Women's suffrage: 10 reasons why men opposed votes for women

  • Published
English suffragettes celebrating in streets of London

A statue marking the life of suffragist Millicent Fawcett was unveiled in London this week.

This hugely influential feminist campaigned for the right to vote, which was granted to women over the age of 30 a century ago in 1918.

But even as late as 1917 - just months before the bill was passed - powerful men in Parliament were trying to stop votes for women.

Here are some of their arguments, according to House of Commons records.

Grey line
Emmeline Pankhurst being arrested, 1910Image source, PA

Sir James Grant, MP for Whitehaven

"Men have the vote and the power at the present moment; I say for Heaven's sake let us keep it.

"We are controlled and worried enough by women at the present time, and I have heard no reason why we should alter the present state of affairs."

Grey line
A suffragette selling a copy of 'The Suffragette' to another woman, 1910.Image source, Getty Images

Rowland Hunt, MP for Ludlow

"There are obvious disadvantages about having women in Parliament. I do not know what is going to be done about their hats.

"How is a poor little man to get on with a couple of women wearing enormous hats in front of him?"

Grey line
A protest march by women suffragettes in London with police in attendance. The banner held by the leading women reads '1st Woman Suffragist Arrested in London'.Image source, Getty Images

Frederick Banbury, MP for City of London

"Women are likely to be affected by gusts and waves of sentiment.

"Their emotional temperament makes them so liable to it. But those are not the people best fitted in this practical world either to sit in this House... or to be entrusted with the immense power which this bill gives them."

Grey line
A crowd in Hyde Park at a suffragette meeting, circa 1910.Image source, Getty Images

Sir Charles Hobhouse, MP for Bristol East and Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster

"You have at the present moment certain statistics which show that both the birth and marriage rate are decreasing.

"Can you adopt at this time a policy which might mean an immense destruction of the population of the country which it is essential should not only be retained, but increased."

Grey line
A woman speaking from a platform to a densely packed crowd - 'The Suffragettes busy at Portsmouth. Miss Douglas Smith.Image source, Getty Images

Sir Charles Henry, MP for Wellington

"One of the greatest features in connection with this country is the responsibility of men towards women, and I would view with the greatest apprehension any step which would tend to relieve men of that responsibility."

Grey line
English suffragette Estelle Sylvia Pankhurst (1882 - 1960) stands on a platform to paint the front of the Women's Social Defence League premises in Bow Road, East London, 11 October 1912.Image source, Getty Images

Sir John Rees, MP for Nottingham East

"Women are tremendously accessible, extraordinarily impressionable, noted for the adoption of any new thing, and for the easy acceptance of other people's views.

"Are those qualities which fit women to rule over the home and foreign affairs of a mighty empire?"

Suffragette Sylvia Pankhurst in a Polling Booth in 1910.Image source, PA
Grey line

Godfrey Collins, MP for Greenock

"Intuition is far more largely developed in women than in men, but instinct and intuition, although good guides, are not the best masters so far as Parliament is concerned.

"Parliament exists for the very purpose of opposing feelings, fancies, and inclinations by reason."

Grey line

John Henderson, MP for Aberdeenshire Western

"I have read their writings, and in one paper... a moderate publication, I saw that the Prime Minister was violently described as an old fossil.

"What can you say of people who exhibit such a want of judgment, and such a lack of perception of actual facts?"

Grey line
A woman peers through a shattered window the day after a bomb attack by suffragettes on nearby Holloway prison, 19 December 1913.Image source, Getty Images

Arthur Beck, MP for Saffron Walden

"I daresay that the idealism of the feminine mind and its deadly logic which we have all experienced in private life are qualities superior to those of men, but I do say that in governing a great country and in considering the problems which we have to consider every day in this House such qualities are not valuable, but destructive."

Grey line
The English suffragette Christabel Harriette Pankhurst, (1880 - 1958), later Dame Christabel, who with her mother Emmeline founded the Women's Social and Political Union in 1903.Image source, Getty Images

John Henderson, MP for Aberdeenshire Western

"This is a commercial and industrial country. But it could hardly be hoped that women could govern and manage our commerce and industry.

"If we were to have women in this House they would be legislating for these commercial industries of the management of which they know nothing."

Grey line