Summary

  • The families of three girls killed in the 2024 Southport attacks say the killer's family "failed"

  • Elsie Dot Stancombe, Bebe King, and Alice da Silva Aguiar were killed in the attacks - their parents have released statements after the Southport inquiry heard evidence from the killer's family

  • Jenni and David Stancombe say Axel Rudakubana's parents "knew how dangerous he was, yet they stayed silent", while Lauren and Ben King criticise "the repeated failings of agencies and professionals who should have known better"

  • Earlier, Axel Rudakubana's mother said she was "profoundly sorry" for the family's failure to stop the Southport killer

  • And his father admitted he "didn't have the courage" to call police in the week of the attack, after his son tried to take a taxi to his old school

  • Axel Rudakubana was sentenced in January to a minimum of 52 years in prison for the murders of Elsie Dot Stancombe, seven, Bebe King, six, and Alice da Silva Aguiar, nine

  1. Was carrying knives 'common' in killer's school?published at 10:12 GMT 5 November

    Jonny Humphries
    BBC News

    Mr Boyle asks Mr Rudukabana about a claim in his witness statement that knife carrying at the Range High School was "pretty common" and questioned if expelling his brother was to "make an example" of him.

    This has been strongly denied by school management, with head teacher Mr McGarry telling the inquiry there had been no incidents of knife carrying in the six years since 2019.

    Mr Rudukabana said he "trusts" his friends who told him this information.

    Mr Boyle asked if he was downplaying his brother's behaviour.

    He said "No, no, no, I'm referring to the general situation.

    "I mean the school has denied he was being bullied. But his actions, this situation that was aced was not simply in isolation of the circumstances he's under."

  2. Dion recalls his brother talking about carrying a knifepublished at 10:04 GMT 5 November

    Jonny Humphries
    BBC News

    The hearing has resumed and Richard Boyle, counsel to the inquiry, will continue to question Dion Rudakubana.

    He begins by asking about a visit from a Lancashire Police officer to the family home on 7 October 2019.

    Mr Rudukabana said he was at home, but not in the same room.

    He recalled his brother telling the officer directly he had a knife and had "intended to use it".

    This refers to his sibling admitting carrying knives to his school, Range High School, which led to him being expelled.

  3. The scene is set for another day of intense evidencepublished at 10:02 GMT 5 November

    Judith Moritz
    Special correspondent

    The hearing room is ready to begin. The ranks of barristers are sitting in position and are able to see the video-link screen which Dion Rudakubana will be seen on.

    I’m sitting on the media benches which are next to the public area.

    As ordered by inquiry chairman Sir Adrian Fulford, this section of the room is not able to see the screen that the barristers can see.

    The media are also prevented from broadcasting this evidence on TV and radio, and we can’t show Dion Rudakubana’s photograph or give any details which may locate him or identify him.

    The chairman has ruled that such special measures are allowed because of a continuing threat to his life if he is identified.

  4. Brother and father due to give evidence.published at 09:48 GMT 5 November

    Jonny Humphries
    BBC News

    Chairman of the inquiry sitting against a purple backdropImage source, PA Media

    Dion Rudakubana, 21, will continue his evidence via video-link from a secret location.

    On Tuesday he told the inquiry his brother became progressively more violent and unpredictable after he was expelled from the Range High School in Formby in October 2019.

    He told the inquiry by 2022 he feared his parents had "lost control" of him.

    We are also expected to hear from Axel and Dion's father, Alphonse Rudakubana, who again will appear via video-link.

    He is expected to be asked questions about what knowledge he had of his son's obsession with weapons and what information he shared with different agencies.

  5. Welcome back to our live coveragepublished at 09:44 GMT 5 November

    Tom Mullen
    BBC News

    Good morning and welcome back.

    We'll be with you throughout the day with more live updates as the brother of Southport killer Axel Rudakubana continues giving evidence at the public inquiry into the stabbings

    Dion Rudakubana has previously told how he became "increasingly wary" of his brother's "violent outbursts"

    He also said he seriously feared Axel would kill a family member "if things escalated".

  6. Southport killer's brother became increasingly wary of violent outbursts, inquiry hearspublished at 17:17 GMT 4 November

    Elliot Burrin
    Live reporter

    The older brother of the Southport killer today gave evidence in the public inquiry into the 2024 attack, in which three young girls were killed.

    Appearing on video link, Dion Rudakubana said he was "increasingly wary" of Axel's "violent outbursts".

    Here's what else we heard from him:

    • By 2022, he seriously feared his brother would kill a family member "if things escalated"
    • The brothers stopped speaking to each other in 2023
    • When asked if he agreed that his parents had "lost control" of his brother, he replied: "Erm, yes"
    • His brother became significantly more violent after being expelled from his high school in 2019

    Earlier, the inquiry heard that the killer had possibly viewed violent material on X minutes before the attack.

    A senior X executive defended the importance of free speech on the app, saying that X would not limit individual rights.

    The inquiry has adjourned for the day, and we will shortly be ending our coverage - but we'll be back tomorrow morning as Dion continues to give evidence.

