Urgent review ordered into asylum seeker taxi costs

Home secretary Shabana MahmoodImage source, Getty

The home secretary has ordered an urgent review into the use and cost of taxis to transfer asylum seekers from their hotels to appointments.

The move by Shabana Mahmood follows a BBC investigation that found some migrants having to travel long distances on journeys costing hundreds of pounds.

One asylum seeker told the BBC he had taken a 250-mile journey to visit a GP, with the driver telling him the cost to the Home Office was £600.

Asylum seekers are issued with a bus pass for one return journey per week, but for any other necessary travel, such as a doctors' appointment, taxis are called.

The BBC asked the government how much it spends on taxi travel for asylum seekers via a Freedom of Information Act request, but the Home Office said it does not keep these figures.

The File on Four investigation reported that asylum seekers must show proof of an upcoming appointment at the reception desk of their hotel, where a taxi is booked on an automated system. Public transport or walking is not presented as an option.

This can result in some unusually long journeys and others that are unusually short.

For instance, when migrants move between hotels, they sometimes keep the same NHS doctors - especially for GP referrals.

Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden told BBC Radio 4's Today programme he agreed that there should be an investigation into how the system works.

"I'm not surprised that this was a feature that caught people's eye", he said.

On Tuesday, housing minister Matthew Pennycook told the Today programme it was "questionable" that asylum seekers needed to take such long taxi journeys and said the government would "look into those cases".

He added that asylum seekers were not "ordinary citizens just jumping on a bus".

File on 4 Investigates: Inside the Migrant Hotel

In recordings made as demonstrations unfold, Sue Mitchell takes listeners into the closed world of the migrant hotels.

Tuesday 23 September

Listen now BBC Sounds or on Tuesday 23 September at 20:00 on BBC Radio 4

Shadow home secretary Chris Philp, said: "Every £600 taxi ride for migrants is money that should be paying for British patients to see their GP or for ambulances to turn up on time. This is why people feel the system is rigged against them.

"Labour are writing a blank cheque for illegal immigration while services for hard-working families are strained."

The BBC went into four hotels housing asylum seekers, as part of its investigation, uncovering cramped living conditions, illegal working, and fire alarms covered with plastic bags, as residents secretly cooked meals over electric hobs in bathrooms.

The BBC found:

  • Smoke alarms covered with plastic bags as residents cooking meals used electric hobs in bathrooms

  • A 12-year-old girl living in a hotel who had spent three-quarters of her life in the asylum system. "Once we get settled in a place, then they move us," she said

  • Some asylum seekers saying they had no choice but to work illegally for as little as £20 a day to pay off debts to people smugglers

Get in touch

Have you been affected by the issues raised in this story?