Ghislaine Maxwell: Defence lawyers seek to discredit key accuser

  • Published
Related topics
Accuser "Jane" cries during testimonyImage source, Reuters
Image caption,

"Jane" cried when describing how difficult she found it to tell her story

Defence lawyers for British socialite Ghislaine Maxwell have been trying to find inconsistencies in the testimony of a key accuser at her trial.

The accuser, known as "Jane", says she was abused by Ms Maxwell and convicted paedophile Jeffrey Epstein aged 14.

But on Wednesday, defence counsel Laura Menninger presented documents suggesting Jane was uncertain about Ms Maxwell's participation in the abuse.

Ms Maxwell denies sex-trafficking charges.

She has pleaded not guilty to eight charges of sex trafficking and other crimes, covering a period from 1994-2004.

She has been in a US jail since her arrest last year, and faces up to 80 years in prison if convicted.

The defence claims she is being used as a scapegoat for Epstein's crimes, following his death in prison in 2019.

Prosecutors argue the pair were "partners in crime" in sex abuse.

They say Ms Maxwell, who also has American and French citizenship, recruited and groomed underage girls for her long-term companion Epstein to abuse.

Epstein died in a New York prison cell on 10 August 2019 as he awaited trial on sex-trafficking charges in a federal case. His death was ruled to be a suicide.

Jane is the first of four alleged victims to testify at the trial.

Cross-examining the witness, defence lawyer Laura Menninger produced documents from law enforcement dating back to December 2019 suggesting that Jane was unclear about whether Ms Maxwell was present during the abuse, or whether she touched or kissed her.

In her court appearance on Tuesday, Jane had described the alleged abuse - which went on from 1994 to 1997 - in graphic detail, saying that Ms Maxwell was present for much of it and was "very casual" about the encounters.

Under cross-examination she denied changing her story and questioned the accuracy of the documents, adding that the statements she made then were never recorded.

Through tears she said she had found it difficult to tell the officers involved in initial questioning "the most shameful, deepest secrets that I've been carrying around with me my whole life".

Jane also denied using her experience as a soap opera actor to embellish her testimony, and said she had no financial interest in testifying.

Image source, Getty Images

She said that while she had received $5m (£3.75m) from the victims' compensation fund she wished she had never received that money.

"I guess in this country compensation is the only thing you can get to try and move on with your life," Jane added.

Her only motivation for testifying, she said, was to "find some sort of closure".

What are the charges?

Four charges relate to the years 1994-97 when Ms Maxwell was, according to an indictment, among Epstein's closest associates and also in an "intimate relationship" with him.

Two other charges - of sex trafficking conspiracy and sex trafficking of a minor - came in an amended indictment and relate to the period 2001 and 2004.

Timeline: Arrests and charges

Epstein arrest and death

Financier Jeffrey Epstein is arrested in New Jersey after returning from France on a private jet. Federal charges accuse Epstein of trafficking a “vast network” of underage girls for sex.

He kills himself in a New York jail 36 days after his arrest.

Image copyright by Reuters

Ghislaine Maxwell arrest 

British socialite Ghislaine Maxwell is arrested in New Hampshire and accused of helping Epstein groom his victims.

Charges accuse her of befriending girls as young as 14 and enticing them into having sexual relations with Epstein. One alleged victim told the BBC that she “controlled the girls - she was like Madam”.

Prosecutors claim the abuse occurred in locations around the world, including Ms Maxwell’s London home.

She pleads not guilty. A judge denies her bail, calling her a flight risk.

Image copyright by Getty Images

A second set of charges

Two new US federal charges of sex trafficking conspiracy and sex trafficking of a minor are filed against Ms Maxwell, adding to the six she already faced.

Prosecutors say a fourth victim has been identified. The victim was allegedly abused in 2001 when she was 14 years old. Ms Maxwell denies these charges.

First court appearance

Ms Maxwell appears in court for the first time, pleading not guilty to multiple charges of sex abuse, sex-trafficking and perjury.

Her defence lawyers argue that the conditions in her Brooklyn jail are inhumane and argue that she is “being treated horribly”. She is denied bail.

Image copyright by Reuters

Trial begins

Ms Maxwell trial begins in New York, where she has been in jail since her arrest.

Earlier in November, a jury candidate pool of over 600 New Yorkers was whittled down to 12 jury members.

Who is Ghislaine Maxwell?

Born outside Paris on Christmas Day, 1961, Ms Maxwell grew up in a country mansion, went to Oxford University and speaks several languages.

She is the youngest child of late media mogul Robert Maxwell.

She is said to have had a very close relationship with her late father, and he named his luxury yacht - the Lady Ghislaine - after her.

Image source, Getty Images
Image caption,

Ghislaine Maxwell was said to be very close to her late father Robert Maxwell

Soon after her father's death in 1991, Ms Maxwell left the UK to settle in America, where she worked in real estate, and not long after met Jeffrey Epstein.

She sold her Manhattan townhouse in 2016, and kept a low profile until she was arrested last July at her secluded mansion in the state of New Hampshire.

Media caption,

Epstein accuser Teresa Helm: Ghislaine Maxwell is a 'master manipulator'