Summary

Media caption,

Sea swimmers share their views on water quality

  1. Water review a 'reset moment'published at 18:36 British Summer Time

    George Thorpe
    BBC News, South West

    Sarah Heald, South West Water's chief strategy and regulation officer

    Sarah Heald, South West Water's chief strategy and regulation officer, has told the BBC improvements to the region's water quality will be a team effort.

    She adds the the Cunliffe Report published into the water industry could help provide change in the future.

    Ms Heald says: "I think as we all saw yesterday with the Cunliffe review, we all recognise that a reset moment is required in the industry. And not just in our industry.

    "I think one of the great things that came out of the report is it recognises that the water system is indeed that - it's a system that has many stakeholders of which we are one.

    "We are custodians of clean and wastewater in this region, but have others in this region who also have responsibility and we all need to work together to improve the quality of our water ways."

  2. BBC Spotlight about to beginpublished at 18:22 British Summer Time

    Don't miss BBC Spotlight at 18:30 BST on BBC One and BBC iPlayer for the latest on water quality across the South West.

    Victoria Graham is smiling as she stands next to a screen that reads BBC Spotlight. She is wearing a blue blouse and has a blonde bob.
  3. 'System is at bursting point'published at 18:11 British Summer Time

    George Thorpe
    BBC News, South West

    Tim Selbie stands in front of a wall along the coast of Devil's Point in Plymouth. AA blue and white sign is next to him with safety advice about sea swimming.

    Tim Selbie was about to dive into the water at Devil's Point when he spoke to me.

    The 66-year-old who lives in Plymouth says he tries to go out in the sea once a day between March and October as it was a "lovely environment" to be in and helps bring him peace of mind.

    He says there were sometimes issues due to sewage overflows impacting the water quality.

    "I avoid going out after heavy rain and leave it to settle down again after a couple of days."

    He feels South West Water prioritises shareholders over updating its equipment, which would take a "very long time" to sort out.

    Mr Selbie says the company needed to think about the number of tourists who visit the area as well and want to swim in the sea.

    "The system's at bursting point, probably," he adds.

  4. Water quality 'super important' in Cawsandpublished at 17:52 British Summer Time

    Kirk England
    BBC South West environment and tourism correspondent

    People and boats sit on the sands at the beach in Cawsands.

    I'm in Cawsand on the Rame Peninsula in Cornwall and it's absolutely beautiful.

    I'm sitting on a wooden bench and there's a child with a snorkel and a wetsuit who's just dipped under the water.

    There's a boat which has been on a trip and dropped people off before going off again.

    People are queueing up to have an ice-cream, so it's pretty stunning and fantastic.

    There was a little bit of drizzle earlier, but the sun's come out a bit and it's looks absolutely splendid.

    I've been talking to people here and they've said water quality is "super important".

    One trader I've spoken to said it is one thing tourists check before they arrive and they expect good quality water and want to know if they can go into the water safely.

  5. We need the river to stay beautiful, says paddleboarderpublished at 17:34 British Summer Time

    A paddleboard instructor has been speaking to BBC Radio Cornwall's James Churchfield about how water quality affects her line of work.

  6. Regular sea swimmer wants to see 'obvious' improvementspublished at 17:18 British Summer Time

    George Thorpe
    BBC News, South West

    Colin Hargreaves stands by the water's edge in Devil's Point in Plymouth. A Brittany Ferry is in the background. He is wearing a navy blue robe.

    While I was down at Devil's Point in Plymouth, I spoke to local 70-year-old sea swimmer Colin Hargreaves moments after he got out of the water.

    He says he loves sea swimming and does it three or four times a week, with benefits for both his physical and mental health.

    However, there have been times when he has spotted sewage out in the water while swimming.

    "Sometimes there's a smell and sometimes there's a patchy scum that you have to be a bit aware of," he says.

    Mr Hargreaves adds he would like to see South West Water make more improvements to the networks they operate.

