Summary

Media caption,

Starmer says UK 'cannot ignore' threat Russia poses

  1. Wide-ranging measures announced, but budget still in questionpublished at 20:16 British Summer Time 2 June

    Tinshui Yeung
    Live page editor

    Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer speaks during a visit to BAE Systems in Govan, GlasgowImage source, PA Media

    The government’s message is clear: the world has changed, so the UK’s defence must change too.

    Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, along with the US asking Nato countries to spend more on defence, is the backdrop to today’s strategic defence review.

    The measures in the report are wide-ranging – from better housing for armed forces to building up to 12 attack submarines. All of this is backed by extra government funding, with a pledge to raise defence spending to 2.5% by 2027-28, aiming for 3% by the next parliament.

    But is it enough? MPs in parliament have asked this question repeatedly after John Healey made his statement.

    Our analysis shows that to meet all the goals of making the UK’s armed forces ready for war, more money will be needed.

    John Healey says a defence investment plan, described as a new investment framework, will be published in the autumn.

    While details of this investment plan are still unclear, one thing is certain: the review marks a dramatic change in how the armed forces will fight in the future, as our defence correspondent Jonathan Beale writes.

    You can read his analysis, check out all the key points of the strategy defence review, or read our full news piece.

    We’re ending our live coverage for today. Thanks for joining us.

  2. Union welcomes defence funding increase but urges UK to go furtherpublished at 20:07 British Summer Time 2 June

    Unite, the UK's biggest union, which represents tens of thousands of defence workers, says it welcomes the government's pledge to increase defence spending.

    But general secretary Sharon Graham is calling for the UK to go further and "commit to invest in UK jobs".

    Unite describes the announcement of new nuclear submarines as "a great start", but is also urging the government to commit to new orders of helicopters and fighter jets.

    "Countries that want to do us harm won’t wait and nor can the UK," Graham adds.

    Members of staff watch Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer during a visit to BAE Systems in Govan, GlasgowImage source, PA Media
    Image caption,

    Defence workers watch Prime Minister Keir Starmer during his visit to a Glasgow shipyard today

  3. Analysis

    Navy, air force and army told to work togetherpublished at 19:59 British Summer Time 2 June

    Douglas Fraser
    Scotland business & economy editor

    Any previous defence review would have featured a battle for resources between the three uniformed services. This one barely mentions them, until page 104.

    The Royal Navy, the British Army and Royal Air Force would still have roles, and their identity. But the main role they're being given is to park their differences and work with each other, putting the chief of the defence staff in charge.

    So instead of a battle over preserving traditions, this review implicitly consigns much of that to the regimental museums. It's telling traditionalists to embrace cyber, data and drones.

    The biggest change would be for the Royal Navy. As platforms for long-range missiles and autonomous drones, it's not clear if it still requires two aircraft carriers. The review acknowledges they're there to stay, but looks to a future with a cheaper, more flexible fleet, much of it under water, and defending subsea infrastructure.

    Two British soldiersImage source, Getty Images
  4. Analysis

    Review marks dramatic change in how army will fight in futurepublished at 19:47 British Summer Time 2 June

    Jonathan Beale
    Defence correspondent

    The review marks a dramatic change in the way the armed forces will fight in the future - with drones, software and artificial intelligence. There'll still be heavy metal, like tanks, fighter jets and warships, but working more alongside autonomous systems.

    One of the review's authors, Gen Richard Barrons, described it as the greatest transformation in the armed forces in more than 150 years.

    The war in Ukraine has already shown that technology is changing the way war is fought. It's that war, on European soil, which has highlighted the rising threats and the need to invest more in defence and innovate faster.

    It has also underlined the need for what the report calls “a whole of society” approach. The armed forces are only as strong as the society and industry that stands behind it.

  5. Analysis

    Over 2.5% of GDP needed to fund the defence planspublished at 19:31 British Summer Time 2 June

    Jonathan Beale
    Defence correspondent

    This review was asked to make its recommendations within the budgetary constraints of the government spending 2.5% of GDP on defence.

    But it is already clear that to meet all its goals of making the UK's armed forces ready for war, there will have to be more money.

    The review welcomes the government's "ambition" to spend 3% in the 2030s and adds that "as we live in more turbulent times it may be necessary to go faster".

    Some of the team's recommendations, including a small increase in the size of the regular army when economic conditions allow, have not yet been funded.

    A defence source told the BBC that even the government's commitment to build up to 12 new attack submarines would require an increase in defence spending to at least 3% of GDP.

    Ministers say they believe they will reach that target in the next Parliament, but there are no timelines or guarantees.

    Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer (centre) speaks to a member of staff during a visit to BAE Systems in Govan, GlasgowImage source, PA Media
    Image caption,

    Keir Starmer visited BAE Systems in Govan, Glasgow earlier today

  6. Government faces criticism on defence review releasepublished at 19:14 British Summer Time 2 June

    Keir Starmer in black suit, white shirt and blue tie delivers speech at lectern, a group of workers in uniform behind himImage source, Reuters

    Shortly before the session concluded, Conservative MP James Cartlidge said it was "disappointing" that some MPs didn't receive the strategic defence review (SDR) earlier - saying he had heard reports of major defence companies having received it this morning.

