Ukraine war: Germany under pressure to explain intercepted phone call
- Published
Germany is scrambling to explain how an audio of air force officials apparently discussing giving Ukraine long-range missiles was leaked by Russian sources.
Details of alleged British operations on the ground in Ukraine are also mentioned.
Russia's state-run RT channel posted an audio recording of the meeting last week.
The breach has sparked major concerns about Germany's security among allies, including France and the UK.
Germany's defence ministry has confirmed that a conversation of air force officials was "intercepted" - but couldn't say whether the recording had been tampered with.
German Chancellor Olaf Scholz has repeatedly ruled out sending the Taurus missiles to Ukraine.
Nevertheless, in the recording four senior German military officers, including Air Force chief Ingo Gerhartz and Brig Gen Frank Gräfe, are seemingly heard discussing the prospect of supplying Ukraine with the long-range cruise missiles and saying the weapons could be used to hit the Kerch Bridge, which links Russia to the illegally-annexed peninsula of Crimea.
Mr Gerhartz also mentions rumours that the Taurus system "doesn't even work".
He also suggests that German Defence Minister Boris Pistorius has been wondering "what that would look like" if Germany did eventually decide to provide the Taurus to Ukraine.
The men also appear to discuss details of alleged British operations on the ground in Ukraine and imply that Britain has been sending personnel to help Ukrainians work the Storm Shadow missiles.
The officers say that because of the complexity of the Taurus system, the Ukrainians would also need similar assistance and training from German staff.
On Monday, Chancellor Olaf Scholz said having German soldiers involved in such a task on Ukrainian soil was "completely out of the question".
The officials discuss the logistical problems of hitting the Kerch Bridge and say the Ukrainians would need assistance with mission planning - which could also be seen as German involvement and a "red line for the government".
In another section of the leaked conversation, the officials say that the Taurus would not change the course of the war and that Germany would send no more than 100 missiles to Ukraine.
They add that the political momentum to send the Taurus could come from the fact that the British and French have pretty much run out of Storm Shadows and Scalp missiles.
Tobias Ellwood, a UK member of parliament and former chairman of the Commons Defence Committee, told the BBC that the leak was "worrying on a number of levels".
The discussion was reportedly hosted on the Webex conference platform rather than a secure army platform, causing further embarrassment for Berlin.
Germany's Military Counterintelligence Service is investigating the security breach. But it is not clear whether the results of the investigation will be made public.
Mr Scholz's allies have resisted calls from the opposition for a parliamentary inquiry.
The episode has highlighted divisions over Mr Scholz's current insistence that he won't send Taurus missiles to Ukraine. Mr Scholz fears the missiles, which have a range of around 500km (300 miles), could be used by Ukraine to strike Russian territory.
France and Britain have supplied Kyiv with Scalp and Storm Shadow missiles, both of which have around half the range.
Mr Ellwood said the leak revealed a "tension... between senior German military who want to see Taurus dispatched and the German Chancellor, who seems increasingly focused on his political survival rather than what's best for the continent."
German Defence Minister Boris Pistorius is attempting to portray the hack as an attempt by Russia to sow division. He called the leak a "hybrid disinformation attack" aimed at "undermining our unity."
"We mustn't fall for Putin," he said on Sunday.
For its part, the Kremlin is framing the leak as proof that the West is directly involved in the conflict in Ukraine.
Spokesman Dmitry Peskov said on Monday that the leaked conversation "suggests that the Bundeswehr is discussing substantively and specifically plans to strike Russian territory."
Dmitry Medvedev, the hawkish former Russian president, said that Russia would "not forget" the leaked conversation.
"The road of diplomacy is not yet closed, but they must understand what we did to them during [World War Two]," he said.
Additional reporting by Michael Ertl
Related topics
- Published2 March
- Published29 February