Adding uppublished at 12:32
Daily Politics
Live on BBC Two
Shadow employment minister Stephen Timms says the Tory proposal is "a pretty implausible and panicky gimmick". He says "the numbers don't add up" and suggests that the Tories could put VAT up and then pass the law, rendering it somewhat meaningless.
On Labour's plans to increase the top rate of income tax to 50p, Mr Timms won't be more specific than predicting that it will "bring in a very worthwhile sum". He admits that "I don't know the figure". The Institute for Fiscal Studies, Mr Timms is helpfully informed, thinks it will only bring in £110m. That's a "useful" and "worthwhile sum", Mr Timms says.