BBC Homepage
  • Skip to content
  • Accessibility Help
  • Your account
  • Notifications
  • Home
  • News
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • iPlayer
  • Sounds
  • Bitesize
  • CBBC
  • CBeebies
  • Food
  • More menu
More menu
Search BBC
  • Home
  • News
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • iPlayer
  • Sounds
  • Bitesize
  • CBBC
  • CBeebies
  • Food
Close menu
BBC News
Menu
  • Home
  • InDepth
  • Israel-Gaza war
  • War in Ukraine
  • Climate
  • UK
  • World
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Culture
More
  • Tech
  • Science
  • Health
  • Family & Education
  • In Pictures
  • Newsbeat
  • BBC Verify
  • Disability
  • Trending

Why did a strangely undramatic protest photo grip Brazil?

  • Published
    16 March 2016
Share page
About sharing
The picture that went viral in BrazilImage source, Joao Valadares / Correio Brazilienze
Image caption,

The photo had gone viral even before the protests where it was taken had ended.

ByBBC Trending
What's popular and why

The picture above, taken during anti-government protests in Brazil, has been held up online as emblematic of the country's economic and racial divides - though others loudly defended the couple captured on camera.

A white couple walk their dog in Ipanema, one of the wealthiest neighbourhoods in Rio de Janeiro. Behind them, their twin toddlers ride in a stroller pushed by a black nanny. The parents are wearing yellow and green clothes - the colours of the Brazilian flag - whereas the maid is dressed in the all-white uniform that some upper-class Brazilians prefer their domestic employees to wear.

The family and their maid were on their way to join one of more than 100 protest marches held Sunday across Brazil. The protesters - two million of them last weekend - are fed up with corruption allegations against President Dilma Rousseff and a poorly performing economy.

And by the time the demonstrations were over, this one picture - strangely absent of large crowds, dramatic scenes or tense confrontations - had been shared millions of times.

To understand why requires a little bit of knowledge about Brazilian politics today.

Rousseff and her predecessor, Lula da Silva, have both come under fire for corruption allegations linked to the state-run oil company, Petrobras. Da Silva is currently under investigation in a bribery case, and high-profile members of the ruling Workers Party have been convicted of corruption charges. Both Da Silva and his successor have denied any wrongdoing and say the allegations are politically motivated.

Even though Brazilians across all classes and ethnicities have expressed frustration with the current left leaning administration, polls suggest the demonstrations are dominated by white and upper-middle-class people. One survey of protesters in Sao Paulo indicated that protesters were much wealthier than average and that three-quarters were white (compared to less than half of the general population).

So for many online, the photo snapped by Joao Valadares, external, a journalist with Brazilian newspaper Correio Brazilienze, external, became a symbol of how polarized Brazil is over the current protests.

"I want my country back, where I can have my "maid" and not give her any rights (IRONY)", one user commented. "What the picture says, between the lines, is that you are asking for a better world for yourself as a white employer, and for your perfect family, while the black nanny continues to be a maid."

line

Follow BBC Trending on Facebook

Join the conversation on this and other stories here, external.

line

But others took umbrage at those who dismissed the value of domestic workers.

"Since when being a nanny is a not a decent work anymore?" one asked. "What is wrong with that picture? She is WORKING", snipped another user.

Media caption,

Police said more than a million people were on the streets of Sao Paulo

The couple photographed, Claudio Pracownik and Carolina Maia Pracownik, were not available for comment. But in a Facebook post, Mr Pracownik - who is the finance director of Brazil's famous Flamengo soccer club - criticised what he called "the violation of my privacy" and said the photo was being used as a distraction from the country's political and economic crisis.

"I earn my money honestly," he wrote.

According to Mr Pracownik, the nanny in the picture works for the family only on weekends and is paid above the going rate for it. He also said he's proud to employ people and argued that people shouldn't assume the maid is a victim.

"She is free to resign if she would prefer other work or another employer," he said.

"I don't treat her like a victim or as if she is a member of my family. I treat with respect and with dignity that any employee deserves."

In an interview with a local newspaper, the nanny, Maria Angelica Lima, said she felt "exposed" by the picture but that she had no problem working for the Pracownik family or attending the protest.

"I was working," she says. "I went with them because I was taking care of the children. I don't see anything wrong with that."

Lima also said she had no objection to wearing a uniform, which is provided by the couple, and noted that she even employs a nanny herself, for the times when she and her husband are both working.

Many people were riffing on the photo online - such as in this illustration. The sign says "Justice for Brazil"Image source, Facebook
Image caption,

Many people were riffing on the photo online - such as in this illustration. The sign says "Justice for Brazil"

Blog by Luis Barrucho, BBC Brasil

Next story: Who's at the controls of Iran's bot army?

