Saudi Arabia: Johnson says he raised human rights in energy talks
- Published
Prime Minister Boris Johnson is one of the few western leaders to visit Saudi Arabia since the murder of journalist Jamal Khashoggi
Prime Minister Boris Johnson has said he raised human rights when meeting Gulf leaders for talks about ending reliance on Russian oil and gas after the invasion of Ukraine.
He discussed energy security and other issues in Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates on Wednesday.
He said a global coalition was needed "to deal with the new reality we face".
But critics have expressed concerns about the human rights records of the countries.
Last weekend, Saudi Arabia carried out a mass execution of 81 men in one day, and its Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman has been implicated in the murder of Washington Post journalist Jamal Khashoggi in 2018.
On Wednesday, Saudi news agency SPA announced three further executions, in what the Reprieve group described as a "provocative act" designed to "flaunt the Crown Prince's power".
Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer said "going cap in hand from dictator to dictator is not an energy strategy".
Hatice Cengiz, the fiancee of Mr Khashoggi, told the BBC Mr Johnson should not be "doing deals" with Crown Prince Salman unless he insisted "on the truth and justice for Jamal's murder".
Labour deputy leader Angela Rayner told MPs Mr Johnson was on "a begging mission to the Saudi prince" after failing to invest in home-grown energy.
But Mr Johnson said if western countries wanted to "avoid being blackmailed" by Russia's President Vladimir Putin, they needed to move away from using his country's fossil fuels and explore other partnerships.
In the Saudi capital, Riyadh, Mr Johnson told the BBC he raised human rights and "what we can do to stabilise oil prices" in his meeting with Crown Prince Salman.
When asked if the recent executions were discussed, Mr Johnson said "in spite of the news that you've referred to, things are changing in Saudi Arabia", adding, "that's why we see value in the partnership".
Earlier, he pointed towards Saudi Arabia announcing a £1bn investment in green aviation fuel in the UK as "the kind of thing we want to encourage".
The prime minister inspected a guard of honour after arriving at Abu Dhabi airport
Mr Johnson landed at Abu Dhabi airport in the UAE, where he was met by British Ambassador to the UAE Patrick Moody.
He then travelled to the Saudi capital, where he met Crown Prince Salman and Saudi ministers.
'Flawed argument'
Recent executions in Saudi Arabia have drawn criticism from MPs and human rights groups.
Tory MP Crispin Blunt said the executions left Mr Johnson with "exquisite difficulties" in asking Saudi Arabia for help with oil supplies.
One of the world's largest oil producers and influential on the international stage, Saudi Arabia is ruled by a monarchy which restricts political rights and civil liberties.
The rise of Crown Prince Salman as de-facto ruler in 2017 has seen moves towards liberalising some laws and diversifying the economy.
But the Saudi government's image has been damaged in recent years, particularly by the assassination of the prominent US-based journalist in 2018, Mr Khashoggi.
He was murdered at the Saudi consulate in Istanbul. Saudi Arabia said he had been killed in a "rogue operation" by a team of agents sent to persuade him to return to the kingdom.
But a UN investigator concluded that Mr Khashoggi was "the victim of a deliberate, premeditated execution" for which the Saudi state was responsible. Crown Prince Salman denied any role.
Mohammed bin Salman is asked: "Did you order the murder of Jamal Khashoggi?"
Mr Khashoggi's fiancee Ms Cengiz, who accompanied him to the entrance of the consulate, said Mr Johnson's rationale for meeting Crown Prince Salman was a "flawed argument".
He "should not run from the arms of one unpredictable tyrant" to another, she said.
"Johnson must demand to know the truth and to get justice for the brutal killing of Jamal and for all human rights abuses," Ms Cengiz said. "He cannot act as though nothing has happened. This would be so shameful."
No straightforward options
Opposition parties and some Conservatives too are uneasy about the government's association with Saudi Arabia - and have been for years.
That's more acute after dozens of executions there a few days ago.
Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer said going cap in hand from dictator to dictator is no substitute for an energy strategy.
But for the government, handling the fallout of the conflict in Ukraine means what are described as "hard-headed" decisions, even if it's "distasteful".
With huge diplomatic and economic forces at play, there are no straightforward options.
Disentangling Russia's economy from the West's may seem a diplomatic no-brainer, but the cost and complications of doing so simply can't be ignored.
The energy talks come during a global spike in energy prices driven by tight supplies, President Putin's invasion of Ukraine and western attempts to reduce dependence on Russian oil and gas.
Saudi Arabia is the largest producer in the oil cartel Opec and has the spare capacity to help lower prices by increasing supplies.
Mr Johnson was hoping to convince Crown Prince Salman to boost his kingdom's oil production and garner his support for action against Russia.
Foreign Secretary Liz Truss said while the UK did not agree with "every single policy of Saudi Arabia or the UAE", they "do not pose a threat to global security in the way that Vladimir Putin does".
"We need to bring those countries into the circle of influence of the UK and pull countries away from dependence on Russia," she said.
Muted reaction
Saudi Arabia, the UAE and other Gulf states have so far refrained from overtly condemning Russia, although they did vote in favour of a UN resolution denouncing the invasion of Ukraine.
Their muted reaction has caused some consternation among western nations including the UK, Dr Tobias Borck, a researcher of Middle East security at the RUSI think tank says.
"In the past 10 years this idea has taken hold in the Gulf that the West doesn't stand for anything anymore, that the West is no longer willing to wield its power in the world," Dr Borck told the BBC.
He said Mr Johnson's trip was a vital opportunity to rebuild relations with the Gulf states and convey to them why the invasion of Ukraine "is a watershed moment for European security".
Keir Starmer says that “going cap-in-hand from dictator to dictator” is not an energy policy.
Meanwhile, Russian attacks on Ukrainian cities continued as the worst war Europe has seen in decades entered its 21st day.
The attacks came as Ukraine and Russia held peace talks, after Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky conceded that Nato membership was not on the table, in an apparent concession to Moscow.
Mr Zelensky said the talks were becoming "more realistic", while Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov said there was "some hope for compromise".
The Ukrainian president addressed the US Congress by video link, having made similar appearances in parliaments across Europe, including the UK's.
- Published15 March 2022
- Published15 March 2022
