Leaders clash over the Budgetpublished at 12:16 Greenwich Mean Time 31 October
Philip Sim
BBC Scotland political correspondent
Labour have joined the SNP in backing tax rises, which is fish in a barrel stuff for Russell Findlay as Scottish Tory leader.
He can claim to be “on the side of Scotland’s taxpayers” from the fairly safe position of opposition, where neither he nor his colleagues have to worry about taking tough decisions or balancing the books.
What was remarkable about this exchange was the fact that the first minister didn’t include any criticism of the UK government.
John Swinney’s first answer could have been written by Rachel Reeves, as he tore into the “horror show” that the previous Conservative administration left behind at Westminster.
He could also wield Mr Findlay’s previous backing for Liz Truss – for all that he is seeking a fresh start as Tory leader, his party’s actions in government at Westminster are still fresh in the memory.