have told us that they are occasionally doing raids and stopping these very dangerous vehicles and confiscating them, but more needs to be done. These are bikes that have been souped up to travel at much greater speeds than for 20 mph. I see them myself when I am travelling along the road on a bike. So, when they are seized, I want to know what happens to them. In line with reduce, reuse, recycle, what discussions may you have had with the police and local authorities to see if these bikes could be reverted to their original purpose, which is to enable vulnerable people who may have difficulty using a pedal bike to be able to get around, particularly travelling up hills?"

    The first minister replies, "we really welcome initiatives like the one introduced by South Wales Police and their partners, in which they work together to enforce against anti-social illegal riding, and they deliver training and awareness courses at the same time. So, we want to make sure we work with them and make sure that illegal e-bikes that pose those risks are tackled, and that we work with partners to make sure that, where possible, we can revert them to the initial condition that they were in."

    Jenny RathboneImage source, Senedd Cymru
    Image caption,

    Jenny Rathbone

  3. 'Anguish' following change in the issuing of death certificatespublished at 14:13 British Summer Time 20 May

    Llyr Gruffydd, Plaid Cymru MS for north Wales, asks the first minister to "outline how the recent statutory change in the issuing of death certificates has impacted the Welsh NHS".

    He warns that the new legislation that requires senior doctors in England and Wales to independently scrutinise every death is leading to long and unacceptable delays for some families to receive a death certificate for a family member before bodies can be released for funeral arrangements.

    He says "it's sometimes six, seven or up to eight weeks, from some of the cases that I've seen, after the person has passed away. Now, that, of course, leads to increased anguish, where families can't proceed with the financial, the legal or the practical arrangements that need to be put in place, the emotional toll is significant as well, and, of course, it's especially pertinent for faith communities for whom a quick burial is of the utmost importance."

    Eluned Morgan replies "I absolutely sympathise. When you've gone through a loss like that, and then you have to wait, I think that is really, really difficult for families. I think it's probably worth reminding people why this is happening. This is happening because the changes as a result of many high-profile reviews, including the Shipman inquiry, meant that people - and after that big, long inquiry - said that you need additional safeguards to the death certification process. So, there is a little bit of bedding in. It has taken longer than we've hoped. The latest median time from death to registration has remained stable now at 11 days, down from 14. I still think it's too long, but it's definitely coming down. And what we do have is a strategic oversight group that is moving things on, and are making changes, to try and see if we can reduce that further."

    The death certification reforms came into effect on 9 September 2024, , externaland are designed to provide better safeguards against medical negligence.

    Under the new system, which was brought about partly in response to Harold Shipman's murders, , externalGPs no longer issue death certificates independently.

    After a GP completes a medical certificate of cause of death (MCCD), an independent medical examiner reviews it.

    Once approved, the certificate is sent to the registrar, who officially records the death.

    The process means GPs have to give access to a patient's records in order for the medical examiner to decide if they agree with the MCCD.

    Llyr GruffyddImage source, Senedd Cymru
    Image caption,

    Llyr Gruffydd

  4. Impact of immigration white paper on social care?published at 13:57 British Summer Time 20 May

    Plaid Cymru MS Cefin Campbell asks "what assessment has the Welsh government made of the impact of the UK government's immigration white paper on social care in Mid and West Wales?"

    He says the immigration plan "fails to recognise the contribution that migrant workers and overseas students make to our economy, and represents a further lurch to the right from a prime minister determined to dance to Nigel Farage’s tune".

    Eluned Morgan says the Welsh government is analysing the immigration white paper and its impact on all sectors, including social care.

    She adds, "our overseas workers in our social care sector are appreciated, and they do make a great contribution, and a significant contribution, to our workforce. They bring diversity, they bring experience, they bring sympathy and skills into our sector".

    She says that in Hywel Dda health board, one in every 10 of the workforce comes from overseas, but almost 50 per cent of dentists and GPs come from overseas.

    The white paper proposes care workers on sponsored visas would need to remain in the UK for 10 years before gaining the right to live and work here indefinitely - double the current requirement of five years.

    The proposal was announced in a speech by the prime minister last week, where he warned the UK risks becoming an "island of strangers".

    Sir Keir Starmer did not set a precise target, but the Home Office estimated the new policies could lead to a 100,000 drop in immigration per year by 2029.

    According to Social Care Cymru, around 88,000 people work in Wales' care sector, with approximately 15% to 20% coming from overseas.

    Cefin CampbellImage source, Senedd Cymru
    Image caption,

    Cefin Campbell

  5. 'Labour is botching its response to the damage of Brexit'published at 13:52 British Summer Time 20 May

    Rhun ap IorwerthImage source, Senedd Cymru
    Image caption,

    Rhun ap Iorwerth

    On the new deal between the UK and the EU, Plaid Cymru leader Rhun ap Iorwerth says "I'm pleased that there is some acceptance now of the harm of Brexit, but it's not bold enough in its response to that reality".

    He says "with its so-called 'partnership in power' and promise of two Labour governments working together in the interest of the people of Wales, I would have expected the first minister to have been sighted on the deal in advance and to have been given an opportunity to influence the prime minister, especially given that parts of the deal involved areas of devolved responsibility. But, in yet another signal that Wales's voice matters little to UK Labour, the first minister has admitted, I heard her myself, she was again sidelined, including on those aspects of the deal that fall under the jurisdiction of this Senedd."

    He asks, "why does she continue to allow Keir Starmer to treat the Welsh government, this institution and the people of Wales with such contempt?"