    He says he was "begging" the minister of the armed forces for a copy of the SDR, but was refused.

    Cartlidge says he wants to know how the MPs can hold the government to account when it comes to "commercial sensitivity".

    Before the statement, there was some political wrangling in the House of Commons over where and how Prime Minister Keir Starmer should have delivered this morning's defence spending plans.

    For context: The ministerial code states that the most important announcements of Government policy should be made in the first instance in Parliament when it is in session.

    Speaker of the House Lindsay Hoyle made a note describing Keir Starmer's announcement this morning as a "blatant breach of the ministerial code".

    Leader of the House Lucy Powell, however, rejected the accusations and noted that the government has brought a number of matters to the House of Commons in the first instance - pointing out that the defence secretary would shortly be delivering a speech.

  7. Questions to defence secretary endpublished at 19:05 British Summer Time 2 June

    A little over an hour and a half after John Healey's statement started, the question session from the members of Parliament concludes.

    We will bring you a recap of the session soon, so stick with us.

  8. Steps being taken to ensure decent home standards met in military housingpublished at 18:45 British Summer Time 2 June

    Lib Dems' Calum Miller asks if John Healey can commit to making sure military housing meets the decent home standard.

    Healey says it's right to raise the issue, but adds that "we can't turn this round overnight".

    He says the government has already taken steps this year to address it, including bringing "36,000 military homes back into public control".

  9. Focus on 'real security, not weapons which must never be used' - Greens MPpublished at 18:38 British Summer Time 2 June

    Ellie Chowns in light grey blazer and matching jeans stands in House of Commons, green leather benches behind her and colleagues sitting to her right and leftImage source, UK Parliament

    In the last few minutes, we've heard from Green Party MP Ellie Chowns, who accuses the government of "confusing security with spending more on weapons".

    She says that instead of "wasting £15bn on nuclear warheads - weapons which must never be used" they should instead focus on "real security" which involves diplomacy, decent housing, tackling the climate crisis and pandemic preparedness.

    Healey responds that the government is strengthening the armed forces to "secure the peace, not to fight the war".

    He says "we deter the attacks that we fear by being strong enough to defeat our enemies".

    Healey adds that this has helped to keep the stability in Europe for over 75 year and it's been the "ultimate guarantee of our national security".

    "It is what Putin fears most," he says.

  10. BBC Verify

    Can higher defence spending really be 'an engine' for UK growth?published at 18:32 British Summer Time 2 June

    By Ben Chu

    John Healey (L) and Keir Starmer (C) listen to a BAE employee (R) speaking as they visit the defence firm's headquarters in Glasgow. All three are wearing yellow hi-vi jackets while inside what looks like a hangarImage source, PA Media
    Image caption,

    Healey and Starmer say new defence investment will create new jobs and boost growth

    The Strategic Defence Review states it will make defence “an engine for growth across the UK”.

    Is that feasible?

    There is no official measure of the contribution of defence manufacturers to the UK economy, but one of the main lobby organisations for the sector - ADS - estimates it contributed around £12bn in 2023, external.

    That’s equivalent to around 0.5% of total UK economic output in that year.

    The Ministry of Defence also estimates, external that its spending with contractors directly supports around 134,000 jobs in UK industry.

    Increased domestic defence spending of billions of pounds a year would likely boost those figures and mean defence making a larger contribution to UK GDP and employment than it currently does.

    However, some of this could be economic activity that is effectively shifted from other sectors of the economy, if the government reduces state spending in areas such as transport and energy infrastructure to be able to spend more on defence.

    In other words, the growth in output from defence industries would not necessarily be additional economic activity but could be activity which is moved around.

  11. Government to work with DfE to increase recruitmentpublished at 18:21 British Summer Time 2 June

    Back to the Conservatives, MP Mike Wood asks if the government will work with the Department for Education (DfE) to expand cadet forces into more state schools.

    Healey says the government will work with the DfE to ramp up the number of cadets by 30% by 2030.

    "It offers a unique opportunity for many young people. Skills, experience that makes a transformation to their prospects," he says.

  12. SNP doubles-down on defence review fundingpublished at 18:16 British Summer Time 2 June

    SNP MP Kirsty Blackman in burgundy tartan dress with blue and yellow chequers stands in house of Commons. She has short brown hair, a necklace around her neck and a watch around her left wrist. She's holding a pen and notebookImage source, UK Parliament

    We've been hearing from the SNP's Kirtsy Blackman, who also asks where the money for the defence review will come from.

    "He can’t even provide clarity on where the money is coming from," she says after listing a series of issues not addressed in his earlier statement.

