What do Scots think of England's relationship with them?
Scotland's First Minister Alex Salmond is setting out his ideas on Wednesday on how a referendum on independence might work.
The Scottish government is formally launching its consultation on the move with arguments over whether there should be one or two questions on the ballot paper.
Radio 5 live's Nicky Campbell found out what people in Edinburgh made of England's relationship with Scotland.
To hear other 5 live interviews, please visit the best bits page.