Bolsonaro's coup trial gripped Brazil - and his conviction will divide the country

Jair Bolsonaro pictured from the neck up, in a pale yellow polo shirt with a navy trimImage source, EPA/ Shutterstock
  • Published

This is a huge moment for Brazil.

Ex-President Jair Bolsonaro has been convicted of attempting a coup and leading an armed criminal group after losing the last election, which culminated in his supporters attacking government buildings.

He now faces a 27-year prison sentence, after four out of five of Brazil's Supreme Court justices found him guilty.

For years, Bolsonaro has fiercely divided the country into those who love him and those who hate him.

His supporters, who include President Donald Trump, have described the trial as political persecution. Trump used it as an excuse to impose 50% tariffs on Brazil.

Trump has said he is "very unhappy" with the verdict and Secretary of State Marco Rubio said the US would "respond accordingly to this witch hunt". Bolsonaro's son Eduardo, who has been lobbying in the US on his father's behalf, said he expects the US to impose more sanctions. The US had already sanctioned the Supreme Court judge Alexandre de Moraes.

His critics have praised the proceedings as necessary to bring closure, and to set a precedent that trying to undermine democracy will not be tolerated.

This ruling is likely to divide the country further.

This trial has gripped Brazil, as millions have seen it live-streamed on social media and television into their homes. And the story line has been no less dramatic than a TV series.

Many people may remember the shocking moments when thousands of Bolsonaro supporters attacked government buildings on 8 January 2023, in scenes reminiscent of the 6 January Capitol riots in the US two years before.

But throughout the course of this trial, many gobsmacking pieces of evidence have been revealed and read out in court.

These include that a plan, drafted by Bolsonaro's allies, for elite armed forces personnel to assassinate the president-elect Luiz Inacio "Lula" da Silva, his running mate, and the Supreme Court judge Alexandre de Moraes was printed out at the presidential palace. It listed "poison" as a method to kill Lula.

Bolsonaro's lawyer was visibly incensed on behalf of his client, when he argued there was no evidence linking Bolsonaro to this plot or the 8 January riots.

The court was also reminded of Bolsonaro's attempts to cast doubt on the electoral system. These included him holding a meeting with foreign ambassadors at the presidential palace to make false claims about electronic voting machines before the election, and public bodies obstructing voters from getting to polling stations – under the guise of "checking the condition of vehicles" – on the day of the vote.

At various moments throughout this trial, the judges referred to Brazil's past. Its democracy is young – it was only restored in 1985 after two decades of a dictatorship, instigated by a military coup, backed by the US.

To Bolsonaro's critics, the parallels were chilling.

The judge leading this case – Alexandre de Moraes – said Brazil risked "slowly forgetting" that it nearly returned to a dictatorship because "a criminal organisation, comprised of a political group, doesn't know how to lose elections".

Brazil's past has been littered with coups or attempted coups, but no one has ever sat in the dock, and past plotters have been granted amnesty. Bolsonaro's critics hope this verdict sends a clear signal: no more.

So what happens next?

Bolsonaro's sentence is, effectively, a life one for the 70-year-old.

The judges said at least 24 years and 9 months of this should be spent in jail.

He will likely try to appeal the sentence length and ask for it to be turned into a house arrest – something he is already on.

Jair Bolsonaro didn't appear in the courtroom for the verdicts. His lawyer has cited health reasons. He has suffered various health problems after he was stabbed at a presidential campaign rally in 2018, before he took office.

There is a precedent in Brazil of convicts being granted house arrest due to age or health reasons.

Congress – where Bolsonaro's party has a majority – is also trying to push through legislation that would grant him amnesty. One of the right-wing frontrunners for next year's presidential election, who is courting Bolsonaro's support, has said he would give Bolsonaro amnesty if elected.

So, while this ruling is an important milestone, his punishment still remains unclear.

Related topics