Why plastic recycling is so confusing

18 December 2018

By Wesley Stephenson

Data journalist

Most people are trying their best to recycle plastic - but the many different ways in which recycling is collected by councils across the UK has left them confused over what can be recycled and what can't.

New plans on how plastic is recycled in England are being put forward by the government. In the rest of the UK, the strategy for recycling is a devolved issue.

Map showing how different councils collect different types of plastic packaging. Tonbridge and Malling, and Rotherham collect none at all.

Each council collects its plastic recycling differently. BBC analysis shows there are 39 different sets of rules for what can be put in plastic recycling collections:

Most collect bottles
Others collect pots, tubs and trays
Some collect a much wider range

Around the UK, all four nations are hoping to improve their recycling rates. The review sticks to the aim that 50% of waste will be recycled by 2020 and aims to recycle three quarters of plastic packaging by 2035.

Scotland has a target to recycle 70% of waste by 2025, as does Wales. Northern Ireland has a proposal that 60% of municipal waste is recycled by 2020.

99% of households have bottles collected from the doorstep. 75% for pots tubs and trays. Only a fifth of households can put black plastic trays in their recycling. Only 18% can put carrier bags in their recycling. 10% cling film and only 1% can put expanded polystyrene packaging.

Waste plastic is collected in different ways too:

Some local authorities collect all their recycling in one bin
Others ask households to separate their plastics from the rest of their recycling

Councils also employ many different companies to collect and sort their plastics.

And having different recycling schemes in different areas - for example, in some areas you can recycle margarine tubs and in other areas you cannot - makes labelling difficult.

47 percent of people polled said they disagreed at home about what plastic should go in the recycling bin

Most people in Britain regularly recycle plastic but almost half have had disagreements at home about what type they can put in which bin, a ComRes poll for the BBC suggests.

And more than a quarter have these disagreements at least once a month.

How is the government proposing to tackle plastic recycling?

Tackle the current postcode recycling lottery under which different materials are recyclable in different areas
Introduce consistent labelling on packaging so consumers know what they can recycle
Make the firms that produce materials responsible for the cost of disposing of those items
Encourage manufacturers to design products that last longer and increase the levels of repair and re-use
Crack down on waste crime by introducing electronic tracking of waste shipments
Introduce a tax on plastic packaging made of less than 30% recycled plastic
Ban plastic packaging where an alternative material could be used
Improve the quality of plastic being exported

Contamination is a common problem. Dirty plastic, general waste mixed with recycling and recycling contaminated by other recycling can all cause problems.

Plastic can often become too contaminated for recycling and have to be sent to landfill or incinerated instead. This happens for several reasons:

People are confused about what goes in which bin
People are not always very careful about what they put in
The plastic is contaminated with food waste
In areas where all recycling is collected in one bin, one type of waste can contaminate another

There are seven different types of plastic, PET, HDPE, PVC, LDPE, PP, PS and the rest are put in an other category

Bottles are mainly made of PET and HDPE and these are easy to collect and recycle
Most trays are made from polypropylene and this is pretty easy to recycle too but not all councils have access to the right facilities
LDPE, used to make some carrier bags and cling film, is easy to process but more difficult to sort and can often be contaminated with food
Polystyrene, used to make some yoghurt pots and plastic cutlery, is not widely recycled
PVC makes up small amount of packaging but can contaminate other plastic recycling
Biscuit wrappers and meat trays can be made from a mixture of many different types of plastic, making them the most difficult type of packaging to recycle

Some types of plastic like natural HDPE (£375 per tonne) are worth much more than mixed plastic and coloured PET (both £30 per tonne)

All plastic can be recycled - but it is not always economical to do so.

Bottles attract the best prices, especially clear ones, which is why almost all councils recycle them
Coloured plastic is less desirable because the colour cannot be removed, restricting its reuse
Polystyrene is almost never recycled because there is no market for it

Most bottles will be sent for reprocessing in this country.

But plastic that is less valuable - about two-thirds collected for recycling - goes overseas and this figure has been rising.

Earlier this year, the National Audit Office reported the plastic sent abroad could be highly contaminated, meaning it may not be reprocessed and could end up in landfill or contributing to pollution.

The price of plastics sent for export has gone negative in some case. Particularly since China banned waste plastic imports.

Some countries are refusing to take any more of our waste.

China, Malaysia, and Vietnam have banned waste imports
Thailand will introduce a ban in 2021

These bans are having an effect on the prices paid for waste plastic.

And this year the prices of the more contaminated plastics have fallen below zero, meaning companies are now expecting to be paid to take them away.

Design: Debie Loizou. Development: Eleanor Keane.

What can be recycled in your area?