Summary

  • Wednesday 22 April 2015

  • First of the all-Wales political debates for Election 2015

  • Stephen Crabb for the Welsh Conservatives

  • Owen Smith for Labour

  • Leanne Wood for Plaid Cymru

  • Kirsty Williams for the Welsh Liberal Democrats

  • Pippa Bartolotti for Wales Greens

  • Nathan Gill for UKIP Wales

  1. Postpublished at 22:51 British Summer Time 22 April 2015

    And that's about it from this evening's live coverage of the first Wales election debate.

    There is plenty more to come with two weeks to go to the 7 May vote - and we'll do our best to bring you all the views.

    Don't forget - if you are hungry for more - The Wales Report is on now taking the temperature as Bethan Rhys Roberts and a studio audience of voters in Carmarthen call their would-be MPs to account.

  2. Postpublished at 22:46 British Summer Time 22 April 2015

    Nick Servini
    Political editor, Wales

    BBC Wales' political editor was at the debate - he sums up how he viewed it:

    "There were no policy surprises, but what the debate did do was to give a specific Welsh perspective on these political discussions.

    "Despite the fact that it's devolved, the NHS still prompted intense argument among the politicians, along with the economy in Wales - particularly food banks and zero hours contacts - and the question of whether or not further powers should be devolved."

  3. Postpublished at 22:45 British Summer Time 22 April 2015

    And the final word this evening from Liz Smith:

    "These debates are increasingly widening the arena from the two main parties and with performances like this from the smaller parties, voters may well take the opportunity to take the duopoly away from them."

  4. Postpublished at 22:44 British Summer Time 22 April 2015

    Liz Smith:

    "Owen Smith and Stephen Crabb both managed to defend their corners but failed to provide a good retort to Leanne Wood or as much passion on the need for 'fairer treatment'.

    Owen SMithImage source, ITV WAles
    Image caption,

    Labour's Owen Smith

    Stephen CrabbImage source, ITV Wales
    Image caption,

    The Conservatives's Stephen Crabb

    "Plaid have a friend in the Welsh Liberal Democrats with Kirsty Williams stating their ambition for 'Home Rule' for Wales.

    "Kristy also performed admirably, keeping Labour on the hoof both in Parliamentary and Assembly terms.

    "Leanne dismissed the St David's Day Agreement as not actually an agreement, but she's certainly made the case for this to be debated further."

  5. Postpublished at 22:40 British Summer Time 22 April 2015

    Liz Smith: "It was a good opportunity for Nathan Gill but he did come across as slightly condescending. He managed to dismiss the others as 'bureaucratic politicians' despite being an MEP himself, and Pippa Bartolotti isn't actually elected as anything at present.

    Nathan GillImage source, ITV Wales
    Image caption,

    Nathan Gill - UKIP Wales

    "Pippa held her own and managed to take a more serious tone than usual, providing a foundation for her to aim for regional seats in the Assembly in 2016. However she is certainly not the same eco warrior character the public might have been expected, in a very different vein from Natalie Bennett or Caroline Lucas."

    Pippa BartolottiImage source, ITV Wales
    Image caption,

    The Greens Pippa Bartolloti

  6. Postpublished at 22:36 British Summer Time 22 April 2015

    So - the final thoughts on the ITV Wales election debate from our commentator Liz Smith, head of monitoring at newsdirect wales, a political intelligence company based in Cardiff Bay.

    Leanne WoodImage source, ITV Wales
    Image caption,

    Plaid's Leanne Wood

    "Leanne Wood did very well tonight - possibly boosted by the practice she's had in the previous two debates.

    "She's not been scared of interjecting and her profile has been massively boosted in the last few weeks. It will be interesting to see if this translates in the polls."

  7. Postpublished at 22:15 British Summer Time 22 April 2015

    Don't forget - it's not just the ITV debate that is looking at Election 2015 - the BBC's Wales Report will be focusing on the issues too - at 22:45 BTS on BBC One Wales - with Bethan Rhys Roberts debating at Carmarthen's Queen Elizabeth High School.