    Eluned Morgan replies, "It's really important for us to recognise that this is a good deal for Wales, and the priorities that we set out, that we've worked up a long time ago, that we've worked through with relevant departments of government in Whitehall, have actually been taken on board. If you look at what's happened in relation to SPS: bringing down export barriers, making sure that those defence opportunities come our way, making sure that the issues surrounding steel were considered and making sure that the youth exchange and energy issues were addressed, those were things that were all on our list of things that we wanted to see, and I am delighted to see that they've been respected. The fact is, we weren't there at the final signing, no, because we are a part of the United Kingdom, and they're the lead nation. You may not like that, as a nationalist, but I am keen to remain a part of the United Kingdom, and that's the way it works."

    SPS is Whitehall speak for sanitary and phytosanitary and translates to animal and food rules.

    Describing herself as a "euro-enthusiast," Eluned Morgan says she was "gutted" that the UK left the EU, but wanted "as close as possible a deal with the European Union in order for our country and our nation to thrive".

    Rhun ap Iorwerth accuses her of wavering from her belief that Wales would benefit from membership of the single market and the custom union.

    "We have a first minister who says she's a euro-enthusiast, but that's in words only," he says.

    Welsh and EU flagsImage source, Getty Images
  6. 'Dreadful' deal between UK and EUpublished at 13:44 British Summer Time 20 May

    Darren MillarImage source, Senedd Cymru
    Image caption,

    Darren Millar

    Fresh from his party's conference in Llangollen, Darren Millar, leader of the Welsh Conservatives in the Senedd, raises the topic of the new deal struck between the UK and the EU.

    He says "let's be clear about what this deal means: free movement back, payments to the EU back, EU rules back, our fishing industry here in Wales betrayed, an unacceptable mobility scheme, billions of taxpayers' money going back to Brussels, being forced to accept EU rules and decisions from the European court, and European fishing boats in Welsh waters, in British waters, for at least the next 12 years. First Minister, you've got a responsibility to stand up for Wales and represent us. Why on earth have you welcomed this absolutely dreadful deal?"

    Eluned Morgan replies that the "Tories botched Brexit".

    She elaborates, "you promised the people of Wales that they would be better off as a result of Brexit. You said the NHS would be getting more money as a result of Brexit. The people of Wales have had their eyes opened and they've realised that they were told untruths in relation to what they were promised at the Brexit referendum. The fact is that what we will see now is much better opportunities for jobs in this country because people will be able to export to the EU for the first time without that red tape that occurred before. We have seen a £700 million drop in exports to the EU since Brexit. That was your group that promoted that, and that really means real jobs affecting real people in our communities. I am proud that we are moving ahead and that we have got lots of very significant things that will benefit Wales as a result of the third trade deal that has been made within two weeks by the UK government."

    British control over its fishing waters was a big issue in the Brexit campaignImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    British control over its fishing waters was a big issue in the Brexit campaign

  7. Voter participation in the Senedd electionpublished at 13:36 British Summer Time 20 May

    Janet Finch-SaundersImage source, Senedd Cymru
    Image caption,

    Janet Finch-Saunders

    Conservative Janet Finch-Saunders asks "what is the Welsh government doing to increase voter participation in the Senedd election in May 2026?"

    She points out that fewer than 50% of voters have cast their ballot in each of the Assembly or Senedd elections so far, with the next in May 2026.

    Eluned Morgan replies, "we all share an interest in encouraging people to understand their rights and to vote. We're working with key partners to promote democratic engagement, and this Friday is the deadline for the next round of our democratic engagement grant, which is funding innovative work to promote participation."

    The 46% turnout in the first 1999 Assembly election was described at the time as a “huge deficit”.

    In 2021 the turnout was 47%.

    Polling stationImage source, Getty Images
  8. Sex education in schoolspublished at 13:34 British Summer Time 20 May

    Natasha AsgharImage source, Senedd Cymru
    Image caption,

    Natasha Asghar

    Llywydd Elin Jones conducts a ballot to determine the names of members who may table questions to the first minister.

    Conservative Natasha Asghar raises the topic of the provision of sex education in schools.

    She refers to "Bridgend County Borough Council’s quite horrific stance on sexual choking, and how it is indeed taught in schools".

    The council created a PowerPoint presentation that appeared to endorse strangulation during sex that was intended to be used in schools.

    The slides included the sentence: "It is never OK to start choking someone without asking them first."

    Bridgend county council have said it was part of a "draft version", never shown to children and the slides were dropped following feedback from professionals.

    Natasha Asghar asks "do you agree with me today that this is wholly unacceptable as a saga, and has been a colossal waste of time and money, and that efforts should be better spent on tackling important issues within our schools, like the proliferation of pornography amongst young people instead?"

    First Minister Eluned Morgan replies "I agree with you: there is absolutely no place for that kind of instruction within our schools. And I want to be absolutely clear that any materials condoning, or being seen to condone any form of harmful sexual behaviour, including non-fatal strangulation, are completely unacceptable in any school."

    Bridgend county council
    Image caption,

    Bridgend county council commissioned the school resource but said the slide was removed at a draft stage and never shown to children

  9. Croesopublished at 13:00 British Summer Time 20 May

    Hello and welcome to our live coverage of Eluned Morgan’s twenty-eighth session of First Minister's Questions.

    The Siambr (Senedd chamber) has closed for renovations until March 2026, as work is underway on altering it to accommodate the 96 Members who will be chosen in the next Senedd election in May 2026.

    So the 60 MSs are meeting in Siambr Hywel, the original debating chamber that housed the then National Assembly for Wales from 1999 to 2006.

    The meeting is held in a hybrid format, with some members in Siambr Hywel and others joining by video-conference.

    You can click on the play button above to watch the proceedings from 1.30pm.

    Tŷ Hywel
    Image caption,

    Tŷ Hywel, next to the Senedd building in Cardiff Bay, is rented by the Senedd Commission