Summary

  • Labour say they would end non-domicile tax status

  • But a video emerges of Ed Balls saying the policy would cost the country money

  • The Tories say the plans are "a shambles"

  • Pupils who fail their Sats tests will have to resit under a future Conservative government

  • There are 29 days until the general election

  1. Get involvedpublished at 12.59

    Email: politics@bbc.co.uk

    Mark Watson, Thame, Oxon:

    Re: the rich paying their fair share of tax :

    Someone on 100k will pay around 35k in tax and NI, someone on 20k will pay around 3k. Seems like the rich are paying more than their fair share.

  2. Two non-dom statuses?published at 12.55

    Chris Leslie

    And now here’s another member of Ed Balls’ shadow Treasury team having a bash at defending his party’s non-doms announcement. He has rather cleverly introduced the word ‘other’ into the messaging - keep an eye out for it. Speaking on The Jeremy Vine Show on BBC Radio 2, he said Labour had found a way of abolishing non-dom status while raising money. "By creating this temporary residency for a couple of years for legitimate people who come and do business in this country we can make that distinction from that other non-dom loophole which has got to go and is costing us a fortune," he said. Yes, the shadow chief secretary to the Treasury conceded, “one or two” non-doms might leave the UK as a result of Labour’s plans. But most would ultimately stay and pay tax, he insisted. The policy, in Mr Leslie’s view, is "ultimately... a question about whose side are you on?"

  3. Cameron on non-domspublished at 12.49

    Here's a bit more about what the PM has to say on the non-dom story.Speaking in Bolton, David Cameron said Labour was offering itself as a potential government but "can't even run one tax policy without making a complete mess of it". He said the coalition had raised “billions” tackling tax evasion and aggressive tax avoidance, but that today “what you see is total chaos and confusion from Labour”. Mr Cameron added: "One minute saying they're going to scrap the status, the next minute saying it would cost the country money. Frankly this goes to the bigger picture, if these people can't even sort out one policy, how on earth could anyone trust them to run the economy?”

  4. Pic: Cameron's school trippublished at 12.46

    Carole Walker
    Political correspondent

    David CameronImage source, BC
    Image caption,

    David Cameron, visiting a school in Bolton, says there is total chaos and confusion over Labour's non-dom policy

  5. Non-dom 'pragmatism'published at 12.45

    Daily Politics
    Live on BBC Two

    Simon Hughes

    Liberal Democrat MP Simon Hughes says his party had tried to abolish inheritance of non-dom status in the coalition but it hadn’t quite worked out. Still, he tells the Daily Politics, the coalition blocked non-doms from sitting in the Lords and the levy they pay was twice increased. He says the bottom line is what benefits the "UK economy" - or does he mean Treasury coffers?

    Quote Message

    “We have a very uncomplicated view: you’ve got to make a judgement that’s pragmatic in the interests of the economy. In the interests of the economy, it seems to us, we can raise money from keeping the status rather than abolishing it.”

    Simon Hughes, Lib Dem justice minister

  6. Get involvedpublished at 12.42

    Text: 61124

    BBC News website reader:

    UKIP have hit the nail on the head over the armed services policy, and shows the groundswell of public support for veterans, that politicians can only dream of. It also shows UKIP have a finger on the public pulse, & are not just a 1 trick pony over uncontrolled immigration

  7. Non-dom 'abuses'published at 12.38

    Daily Politics
    Live on BBC Two

    Nick Gibb

    Nick Gibb, an education minister, says the Conservatives think anybody earning money in the UK should be paying tax in this country. That’s why they’ve introduced the profits diversion tax, stamp duty on non-doms’ property and taken tax avoidance seriously. “We will look at all abuses,” he pledges.

  8. #nondom trending on Twitterpublished at 12.37

    @uzmanies tweets:, external

    Quote Message

    It's always the same as soon as the rich are asked to pay their fair share there's an uproar. If you don't like it pack your bags #nondom

    @SimonMoores tweets:, external

    Quote Message

    Car crash interview by .@ShabanaMahmood on #bbcsp on #nondom - no figures - no evidence could be damaging to economy but morally justifiable

  9. No tweaks herepublished at 12.35

    Daily Politics
    Live on BBC Two

    Shabana Mahmood

    Reform, tweak or abolish? It sounds like a terrible quiz show. But that is the question put to shadow Treasury minister Shabana Mahmood at the end of a rather painful interview on the Daily Politics. She's pressed on whether Labour is actually planning on scrapping the non-domicile rule… or not. “This is not a reform. No, this is not a reform and it’s not a tweak… we are abolishing the non-dom rule,” she says. The temporary resident exemption is entirely separate, apparently.

  10. Explaining Ballspublished at 12.32

    Daily Politics
    Live on BBC Two

    Quote Message

    “What he [Ed Balls] was referring to was not that we didn’t want to do something about non-doms and prevent the situation where permanent residents can avoid paying tax because their father was born abroad. He was referring to a temporary residence exemption that exists in other taxation systems. That‘s something we were looking at then, it’s something that we will consult on in government to make sure we get things right so that genuine temporary residents are prevented from being brought in.”