Image showing missile being launched off a truckImage source, Twitter/@daniel_mathew12

A group of mysterious Twitter accounts pumps out crude propaganda - but to what end? READ MORE

You can follow BBC Trending on Twitter @BBCtrending, external, and find us on Facebook, external. All our stories are at bbc.com/trending.

Top stories

  • One iPhone led police to gang suspected of sending up to 40,000 stolen UK phones to China

    • Published
      4 hours ago
  • Mother of Israeli hostage says she still doesn't know if he's alive or dead

    • Published
      1 hour ago
  • Israel and Hamas begin indirect talks in Egypt on Trump's Gaza peace plan

    • Published
      7 hours ago

More to explore

  • I was fooled into paying £500 to be a model. Here's how to avoid my mistake

    Older woman with short blonde hair wearing a red top and white trousers posing for a photoshoot
  • 'UK Gaza protests going ahead' and 'Romp in Peace, Jilly'

    A composite image of The i Paper and The Sun. "UK Gaza protest going ahead today on anniversary of October 7 massacre" and "Romp in Peace, Jilly" reads the headlines of the two respectively.
  • What makes this US shutdown different (and more difficult)

    A woman wearing a dress with a black sleeveless top and a knee-length stripped black, white and bright pink skirt looks at a sign in front of the National Gallery of Art saying it is "closed due to federal government shutdown"
  • 'I was lucky to get out': Everest hikers battle hypothermia as blizzard rescue continues

    Person wearing winter trekking gear ploughing through a huge snow drift on Mount Everest
  • The true cost of cyber attacks - and the business weak spots that allow them to happen

    M&S and JLR logos
  • Sex, class, horses: The unique mix that made Jilly Cooper's books special

    Jill Cooper sitting at a piano, pictured in 1996
  • Does your relationship have a swag gap, and is that always a bad thing?

    Jessica Raialo wearing a green and blue flower patterned jacket, orange neck scarf, grey and red t-shirt and a belt, next to her boyfriend wearing a dark cap and long-sleeved top.
  • EastEnders' Kellie Bright on the challenges of being parent of an autistic child

    Kellie Bright is wearing a bright red shirt with white lace details, leaning forward with hands on a colourful floral-patterned surface, against a plain light background. Her hair is tied up with a pink accessory.
  • News Daily: Our flagship daily newsletter delivered to your inbox first thing, with all the latest headlines

    A promo promoting the News Daily newsletter - a graphic of an orange sphere with two concentric crescent shapes around it in a red-orange gradient, like a sound wave.
loading elsewhere stories

Most read

  1. 1

    One iPhone led police to gang suspected of sending up to 40,000 stolen UK phones to China

  2. 2

    Pharmacies facing angry patients over Covid jab confusion

  3. 3

    I was fooled into paying £500 to be a model. Here's how to avoid my mistake

  4. 4

    Conservatives promise to scrap Sentencing Council

  5. 5

    British parts found in Russian drones, Zelensky says

  6. 6

    'UK Gaza protests going ahead' and 'Romp in Peace, Jilly'

  7. 7

    Footage shows Jihad Al-Shamie before attack

  8. 8

    First-year resident doctors back strike action over jobs shortage

  9. 9

    Renewables overtake coal as world's biggest source of electricity

  10. 10

    Queen leads tributes to 'wonderfully witty friend' Dame Jilly Cooper

BBC News Services

  • On your mobile
  • On smart speakers
  • Get news alerts
  • Contact BBC News

Best of the BBC

  • The Bafta-winning Belfast police drama returns

    • Attribution
      iPlayer

    Added to Watchlist
    Blue Lights has been added to your iPlayer Watchlist.
    Blue Lights
  • Andy Zaltzman dissects the week's news

    • Attribution
      Sounds

    Added to My Sounds
    The News Quiz has been added to your My Sounds.
  • Exposing a disturbing scam targeting teenage boys

    • Attribution
      iPlayer

    Added to Watchlist
    Blackmailed: The Sextortion Killers has been added to your iPlayer Watchlist.
    Blackmailed: The Sextortion Killers
  • The foods that could help you live to 100

    • Attribution
      Sounds

    Added to My Sounds
    The Food Chain has been added to your My Sounds.
    The Food Chain
  • Home
  • News
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • iPlayer
  • Sounds
  • Bitesize
  • CBBC
  • CBeebies
  • Food
  • Terms of Use
  • About the BBC
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookies
  • Accessibility Help
  • Parental Guidance
  • Contact the BBC
  • Make an editorial complaint
  • BBC emails for you

Copyright © 2025 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.