  7. Inquiry adjourned for the daypublished at 16:39 GMT 4 November

    Jonny Humphries
    BBC News

    Dion says his brother "never spoke to me" directly about being bullied, saying that he heard about it from his father.

    He adds that he didn’t see any bullying of AR with his own eyes.

    Chairman Sir Adrian Fulford then calls an end to the day's proceedings.

    Dion Rudakubana, brother of the Southport killer, will resume giving his evidence from 09:45 GMT on Wednesday.

    We'll shortly bring you a recap of what was heard at the inquiry today - stick with us.

  8. School denied Dion's reports of bullyingpublished at 16:36 GMT 4 November

    Jonny Humphries
    BBC News

    Had Dion seen any evidence that AR was bullied at school, Richard Boyle asks.

    He responds saying that at some point after February 2019, while AR was in year 8 at the Range High School, he became aware that his brother was being bullied.

    Dion says he remembers his father speaking to a teacher about it quite frequently after school, saying that his father had brought up the bullying on behalf of his brother.

    He confirms that after AR was expelled, he heard from other pupils that it was widely known in his year group he was being bullied.

    Boyle says that the Range staff "strongly denied" a comment in Dion's statement suggesting "there were a lot of trouble-makers" in that school.

    The teacher said Dion continued to stay at the school after AR was expelled.

    "It's not relevant to the troublemakers, I don't know what extent of trouble there would have to be for me to leave,” Dion says. “It was never sufficient for me to leave."

    The school also denied AR was subjected to a "systematic pattern" of bullying.

  9. Dion tells inquiry about the last time he saw his brotherpublished at 16:30 GMT 4 November

    Jonny Humphries
    BBC News

    Boyle moves on to ask Dion about his brother's capacity for empathy, which he says seemed to reduce over time.

    In his earlier statement, Dion referred to his brother as reminding him of a character in the film No County for Old Men.

    "Yeah I think I've been told that character's meant to be a sociopath, and that's why I used the word there," he says.

    He agrees that from around 2021 AR would "dominate the living room" and he would avoid it.

    Dion says the last interaction he had with his brother was in summer 2023.

    Richard Boyle asks Dion to confirm that on that occasion their parents asked AR to say goodbye to him as he was leaving to see his friends, and in response AR "threw a bottle at you".

    Dion says he had closed the door before the bottle hit.

    "At the time this wasn't a particularly significant event other than it being the last interaction," he tells the inquiry.

  10. Parents 'lost control' of AR, brother sayspublished at 16:26 GMT 4 November

    Jonny Humphries
    BBC News

    Dion Rudakubana says his parents were looking for outside services to help his brother.

    Richard Boyle, one of the counsel to the inquiry, pulls up some records from Lancashire County Council, dated 18 August 2021.

    It refers to AR telling a social worker his dad "hits eight-year-olds and hits Dion". When asked, AR confirmed he was referring to himself when he was aged eight.

    The records referred to Dion telling the social worker that they would get a "smacked bottom for being naughty" when they were younger, but he had no concerns about his dad and had not been hit recently.

    Dion tells the inquiry around that time, AR had read some articles by educational psychologists which suggested physically striking children could traumatise them, and that he felt "very wronged" by being smacked as a young boy.

    Boyle says in his statement, AR and Dion’s father, Alphonse, said he had sometimes smacked the boys when they were little and when they were fighting each other.

    Boyle asks: "Would you agree your parents had lost control of AR?"

    "Erm, yes,” Dion replies.

  11. 'It would have been a heavy risk to punish AR,' brother sayspublished at 16:16 GMT 4 November

    Jonny Humphries
    BBC News

    Dion is asked about how much he knew about his brother's contact with mental health or police services.

    Dion replies he "covered his ears" when discussions were going on "because I didn't want to hear it".

    Boyle asks how his parents reacted to AR's violent behaviour.

    "It was always shocking. I think it was the fear that marked all of these," he says.

    "It was always a response to a quite trying situation, so it didn't make sense to try and punish him. Also, there was a heavy risk in doing so."

    Dion clarifies that he means AR was "not just being naughty” but was struggling to manage situations.

    "I don't know what punishment would have looked like...we said there was a general risk to life in general conversation, if you try to confront him...it wouldn't be responded to well," he says

  12. DR afraid brother would 'kill a member of his family'published at 16:12 GMT 4 November

    Jonny Humphries
    BBC News

    Boyle refers to a message Dion R sent to a friend when he was visiting home from university in 2022.

    The message talked about AR becoming annoyed by him speaking late at night because of the thin walls.

    DR suggested that if AR became violent "too much damage would be caused by my dad trying to restrain him".

    He also told his friend there was a risk of "him doing something potentially fatal".

    He said: "The fights are scary because of the danger of someone dying."

    By that point, in 2022, Dion said he believed his brother had tried to stab his father before, adding that he was not sure.

    Boyle then asks: "By this time you had a serious fear that your brother would kill a member of your family?"

    "If things escalated to that point", he replies.

    DR says he never thought to tell anyone about that fear "because things had been growing gradually".

