Flintshire Council could cut ties with litter firm Kingdom

The litter enforcement firm has had a temporary contract with the council for the last two years

Controversial litter enforcement firm Kingdom could lose its contract with Flintshire council over "overbearing behaviour".

The company has issued more than 7,600 fixed penalty notices in the last two years under a temporary contract, generating £20,000 a month.

But its methods have led the council to recommend cutting ties with the firm.

Kingdom representatives said it acts swiftly whenever complaints are made against its officers.

• Flintshire dog fouling and litter fines 'beneficial'

• Councils consider covert tactics to cut litter and dog mess

Councillor Hadyn Bateman condemned the treatment of an elderly woman, who he claimed was fined by Kingdom for accidentally dropping a small piece of paper from her handbag.

"She was told she had committed an offence," he said.

"She had previously never committed an offence in her life and the officers were abrupt and unforgiving."

Councillors were also unhappy that 7,017 of notices issued were for discarded cigarettes, compared to 111 for dog fouling.

The firm says that dog fouling is difficult to monitor

Councillors also heard that Kingdom has a shortfall in the number of enforcement officers it employs in Flintshire, with only two of the four roles its contracted to provide fulfilled.

Kingdom's North Wales regional manager Mark Mountford was present at Tuesday's meeting to defend the company's record.

• Bridgend dog-walking ban mooted over mess health fears

• Dog fouling phone app launched by Flintshire council

"We don't want to just fine people for dropping cigarettes, but if we see an offence we have to act on it," he said.

"Dog fouling is a big problem, but it is hard to catch people."

The majority of councillors backed a recommendation not to renew the contract with Kingdom and to bring the service in-house.

If approved by the council's cabinet, it would see the authority increase the number of its own officers to provide a similar level of litter enforcement, but adopt a stronger focus on educating the public.