    "Can the Secretary of State provide some answers, on what on earth they've spent the last year reviewing?" she says.

    Healey replies that the government has spent the last 10 months "delivering on defence", repeating that they have "put in the largest defence spending since the end of the Cold War".

    "We're delivering for defence. This is a government that will do more and the SDR gives us the vision and direction to do that," he answers.

  13. Defence secretary quizzed on investment plans to fund reviewpublished at 18:08 British Summer Time 2 June

    The Conservative Party's John Glenn presses Healey on where the money will come from to fund the SDR.

    John Healey talks about the defence investment plan, which he says is a new investment framework and programme developed in line with the SDR vision.

    He says the work on this new investment plan will be completed and published in the autumn.

  14. Healey 'determined' to reverse decline of armed forces personnelpublished at 18:02 British Summer Time 2 June

    Defence Secretary John Healey answers questions in the House of Commons in black suit, white shirt and red tieImage source, UK Parliament

    Liberal Democrat MP Ian Roome asks what more the government will do to ensure the armed forces are recruiting personnel.

    Healey says Roome is "right" to highlight that people are at the heart of defence. He says he has removed over 100 rules that prevented some people from joining the armed forces, among other measures.

    The defence secretary says there will be better pay and housing.

    "It's going to take time, we are closing the gap, but I'm determined that we will reverse that long term decline," he says.

  15. Healey pressed on defence spending timelinepublished at 17:47 British Summer Time 2 June

    Conservative MP Edward Leigh asks Healey whether the government will commit to defence spending of 3.5% "not as an ambition, but by a set date".

    Healey responds that the government has already put in a "historic" increase in defence spending, noting an extra £5bn have already been put in since Labour took over.

    Healey reiterates that there is a commitment and a plan to increase defence spending to 2.5% by 2027-28 and to 3% by the next parliament.

  16. Ex-defence minister challenges Healey on Chagos dealpublished at 17:40 British Summer Time 2 June

    James Cartlidge stands in front of despatch box in black suit, white shirt and burgundy tie, to his left, sitting on green leather bench is MP Mark FrancoisImage source, UK Parliament

    In the Commons, former defence minister and Tory MP James Cartlidge uses his response to the defence review statement to criticise Healey about the Chagos Islands deal.

    "The one plan they can guarantee is the one to give billions to Mauritius for land we currently own freehold," he says.

    Healey responds that the deal is a "great investment" in the defence and intelligence base shared with the US. He then lists those who have backed it, citing the US, Nato and India among others as he asks how the opposition party have got themselves "on the wrong side".

    For more on this - head to our explainer.

  17. Analysis

    Today marks a significant turning pointpublished at 17:31 British Summer Time 2 June

    Douglas Fraser
    Scotland business & economy editor

    In more than 30 years since the end of the Cold War, various governments have deployed the reduced defence spending dividend on other priorities, from tax cuts to the health service.

    But this announcement marks a turning point. This spending review looks to be far more significant than any we have seen for decades.

    For a start, ambitions seem to be getting narrower, focussed on the 'Euro Atlantic' area. That is a change from the last review's tilt towards being a power player in waters around Asia.

    But this review, led by Lord George Robertson, who has served as a Scottish Labour MP, defence secretary and secretary-general of the Nato alliance, is patching up some big gaps much closer to home.

    The emphasis is on a shift to combat readiness, which means stepping up preparations for war with an estimate that a Russian attack on Nato could come in two or three years.

    The emphasis is also on the industrial capacity that lies behind that fighting machine.

    Because of stop-start funding and buying in batches instead of funding private companies to continue production of weapons systems, the UK lacks the ability to sustain its front line operations.

  18. Defence secretary statement concludespublished at 17:24 British Summer Time 2 June

    Wide shot on inside of House of Commons with MPs seen sitting on green leather benches, John Healey standing as he addresses the OppositionImage source, UK Parliament

    Healey's statement on the defence review has ended.

    He's now facing questions from members of Parliament.

    Stick with us as we bring you the latest.

  19. Government working on initiatives to drive up cadets numberpublished at 17:21 British Summer Time 2 June

    Healey continues to say that the review sets a "new vision".

    The defence secretary says work to confirm a new defence investment plan will be completed in the autumn to ensure frontline forces "get what they need".

    He continues to say that fewer families now have a "direct connection" to the forces - which is why the government is looking at initiatives including increasing the number of cadets and introducing a voluntary gap year scheme.

  20. Defence review plans to create more than 31,000 jobs, Healey sayspublished at 17:19 British Summer Time 2 June

    Healey says the defence review will be an "engine for growth" and it will create jobs in the UK.

    He says the government will commit £15bn into sovereign warhead program, which will create over 9,000 jobs.

    He adds that the government will build 12 submarines that will help create 20,000 jobs.

    Healey says they will invest £6bn to build six new munition factories and up to 7,000 long range weapons supporting nearly 2,000 jobs.