Supermarkets misleading shoppers on healthy food, say nutritionists

Supermarkets routinely brand vegan products as "healthier"

Products high in salt and saturated fats are being marketed as healthy by leading supermarkets, BBC Radio 5 Live Investigates has found.

The British Dietetic Association said stores including Tesco, Morrisons and Sainsbury's were being "unhelpful" and "confusing" customers.

The Royal Society for Public Health called for an independent supermarket regulator.

Supermarkets said they were committed to "promoting healthy eating".

BBC researchers visited the top five supermarkets in the UK and found Sainsbury's, Morrisons and Tesco were stocking products high in salt and saturated fat in sections marked "healthier choices" and "healthy and diet meals".

Morrisons' "healthier choices" section contained a vegetarian steak slice with almost 10g of saturated fat - nearly half of the recommended maximum daily amount.

'Shocked'

The supermarket said the item "provides customers with a red-meat free alternative".

Sainsbury's edamame, coconut and lemongrass falafel contained more than 6g of saturated fat per half pack - around a third of the recommended maximum daily amount - and was located in their "healthier choices" section.

In Tesco's "healthy and diet meals" section, a "lamb hotpot" contained 8.5g of saturated fat, 45% of the recommended maximum daily amount.

Registered nutritionist Charlotte Stirling-Reed said she was "quite shocked" at some of the items being marketed as 'healthier choices'.

She said: "I'm not saying there's anything wrong with eating them or consuming them in moderation - but telling consumers these are healthier options is a bit misleading."

Nutritionist Charlotte Stirling-Reed said the 'healthier choices' sections of supermarkets are misleading

The Royal Society for Public Health (RSPH) said many products are being identified as "healthy" because they are vegetarian, vegan, free from certain ingredients, or have fewer calories.

But, it said, many have high levels of fat, salt or sugar, and are highly processed.

'Duty of care'

"Supermarkets should be transparent about how they classify foods, and provide clear information about products," the RSPH added.

"There must be incentives and penalties for presenting clear and accurate information.

"Perhaps there is potential to have an independent supermarket regulator. It is important that the good work done so far on labelling is not undermined."

A British Dietetic Association (BDA) spokesperson said supermarkets had a "duty of care" to their customers.

"It is unhelpful and confusing to the consumer, and supermarkets should avoid doing this," they added.

"They should be promoting and educating people to buy foods that actually are healthy - not just marketed as being so."

Trading standards representatives said they would be speaking to supermarkets

Morrisons' own brand lentil hotpot contained almost a third of the recommended maximum daily amount of salt - almost 2g - but was stocked in the "healthier choices" section.

Smoked meat substitute slices marketed as healthy in Sainsbury's contained almost two grams of salt per four slices, making them more salty than seawater.

Action on Salt, which campaigns for a reduction in the consumption of salt, said it was very time-consuming for shoppers to check every label to find a healthier option.

"Placing products in 'healthier choice' sections of supermarkets should ideally highlight products that are actually better for our health," it said.

"However, we've found that many of the vegetarian and vegan products in these sections of the supermarket can be high in salt, with some vegetarian burgers containing more salt than real beef burgers, meaning shoppers are being given a false sense of security.

"Supermarkets should have stronger criteria in place for products allowed to be displayed in their 'healthier choice' sections."

Dietitians say the mislabelling of foods in supermarkets is confusing

Council trading standards officers enforce food safety laws that cover health and nutrition claims in individual supermarkets.

Hertfordshire and West Yorkshire trading standards services - the principal trading standards partners for Tesco and Morrisons - told BBC Radio 5 Live Investigates they will be making further enquiries with both supermarkets.

Tesco said: "We are sorry that some of our products were mistakenly included under the 'Healthy and Diet Meals' sign and are rectifying this immediately."

It added that all nutritional information is clearly listed on packaging.

Sainsbury's said: "Our range of healthier meals are currently stocked alongside our vegetarian and plant-based options. In some cases our signs were not updated to reflect this and we are putting this right."

It said it was committed to helping customers live "healthier lives".

Morrisons said: "Our 'Healthier Choices' section provides customers with the option to buy an item that is healthier than a product that meets a similar need. A 'Healthier Choices' cheese will be substantially lower in fat than ones we sell elsewhere but might still carry a red traffic light label."

5 Live Investigates is on BBC Radio 5 Live, 24 February at 11:00 GMT - catch up on BBC Sounds