  8. Postpublished at 22:10 British Summer Time 22 April 2015

    While people make up their minds on the Wales election debate - here's the thoughts of our commentator throughout the night - Liz Smith:

    "In brief closing remarks, Kirsty Williams repeated Nick Clegg's warnings of 'Nigel Farage or Alex Salmond in Number 10', as they take forward almost a scaremongering attempt towards the 'safety' of the centrist Liberal Democrats.

    "Leanne Wood repeated her call for a 'Team Wales' approach and Nathan Gill said people should vote UKIP if 'you believe in Britain'; suggesting perhaps that their core voters are not those who describe themselves as 'Welsh' but 'British'.

    Debate in full flowImage source, ITV Wales

    "Stephen Crabb said the Conservatives would bring a 'stronger and more prosperous Wales', and attacked Labour, saying that the party takes Wales for granted and they have 'no divine right to rule'.

    "Pippa Bartolotti said people can vote for a 'coalition of the damned or you can vote Green.

    "Owen Smith takes a more realistic tact in his appeal, stating that only two parties on this stage could realistically lead the next government."

  9. Postpublished at 22:02 British Summer Time 22 April 2015

    So the debate is over - but was there a winner? The 'spin room' will no doubt give us some reaction - but feel free to let us know what you think as well.

  10. Postpublished at 21:57 British Summer Time 22 April 2015

    Wales election debate is brought to a close

  11. Postpublished at 21:56 British Summer Time 22 April 2015

    Liz Smith on the exchange between Plaid's Leane Wood and UKIP's Nathan Gill:

    "There's a little frisson as Leanne puts down Nathan Gill, in a similar way she did with Nigel Farage in the first debate.

    "Nathan Gill likens the Assembly to his children asking for more food when there's already something on their plate, saying they should finish that first.

    "Leanne seems insulted by this, interjecting 'the Welsh Assembly are not children Nathan'.

    "Gill responded 'if you're belittled by an analogy there is something seriously wrong with you'. Safe to say that there is no love lost between Plaid Cymru and UKIP."

  12. Postpublished at 21:55 British Summer Time 22 April 2015

    All the parties are now giving a 30 second summing up

    DebateImage source, ITV wales
  13. Postpublished at 21:54 British Summer Time 22 April 2015

    More powers are wanted so that we can improve the life of the economy says Plaid's Leanne Wood

  14. Postpublished at 21:54 British Summer Time 22 April 2015

    Those powers over energy are coming to Wales and it's right that we're able to make those decisions says Kirsty Williams

  15. Postpublished at 21:54 British Summer Time 22 April 2015

    Its about striking the right balance says Conservative Stephen Crabb

  16. Postpublished at 21:53 British Summer Time 22 April 2015

    The NHS, the economy and education is what matters to people, says UKIP's Nathan Gill, not more powers.

  17. Postpublished at 21:53 British Summer Time 22 April 2015

    More from Liz Smith on devolution:

    "Stephen Crabb says that more devolution does not have to mean more red tape; although he didn't use this to promote the role he played in bringing together a degree of consensus on further powers through the recent St David's Day Agreement.

    "Kirsty Williams called for 'home rule' and this is on the cover of the Welsh Liberal Democrats manifesto.

    "For Leanne, this is her key territory and said that all government should have to take responsibility for the money it spends."

  18. Postpublished at 21:52 British Summer Time 22 April 2015

    Liz Smith comments on more powers questions:

    "The leaders are talking about devolution, in response to an audience member's worries about extra 'red tape' this could bring to small businesses.

    "Nathan Gill actually campaigned against further powers in the 2011 referendum, so it's no surprise to hear him describe the Assembly as 'bureaucrats making more work for bureaucrats'.

    "Owen Smith took a more positive note, saying that Labour would devolve powers over policing, job creation, ports and a fairer funding settlement."

  19. Postpublished at 21:50 British Summer Time 22 April 2015

    We should be exporting energy that we don't need says the Green's Pippa Bartolotti