Surrey shop in racism row over tobacco poster

  • Published
Poster
Image caption,

The poster is on display behind the till at Farrants in Cobham, Surrey

A shop is facing calls to remove a poster showing "broken black men" on a tobacco plantation.

In a video shared on social media, Misan Harriman said the signage behind the counter at Farrants in Cobham, Surrey, was "triggering and racist".

"There is no conceivable reason it should be there," he said.

The shop said the image was displayed to "honour, respect and recognise" those involved in the development of Havana cigars.

Farrants sells a selection of confectionary, greetings cards, newspapers and toys, as well as hosting its own tobacco room, which offers cigars and tobacco.

The image appears to show black people working on a tobacco plantation overseen by white men, which the store said was taken at Pinar del Rio plantation in Cuba in 1907 - 21 years after the abolishment of slavery in the country.

Image caption,

A poster next to the image explains why the shop chose to display the picture

Mr Harriman, the chairman of London's Southbank Centre and a photographer who has taken portraits of the Duke and Duchess of Sussex, said he was shopping for children's toys when he saw the image.

"There is a massive picture that is pride of place at the point of payment. It's an image of black men, broken black men, at a tobacco plantation with their overseers next to them. I kid you not," he said.

"This is in a family store. This imagery is massively triggering and racist. I'm so thankful I wasn't with my girls.

"How on earth could anyone have shopped there and found that image acceptable. This is exhausting and damaging to many people."

This Twitter post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.View original content on Twitter
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
Skip twitter post by Misan Harriman

Allow Twitter content?

This article contains content provided by Twitter. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. You may want to read Twitter’s cookie policy, external and privacy policy, external before accepting. To view this content choose ‘accept and continue’.

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
End of twitter post by Misan Harriman

Former Chelsea footballer and current assistant coach for the England men's national team Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink had complained in 2020 about the same image.

Mr Hasselbaink said on Instagram that he had contacted Farrants' owner David Worsfold three years ago and was told the store would "replace" the image.

"As a family we refuse to go into this shop until this painful image is removed," he said.

Image caption,

The store said the image was taken in Cuba in 1907 - 21 years after the country abolished slavery

A statement displayed next to the image in the shop said: "This image was selected as the main display in our store to honour, respect and recognise the ground-breaking work undertaken by all those involved in the development of the iconic Havana cigars available in our tobacco room today.

"Unlike other crop harvesting industries, the tobacco plantation owners of Cuba refused to use slave labour, insisting instead on employing free men."

However, in another video on social media, Mr Harriman said that it was irrelevant if the image actually displayed indentured servants or slaves.

"Indentured servitude happened for decades after any kind of emancipation or end of slavery," he said.

"Many history books have covered it and the power dynamic of those two white men who dressed very cleanly, look very comfortable, next to the broken, soulless, black men that are actually working that plantation.

"The optics, that dynamic, that power dynamic, is there clear as day."

A representative of Farrants said they would not be commenting.

Follow BBC South East on Facebook, external, on Twitter, external, and on Instagram, external. Send your story ideas to southeasttoday@bbc.co.uk

Related Topics