Starplan: Woman awarded £19k for Christmas party harassment

A woman who said she was left feeling unsafe in the workplace after being sexually harassed at a Christmas party has been awarded nearly £19,000.

Shirley Lyons claimed a colleague from Starplan had touched her bottom, hugged her from behind without her consent and made comments about her breasts.

An employment tribunal said that amounted to unlawful sexual harassment.

Ms Lyons worked as a designer and sales consultant for the furniture company in Portadown, County Armagh.

The company is one of the biggest bedroom and kitchen design companies in Northern Ireland and also has branches in England.

Ms Lyons told BBC News NI that she was "still in bewilderment" and "totally disgusted" by her colleague's behaviour.

"I made it very clear before I left the restaurant that I was not happy, I was really angry," she said.

Shirley Lyons was the only female Starplan employee at the Christmas party in 2017

Starplan told BBC News NI that it regretted "any distress caused to Ms Lyons".

"Starplan vehemently opposes any form of harassment," it said.

'Company failed to protect me'

After complaining about the incident, she said she was victimised by some colleagues and that her employer failed to protect her.

"My workplace no longer felt safe for me and I felt physically sick going into work in the mornings," she said.

"I stood up to behaviour that shouldn't be happening in any workplace.

"My manager and my employer totally failed to protect me both from the harassment and from being victimised afterwards.

"I had no option but to resign."

Shirley Lyons worked at the Portadown branch of Starplan

Ms Lyons, 60, was the only female employee, along with six male employees from the Portadown and Dungannon showrooms, to attend the company's Christmas party in December 2017.

She said she had been "surprised and upset" by her colleague's behaviour at the party, which also included a suggestion that they might have an affair.

She subsequently complained to her line manager and a grievance investigation was carried out.

'I'll stand my ground and fight this'

Ms Lyons later raised allegations of victimisation against three of her colleagues, claiming she was being ignored, excluded, threatened and subjected to intimidating and abusive language and behaviour after making her initial complaint.

"I was threatened - I was totally isolated by the other ones," Ms Lyons told BBC News NI.

"At times I thought it was so hopeless - I thought: 'What on earth?'

"But my strength came from I knew exactly what happened.

"I lived it, I experienced it and that was the biggest thing for me - I could tell the truth and I would be standing by that.

"I thought if this is the treatment they're going to give me I'll stand my ground, I will fight this."

Ms Lyons's complaints of sexual harassment and victimisation were partially upheld by the employment tribunal.

The tribunal panel found her claim of unfair dismissal was well founded, while other lesser claims were not upheld.

Employers must ensure staff attending work parties are safe, says Geraldine McGahey of the Equality Commission

Ms Lyons, who waived her right to anonymity in the proceedings, was awarded £18,857.18 in compensation.

The tribunal also found that Starplan had not put in place "any guidelines or instruction for standards of behaviour and the consumption of alcohol for attendees" at the Christmas party and that "the most senior person present was not formally delegated responsibility for supervising".

The Equality Commission, which supported Ms Lyons, said her case highlighted important lessons for employers.

Chief commissioner Geraldine McGahey said work social events were an extension of the workplace.

She added that the employer should have taken action to prevent victimisation by colleagues after it became known that Ms Lyons had formally lodged a grievance with the company.

"Work parties and outings can be an important element of reward, recognition and team building," she said.

"But like any other area of work, employers must ensure everyone attending is safe and their dignity is respected.

"If that doesn't happen and staff have cause to complain they must be protected from victimisation."

Most employers realise that behaviour by their staff at work parties "reflects back on the reputation of the organisation", said Ms McGahey.

"So it's really important that employers do step up to the plate and be proactive in these situations," she said.

Starplan said it acknowledged that the case "draws attention to key learnings and responsibilities for every employer in relation to staff gatherings".