    He says: "We get these stories from the media about bonuses and the bills are going to go up again, but we can't swim in the sea sometimes.

    "I think they need to try harder [to make improvements] and it needs to be quite obvious. We need to be seeing it happen."

  7. What's happened so far?published at 16:49 British Summer Time

    If you're just joining us, here is a quick recap of some of the top lines from earlier:

  8. Parasite outbreak cost firm millions of poundspublished at 16:38 British Summer Time

    Three men wearing hi-viz uniforms are standing near pallets piled high with bottled water in a car park.

    The outbreak of cryptosporidium in and around Brixham last year cost South West Water (SWW) about £21m.

    Pennon Group, which owns SWW, reported a pre-tax loss of £72.7m for the year to the end of March 2025, which was up from a £9.1m loss reported the previous year.

    It said a large portion of the loss was linked to costs around the outbreak of the parasite, which left more than 100 people suffering from a diarrhoea-type illness.

    In May SWW boss Susan Davy apologised unreservedly over the outbreak.

  9. 'Sewage overflows are part of life'published at 16:10 British Summer Time

    George Thorpe
    BBC News, South West

    Carrie and John stand next to eachother smiling at the camera. They are leaning on a granite wall and there is a building behind them and some hedge. Carrie has short dark blonde hair and is wearing a bright flowery top and John has short grey hair and is wearing a burgundy jumper.

    I was in Devil's Point in Plymouth where I found a father and daughter admiring the view across the water.

    Carrie Smith, a former civil engineer who was visiting her father, says planning for sewage overflows has been "part of life".

    "If your sewers are going to overflow, it's better to overflow into water rather than up the street," she says.

    "You need the upkeep of your infrastructure and perhaps that hasn't been done successfully."

    John Prisk believes the issue is "over-hyped".

    "Sometimes the more vociferous you are, the more attention you get," he says.

    "The people who are happy swimming don't complain about it."

  10. Two pollution incidents killed fish in South West riverspublished at 15:54 British Summer Time

    George Thorpe
    BBC News, South West

    A variety of dead fish and eels lined up on a rock.Image source, Three Bay's Wildlife Group

    In June, thousands of fish including trout, eels and lamprey died in the St Austell River – also known as the White River.

    Pennon Group said the pollution was caused by “a delivery by a third party to our treatment works” in the Pentewan Valley.

    On 1 July, the Environment Agency said it was investigating another incident involving fish killed by pollution in the River Lew, near Okehampton, which had been reported the previous day.

    An agency spokesperson said about 90 fish died.

  11. What are water levels like in Somerset?published at 15:43 British Summer Time

    David Braine
    BBC South West senior broadcast meterologist

    Over the border resources in the Wessex water catchment area are well below average.

    An average of 46mm of rain fell across the catchment area in June - 76% of the long-term average

    This is the fourth consecutive relatively dry month, resulting in the driest four-month period from March to June since 1976, and the fourth driest four-month period since records began in 1871

    Both Wessex Water and Bristol Water reservoir levels continued to decrease throughout June.

    The combined levels at the end of June for Wessex Water were approximately 71% capacity, while combined levels were about 66% capacity for Bristol Water.

    For both water companies this is notably lower than reservoir levels recorded this time last year. For Wessex Water, reservoir levels at the end of June are slightly higher than this time of year in 1995 - considered a major drought year. For Bristol Water, levels are lower than at the end of June 1995.

  12. 'You just feel great afterwards. It's a feel-good factor'published at 15:30 British Summer Time

    Swimmers share what they love about getting in the water in Cornwall and what they want to change.

    Media caption,

    Lisa Young has been speaking to swimmers at Gyllyngvase.

  13. 'I almost prefer not to know'published at 14:45 British Summer Time

    Lisa Young
    BBC News, South West

    I caught up with Robert after he came out of the water on Gyllyngvase Beach.

    He's on holiday from York and says he never checks water quality before he swims, telling me: "I almost prefer not to know.

    "The water looks quite clear to me but I guess that might be concealing things that I don't want to know about.