    "There was no point of alarm to go and report it."

    He adds that he was away from the family home a lot whilst at university.

  13. Dion Rudakubana had 'stopped speaking to his brother by 2023'published at 16:02 GMT 4 November

    Jonny Humphries
    BBC News

    Dion Rudakubana tells the inquiry AR's behaviour became significantly more violent after he was expelled from Range High School in Formby, Merseyside, in October 2019.

    He said: "It opened up to everyone in the house and things are basically getting smashed."

    Mr Boyle asked: "Did that continue on all the way through until 2024?"

    Dion Rudakubana said there were periods of improvement in 2020, but then "progressively got worse again".

    He said after he left for university in 2022, AR spoke to him less "because he was not familiar with having me around", and by 2023 that had gone to "nothing".

  14. Dion Rudakubana 'increasingly wary' of his brotherpublished at 15:53 GMT 4 November

    Jonny Humphries
    BBC News

    Dion Rudakubana was diagnosed with a neuromuscular disorder at the age of 12 which led to him becoming a wheelchair user, and led to his parents him helping more.

    Mr Boyle asked if that changed his relationship with his brother, who the inquiry is referring to as AR.

    “There was tension that came about," he said.

    "Up until that age he got more attention than I did because he was younger than me, so there was a change in focus around that time.”

    He agreed that AR appeared to resent this change.

    Dion Rudakubana confirmed that after the move to Southport, AR's mood appeared to deteriorate, particularly when he moved from primary school to Range High School in Formby.

    He said AR would become "despondent" and have "violent outbursts".

    "You were worried he would try and hit you?" Mr Boyle asked.

    "His frustration was a result of his lower mood...but yeah I was concerned because he was bigger...physically larger and it would hurt more."

    Dion Rudakubana agreed that he became "increasingly wary" of his brother, who would hit him regularly.

    He said he did not recall AR being violent to his parents before he was expelled from Range High School in 2019.

  15. Southport killer's older brother says their conversations were 'intense'published at 15:47 GMT 4 November

    Jonny Humphries
    BBC News

    Dion Rudakubana is being questioned by Richard Boyle, a member of counsel to the inquiry.

    He is asked if his parents ever spoke of their experiences in the Rwandan genocide, which caused them to seek asylum in the UK.

    He replies: “Particular stories, I guess, slowly accumulated over time from 12, 14 years.”

    He is asked if those stories had an impact on their family life.

    “My parents used discretion in telling us, things were left out until we were older,” he explains.

    “I wouldn’t say I was traumatised by them, but I emotionally engaged with them.”

    Mr Boyle asks about what it was like growing up with his younger brother Axel.

    Mr Rudakubana says their conversations were “intense” and “more involved”, likely due to them both being autistic.

    He said his brother would hit him, but in hindsight “that was not unusual for primary school aged boys”.

  16. Dion Rudakubana begins to give evidencepublished at 15:39 GMT 4 November

    Jonny Humphries
    BBC News

    Dion Rudakubana has taken the oath by swearing on the Bible.

    He is appearing on a video link from a remote location, and his image is not being broadcast.

    He confirms that a statement he gave to police is accurate, but is not in chronological order and "lacked nuance".

    He agrees this is likely the case because he is autistic.

    Dion Rudakubana left the family home in 2022 to attend university.

    He confirms he moved to Southport from Cardiff in 2013, when his father Alphonse secured a job as a taxi driver.

  17. Reporting restrictions in placepublished at 15:31 GMT 4 November

    Ian Shoesmith
    BBC News

    Reporting restrictions mean the media are legally prevented from publishing any photograph or voice recording of Dion Rudakubana.

    Journalists are also not allowed to publish any details of his location, education, or workplace.

  18. Dion Rudakubana begins giving evidencepublished at 15:29 GMT 4 November

    Ian Shoesmith
    BBC News

    After a longer than anticipated adjournment, proceedings have now resumed at Liverpool Town Hall

    Dion Rudakubana is now giving evidence to the public inquiry set up to examine his brother's fatal attack on a Taylor Swift-themed dance class in Southport on 29 July 2024.

  19. Dion Rudakubana preparing to give evidencepublished at 15:10 GMT 4 November

    Ian Shoesmith
    BBC News

    The hearing is about to resume at Liverpool Town Hall - technical arrangements have been made to allow the Southport attacker's brother to give evidence remotely.

  20. X boss completes her evidencepublished at 14:48 GMT 4 November

    Jonny Humphries
    BBC News

    Ms Khananisho is then questioned by William Chapman, counsel to the families of the three murdered girls.

    Mr Chapman asks about how the algorithm serves content to its users, and whether an interest in violence would cause X to offer up more violent content.

    Ms Khananisho says she does not know.

    She also says she is unaware of any research into the link between online and real-world violence.

    That completes Ms Khananisho's evidence, and she is thanked by chairman Sir Adrian Fulford.

    There will now be a short break of about 20 minutes while a technical arrangements are made for Axel Rudakubana's brother, Dion Rudakubana, to give evidence remotely.