So long, Tom

  • Published

So farewell then, Tom McNally.

The decision of the avuncular Lib Dem Lord to stand down as deputy leader of the House and leader of his party there, may seem a minor political footnote, but it matters.

Since Tony Blair swept away the Lords' built-in Conservative majority of hereditary peers, managing the upper house has, almost unnoticed, become increasingly difficult.

Even now, I get the impression that many Commons-based ministers don't quite grasp that they do not have an automatic majority in the Lords - despite the hundreds of defeats they have inflicted on the Blair, Brown and Cameron governments.

Almost no-one appreciated at the time quite what a blow the untimely death of the then Leader of the Lords, Lord Williams of Mostyn was to the last Labour government; his combination of charm, wit and intellect, plus strong tactical nous was irreplaceable.

Without him, the government was defeated more often, and forced to make concessions to avert defeat, more often.

Lord McNally, a gnarled political professional, has some of the same qualities.

He was case-hardened in Jim Callaghan's Downing Street, where he served as political secretary during the convulsions of the winter of discontent, after which he was pretty unimpressed by the normal run of political crises.

He could make the House laugh, hailing the first Lord Speaker, Lady Hayman as "the Mary Poppins of the House of Lords" and noting, in his tribute to Lady Thatcher, that… "If one considers the number of people whom she sacked, promoted, defeated or berated, they must make up a goodly number of those present in the House today.…not only does this House know where the bodies are buried but some of the bodies are present here."

But he hasn't always been good humoured; in the debates on the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill he became increasingly tetchy, under sustained goading from Labour's Lord Bach.

Which Wallace?

When he celebrated his 70th birthday recently, he told colleagues he was planning to give up the leadership in the near future. So who will replace him?

One view is that the Leader also has to be a government minister, which effectively narrows the field to Wallace, (Lord Wallace of Tankerness) the advocate general for Scotland, and former deputy first minister in the Scottish government, in coalition with Labour.

Another Wallace, the Foreign Office whip William Wallace (Lord Wallace of Saltaire) might be a possible contender.

The government's Deputy Chief Whip, Lord Newby, who is returning officer for any leadership election, looks unlikely to stand, but any number of backbench peers might at least ponder having a go.

We'll soon find out; the closing date for nominations will be October 15th and the election will be held on October 22nd, unless the new leader is returned unopposed.

Meanwhile, Lord McNally has not announced that he is leaving his post as a justice minister - on the other hand, there is talk of a Government reshuffle on Monday.

Lord McNally probably got on with the previous justice secretary, Ken Clarke, like a house on fire, but may have found the latest secretary of state, Chris Grayling, a little less sympathetic.