Cathays stabbing victim 'was the aggressor'

  • Published
Fahad Mohamed NurImage source, South Wales Police
Image caption,

Fahad Mohamed Nur was found near Cathays train station in Cardiff in June

A man stabbed to death was the aggressor in the fight, a barrister representing one of those accused of his murder told a court.

Fahad Mohamed Nur, 18, was found fatally injured near Cardiff's Cathays railway station on 2 June.

Brothers Mustafa Aldobhani and Abdulgalil Aldobhani along with friend Shafique Shaddad deny murder.

Narita Bahra, defending Abdulgalil Aldobhani, told Cardiff Crown Court Mr Nur had a history of violence.

She said Mr Nur had previously been stopped by police carrying two concealed knives.

On the night of attack, Ms Bahra said Mr Nur had £860 of Class A drugs - made up of 43 wraps of crack cocaine and heroin - hidden in his underwear and nearly £1,000 in cash hidden in his shoe.

The jury was told two weeks after his death, police found a meat cleaver and a kitchen knife hidden in the hollow of a tree near Cardiff University, not far from the scene.

Ms Bahra said of her client: "Did he inflict the fatal wound and at the time of doing so did he intend to kill - and if he didn't - are you sure he was participating in a joint attack - or might he have been acting in self-defence?"

WeaponsImage source, CPS
Image caption,

Two weeks after the attack a meat cleaver and a kitchen knife were found hidden in the hollow of a tree

The court previously heard there was no forensic evidence linking Mustafa Aldobhani, of Cathays Terrace, to the location of the stabbing.

A pathologist found the cause of Mr Nur's death was a stab wound to the heart - in all he had 21 knife wounds with injuries to his face and arms, and later died at the University Hospital of Wales from "catastrophic injuries".

A fourth defendant, Aseel Arar, 35, of Middle Park Road, Selly Oak, Birmingham, denies assisting an offender.

It is alleged she booked a flight to Morocco for herself and her boyfriend, Abdulgalil Aldaobhni, also of Cathays Terrace, after the killing.

The trial continues.

Related internet links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.