Buy one, sell one, loan one out - your picks

Your views image
  • Published

If you could only buy one, sell one, and loan out one player at Newcastle United, who would you pick?

That was the question we asked you to answer, with the transfer window set to open on Friday.

Here are some of your thoughts:

Edwin: Buy: Michael Olise - Olise, Gordon and Isak would make a front three capable of honours next year. Sell: Jeff Hendrick - after 25 appearances in four years, you would think the time has come for his sale with FFP breathing down our necks. Loan: Lewis Miley - Tonali's potential return might push him out and he needs to play regularly.

Reece: Buy: Ferran Torres from Barcelona. Sell: Miguel Almiron. Loan: Harvey Barnes.

Marcus: Buy: Serhou Guirassy - consistent, mature, experienced and can play as a central striker or out wide, so he would give us options with Isak. Sell: Callum Wilson - still deadly but too injury prone. Loan: Ciaran Thompson - a future starter who just needs more experience.

Krishnan: Buy: Ademola Lookman from Atalanta or Lois Openda from RB Leipzig. Sell: Alexander Isak. Loan: Lewis Miley.

Steve: Buy: Kalvin Phillips - if his wages could be agreed, a couple of months under Eddie Howe would see him grow into a totally different player. Sell: Callum Wilson. Loan: Sean Longstaff.