    "It was beautiful, very refreshing."

    The beach and sea at Gyllngvase Beach. There is a RNLI lifeguard yellow and red flag is in the foreground lying flat as there is no wind. In the sea there are three swimmers in wetsuits wearing swimming caps and they are standing together with water up to their knees. The sea is calm and there is a headland visible across the other side of the bay.
  14. We feel better the further west we get - touristspublished at 14:12 British Summer Time

    Lisa Young
    BBC News, South West

    Harry and Tamzin stand together on the beach smiling broadly at the camera. Harry has short brown hair and is wearing a T-shirt and a towel wrapped around his waist. Tamzin is wearing a DryRobe and has long and curly blonde hair piled up in a bun. Behind them the sea is calm and it is slightly cloudy. On the headland Pendennis Castle is visible.

    Harry and Tamzin, who live in Bristol, were spending some of their holiday on Gyllyngvase Beach in Falmouth.

    They say they usually check the Surfers Against Sewage website but did not this morning.

    Tamzin says: "We've just been in and it felt lovely, it looks nice and it looks clean."

    They told me they are originally from Southampton, where they swam in the Solent.

    Harry says: "The Solent is notoriously not very clean and there's been periods where we haven't been able to swim down there because it's not been clean enough, the water quality has been too low.

    "I generally feel better the more west we get - I don't know if that's true but it just generally feels nicer."

  15. A quick recappublished at 14:01 British Summer Time

    Throughout the day we are taking a close look at water quality issues in Devon and Cornwall. If you're just joining us here's a quick look at what's happened so far:

  16. I just take the risk, says swimmerpublished at 13:33 British Summer Time

    Lisa Young
    BBC News, South West

    Gilly is standing on the beach and is smiling at the camera. She is wearing a cap and a bright pink airtex T-shirt and is clasping her hands togther. behind her is a lifeguard's paddleboard and a swimming zone flag. The sea is calm and there is a cargo ship on the horizon.

    I caught up with swimmer Gilly Mead after her dip at Gyllyngvase Beach in Falmouth.

    She lives near Stithians and swims at least once a week "when the mood takes me".

    Earlier this morning the water was "a bit murky" - but she says "that's not anyone else's fault, just the weather".

    Her friend regularly checks water quality apps but she says she prefers just to get in.

    "I just take the risk, really," she says.

  17. What are storm overflows and why are they an issue?published at 13:21 British Summer Time

    Lisa Young
    BBC News, South West

    A storm drain next to a beach. It is built into the quay wall and water is pouring out of it to join the sea. There is seaweed on the beach and people are lying on the sandy part of it. There are a number of beach-related businesses in the buildings lining the beach and quay.

    The government describes storm overflows as "safety valves" built into the combined sewer system.

    When there is extensive rainfall, excess sewage is discharged into rivers, lakes or the sea through the system.

    This protects properties from flooding and stops sewage backing up in homes and streets, the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs says.

    Campaigners say discharges from storm overflows can contain raw sewage which can contain high levels of harmful bacteria and viruses, and other pollutants such as microplastics and pharmaceuticals.

  18. 'I can see a brown slick going across the water'published at 13:09 British Summer Time

    Lisa Young
    BBC News, South West

    I've been on Gyllyngvase Beach in Falmouth speaking to swimmers about the quality of the water.

    Angela Ratcliffe, who lives in the Cornish town, told me she gets in the water nearly every day.

    "I'm disabled and so if I get in there I'm not disabled," she says.

    "I can do exercises and everything in there without being in pain."

    She says she loves the water but she knows when not to get in.

    "At home I look out and can see a brown slick going across and quite often there's a lot of scum," she says.

    "I think it's because they've built so many houses - the infrastructure cannot take it."

    Angela is standing on the shore smiling at the camera. She has crutches and is wearing a swimming costume and a pair of sunglasses. The bay is behind her and there is a large cargo ship on the horizon. The water looks clear.