Celtic recruitment flawed under Brendan Rodgers - Kris Commons

  • Published
Celtic manager Brendan Rodgers with striker Odsonne Edouard (right)Image source, SNS Group
Image caption,

Celtic paid a record transfer fee to land Odsonne Edouard (right) over the summer

Most of Brendan Rodgers' signings have "not made any impact" and there is a "recruitment issue" at Celtic, says former midfielder Kris Commons.

Rodgers voiced frustration at the lack of new faces following defeat to AEK Athens in Champions League qualifying.

But Commons points to the "£25m" his former boss has spent since May 2016.

"Whoever is in control of bringing in players needs to have a look at themselves as the quality is not good enough," Commons told BBC Scotland.

Lee Congerton has been the Scottish champions' head of recruitment since March 2017 - an appointment described as "outstanding" by chief executive Peter Lawwell.

Yet of the players who started Tuesday's 2-1 loss in Greece - which confirmed a 3-2 aggregate defeat - only defender Jack Hendry has been signed during his tenure.

Midfielder Olivier Ntcham was the only other member of the starting XI to have joined after Rodgers' arrival.

"The quality isn't good enough for a starting place in the 11," Commons said.

"Everyone says he's been crying out for defenders, but he signed two goalkeepers in Dorus de Vries and Scott Bain, two centre-halves in Marvin Compper and Jack Hendry, right-back Cristian Gamboa, he's just re-signed Emilio Izaguirre...

"He's had the funds to get good players but they're not making any impact on the side. He has three or four that pass the mark - Scott Sinclair, Odsonne Edouard, Moussa Dembele and Olivier Ntcham.

"Peter Lawwell does not have a blank chequebook. Rodgers has spent around £25m on transfers - without signing-on fees, wages, agent fees - in 24 months. Lawwell probably thinks he's given him enough."

'Boyata in the driving seat'

Dedryck Boyata was among those missing from the defeat in Athens, with Rodgers suggesting the defender was fit, while the Belgian international maintained he was "not 100% operational".

Commons played alongside Boyata and was surprised at Rodgers "pretty much calling his player a liar".

"If Dedryck says he's not fit, he's not fit. He's not that sort of character," he said. "Rodgers is probably saying 'we need you, even if you're 80% fit, we need you'.

"It's a strange one, because they've turned down really good money for him. He wasn't first choice, but he's gone away and had a good World Cup. His stock has gone up, he's in the driving seat."

Defeat at Hearts preceded the loss to AEK, the first time Rodgers has lost back-to-back games with Celtic.

"There will be more pressure now," said Commons. "People will fancy taking them all the way.

"They need to get heads together, they've got some very important games coming up. All eyes will be on the 2 September game when Steven Gerrard brings Rangers to Celtic Park - there could be fireworks."

CELTIC SIGNINGS

2018/19

2017/18

2016/17

Odsonne Edouard - PSG - £9.27m

Olivier Ntcham - Man City - £4.5m

Scott Sinclair - Aston Villa - £3.69m

Scott Bain - Dundee - free

Charly Musonda - Chelsea - Loan (£2.25m)

Eboue Kouassi - FK Krasnodar - £3.15m

Emilio Izaguirre - Al Feiha - free

Jonny Hayes - Aberdeen - £1.32m

Cristian Gamboa - West Brom - £1.08m

Jack Hendry - Dundee - £1.23m

Kristoffer Ajer - IK Start - £540k

Marvin Compper - RB Leipzig - £1.03m

Kolo Toure - Liverpool - free

Lewis Morgan - St Mirren - £306k

Moussa Dembele - Fulham - undisclosed compensation fee

Kundai Benyu - Ipswich - free

Dorus de Vries - Nottingham Forest - free

Odsonne Edouard - PSG - loan

Patrick Roberts - Man City - loan

Scott Bain - Dundee - loan

CELTIC DEPARTURES

2018/19

2017/18

2016/17

Stuart Armstrong - Southampton - £7.16m

Emilio Izaguirre - Al-Feiha - £1.26m

Stefan Johansen - Fulham - £2.07m

Erik Sviatchenko - FC Midtjylland - £1.03m

Liam Henderson - Bari - £108k

Stefan Scepovic - Getafe - £1.08m

Sam Wardrop - Dundee Utd - free

Eoghan O'Connell - Bury - free

Carlton Cole - Sacramento FC - free

Jamie Lindsay - Ross County - free

Paul McMullan - Dundee Utd - free

Stuart Findlay - Newcastle Utd - free

Nadir Ciftci - Genclerbirligi - free

Connor McManus - Morton - free

Michael Duffy - Dundalk - free

Jamie McCart - Inverness CT - free

Logan Bailly - Mouscron - free

Charlie Mulgrew - Blackburn Rovers - free

Joe Thomson - Dunfermline - free

Leo Fasan - Bury - free

Anthony Stokes - Blackburn Rovers - free

Efe Ambrose - Hibs - free

Gary Mackay-Steven - Aberdeen - undisclosed

Saidy Janko - Saint-Etienne - undisclosed

Around the BBC

Related internet links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.