    Shabana Mahmood, shadow Treasury minister

  11. Parliamentary sketchespublished at 12.29

    A couple who used their own drawings to complete a football World Cup sticker album have been sketching party leaders ahead of May's election.

    Composite image showing Panini Cheapskates' drawing of David Cameron, and the prime minister's photographImage source, PANINI CHEAPSKATES/PA

    Alex and Sian Pratchett, from Oxford, are dubbed the "Panini Cheapskates". Mr Pratchett admitted the couple's artistic talents had not improved since last year's tournament.

    Readers can judge for themselves from the above attempt at David Cameron, and view more sketches in our report.

  12. Non-dom question markspublished at 12.27

    Daily Politics
    Live on BBC Two

    Shabana Mahmood

    Shadow Treasury minister Shabana Mahmood, confronted with the Ed Balls clip on the Daily Politics, prefers to focus on the broader approach being taken by Labour: “We have announced we will get rid of non-dom status so it won’t be possible for you to be permanently living here but somehow claim you’re not really because your dad was born abroad.” Pressed on the issue of whether the changes will end up costing Britain money, she says today’s announcements are set to raise “hundreds of millions of pounds”. The Institute for Fiscal Studies say they’re not sure exactly what the answer is, Andrew Neil points out, as there are too many unknowns. And Ms Mahmood struggles to say where she’s getting her figures from. “There are a number of people who’ve said it could raise hundreds of millions,” Ms Mahmood says. She just can’t name any right now.

  13. Gut feelingspublished at 12.20

    Daily Politics
    Live on BBC Two

    Matthew Parris

    Times columnist and ex-MP Matthew Parris is on the Daily Politics show offering his views about the campaign. “I have the gut feeling that the Conservatives are going to do better than the polls suggest,” he says. “When I go canvassing… I get a sense of quite a strong and solid Conservative feeling in my part of the country. But the polls don’t suggest it, so we’re all baffled.” That view certainly reflects the Tories’ confidence about the national picture voiced by MPs before parliament was dissolved.

  14. BBC story: Labour would scrap 'non-dom' tax statuspublished at 12.18

    Your comments

    mytwopeneth comments on this story :

    Quote Message

    Can't you see Ed is dumbing down the complex issue of tax because he assumes the public are dumb and just wants to pit rich against not-so-rich (we're not poor).

    more duck houses comments:

    Quote Message

    Why should anybody live in this country and not pay their fair share of taxes? Brilliant move by Ed Miliband. Tories out defending the one rule for the rich and another for everyone else again!

  15. Referendum tensionspublished at 12.16

    Daily Politics
    Live on BBC Two

    Nicola SturgeonImage source, Getty Images

    Scotland is completely divided on the issue of the independence question - it's therefore divided on the question of whether there should be another referendum, BBC Scotland's Political Editor Brian Taylor tells the Daily Politics. What Nicola Sturgeon was trying to say when she got booed last night is this is not a question to be determined by the next Westminster parliament. She wants to wait until next year but she is under pressure to try and pre-empt that decision, to say whether it is likely. You know what? She'll hold that referendum on independence when she thinks she can win.

  16. Policy 'will raise money': Milibandpublished at 12:09

    A little more from the Warwick speech on Mr Miliband's non-dom policy and the matter of whether it will raise money. He believes it will but is "cautious" to estimate how much.

    Quote Message

    "We can see from the independent estimates that there are that it's going to raise money. You've seen respected independent people out there saying that it is going to raise resources. I believe it will raise resources, at least hundreds of millions of pounds."

    He describes the decision to abolish the status as a moral decision, as well as a practical one.

  17. 'I've been edited'published at 12.10

    Ed Balls blogImage source, Ed Balls / Labour

    And now Ed Balls has written a blog, external complaining that the Tories have "edited my words". (A little note: The footage was from a BBC Leeds interview, but it was the Conservatives who cut out the bit where Mr Balls says "I think we can be tougher and we should be and we will.") On his blog, the shadow chancellor says: “That is exactly what we have proposed – ending a situation where people permanently living in the UK year after year can claim non-domicile status to reduce their tax bills and play by different rules to everyone else.” He says Labour was working on the plans announced today when he made those comments back in January.

  18. Get involvedpublished at 11.08

    Text: 61124

    Ed, Middlesex:

    How can we say benefit fraud is 1% when it mostly unknown. From what I see it is huge.

  19. Tom Bradby, political editor, ITV Newspublished at 11:59 British Summer Time 8 April 2015

    @tombradby

    tweets:, external

    Quote Message

    If it is all about encouraging rich people to 'invest', why don't we let all rich people off tax so they can 'invest' too?"

    tweets:, external

    Quote Message

    Of course we wouldn't do that, because it would be manifestly absurd."

  20. Corporation tax 'loopholes'published at 11:55

    The left-leaning think tank, the Centre for Labour and Social Studies, hails the non-dom announcement as a "huge step forward for tax justice in the UK". It wants the next government to go further by closing corporation tax loopholes which allow companies like Amazon and Starbucks to avoid significant amounts of tax.

    Quote Message

    More than 400 of the 800 largest businesses in the UK paid less than £10m in corporation tax in 2012/13 and around 160 paid no corporation tax at all."