Swinney is promising nothing, claims Rosspublished at 15:55 British Summer Time 4 September
The Scottish Conservative leader says the Programme for Government was the first minister's "big moment" to "boldly launch" his premiership as first minister.
"Has he really been waiting 25 years to deliver that speech we just listened to?" Ross says.
"Because what we got was a programme of tired old promises that should have been delivered years ago."
Ross says the first minister is making it impossible for his government to fail by "promising nothing".