Family of woman who died blame parked cars for ambulance delay

Aimee, pictured with her father, said it was not about blame but raising awareness of parking issues

The family of a woman who died after suffering a cardiac arrest say their neighbours had to move a parked car to allow an ambulance to access their street.

Philomena Donnelly had the cardiac arrest at home in west Belfast in August and died five days later.

An ambulance arrived at her address within 11 minutes - which is within the target for a category one incident such as a cardiac arrest - but Mrs Donnelly's husband Damien told BBC News NI it was initially blocked from accessing the road.

The Northern Ireland Ambulance Service (NIAS) said it could not comment on individual cases but expressed sympathy to the Donnelly family and said it would directly engage with them over any questions.

Philomena Donnelly suffered a cardiac arrest at home in west Belfast in August

Ambulance crews can experience a range of issues which can affect response times, the service said.

"These can include (but are not restricted to) traffic congestion, road closures, poor weather conditions, pedestrian activity, lack of house numbers etc," it added.

Mr Donnelly said the paramedics told him streets in Turf Lodge were often blocked for all emergency services.

The family now want to raise awareness of parking issues in their area.

'Impossible street access'

Mr Donnelly told BBC News NI he performed CPR as he waited for the ambulance and that he could hear sirens in the background.

"That noise seemed to last for a lot longer than what I would have expected," he said.

Mr Donnelly said access to the street was "impossible" due to cars parked on both sides of the road.

He said neighbours had to move a car so the ambulance could get down the street.

"They’re stopping to wait for someone to move a car," he said.

"If the ambulance had a straight run, it would have got here quicker."

The Department for Infrastructure (DfI) said it would visit the area and make changes within its remit.

The couple's daughter, Aimee, said there were unanswered questions.

"My mummy was in cardiac arrest, and every second counts," she said.

"If the paramedics were able to get there even 20 seconds earlier, would the outcome have been different? It’s the same question over and over. And we’ll never get the answer to it.

"I do believe it made a difference. This isn’t about blame, this is about raising awareness of where to park."

'Plagued for decades'

The Social Democratic and Labour Party councillor for the area, Paul Doherty, has been trying to raise awareness of the issues.

"Residents in Turf Lodge have been plagued for decades with issues around parking and congestion. The infrastructure is outdated and the roads are not fit for purpose," he said.

"We can’t have a situation where emergency services, be it an ambulance, be it a fire service, can’t get into this area to attend to people who are at real risk."

The Donnelly family have requested meetings with the DfI, Housing Executive and Belfast City Council to discuss practical measures such as double yellow lines.

The DfI confirmed it had received the councillor's request for a site visit and also appealed for drivers to be considerate when they park.

It comes as a new pilot scheme from Belfast City Council aimed at stopping bad parking in south and east Belfast began in October.

Drivers there could face fines and possible prosecution for bad parking.

'Bit of dignity'

The Donnelly family said parking was also an issue when the funeral company brought Philomena home.

Mr Donnelly said the car could not get around the corner.

"Aimee had to go up the street and find who owned the car that was parked while Philomena was in the back of the funeral director's car, waiting to come home to rest," he said.

On the morning of the funeral, the family said they had to knock on doors to get cars to move, "just for that bit of dignity at the end".

The Northern Ireland Ambulance Service said: "We would like to thank the public for their consideration and support when encountering ambulance crews who are responding under emergency conditions ie blue lights and sirens.

"In such circumstances, time is of the utmost importance but equally, the safety of our staff and all road users is paramount."