Summary

  • President-elect Joe Biden says Donald Trump's refusal to concede the election "will not help the president's legacy"

  • He also spoke in defence of the Affordable Care Act, also known as Obamacare, and said he had spoken to six world leaders

  • President Donald Trump is refusing to admit losing the election, making unsubstantiated claims about voter fraud

  • The US justice department has given federal prosecutors an unusual go-ahead to investigate alleged vote irregularities

  • Top Senate Republican Mitch McConnell says the president has every right to pursue legal challenges

  • Democrat Joe Biden was projected as the election's winner, with an unassailable lead, on Saturday

  • Results from the states of Georgia, Arizona, North Carolina and Alaska are still outstanding

  1. Thank you for joining uspublished at 23:03 Greenwich Mean Time 10 November 2020

    This ends today's live coverage of the US 2020 election, and the latest from Trump's and Biden's teams as Biden works on his transition into the White House - only 10 weeks from now.

    Here's a recap of the main developments from today:

    • Biden defended the healthcare reform act known as Obamacare as the Supreme Court considered whether to overturn the law and cut health insurance to millions
    • Analysts say the questions asked by several judges on the top court during today's hearing may indicate that the conservative-led panel is unlikely to believe the whole of the law should be overturned
    • Boris Johnson and several other global leaders have spoken to Biden on the phone to congratulate him on his victory, although other leaders such as Russian President Vladimir Putin and Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro have still refrained from declaring Biden the winner
    • Most Republican senators in Congress are still refusing to concede that Biden won, citing Trump's ongoing legal battles
    • Secretary of State Mike Pompeo drew fierce criticism after suggesting the only transition plan in place was for a "second Trump administration". Critics called it a departure for the US top diplomat, who frequently calls upon other nations to respect democratic processes.

    Today's live page was brought to you by our teams in London and Washington DC. The writers were Mal Siret, Penny Spiller, Sean Fanning, Alix Kroeger, Ritu Prasad, Yaroslav Lukov and Max Matza, and the editors were Vicky Baker, Boer Deng and Helier Cheung.

  2. White House ploughs ahead with next year's budgetpublished at 22:47 Greenwich Mean Time 10 November 2020

    Landscaping crews doing gardening work at the White HouseImage source, Getty Images

    The White House budget office is directing government agencies to put together Trump's proposed federal budget , externalfor fiscal year 2022, which is due to go into effect two weeks after Biden will take office.

    The move by the Office of Management and Budget meshes with other moves from the Trump campaign to deny that Biden will be president in 10 weeks and stall the transition as Trump fights the election in the courts.

    The Trump-appointed head of the General Services Administration has also declined to acknowledge Biden's victory, making it impossible for his transition team to get the funds needed to physically move office and to obtain access to sensitive government documents.

    “If President Trump wants to waste time and resources on a budget that will never see the light of day, that’s his decision," Alexandra Weinroth, spokeswoman for the Democratic-led House Budget Committee told Politico, external.

    “But we look forward to receiving the budget of our 46th President, Joe Biden, in February.“

  3. Clinton recalls 'gracious' Bush Snr letterpublished at 22:37 Greenwich Mean Time 10 November 2020

    Former US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton has posted the letter George HW Bush left for Bill Clinton in the White House on his inauguration day on 20 January 1993 after losing the presidential election to his bitter rival.

    "Your success now is our country's success. I am rooting hard for you," Bush stated in the letter.

    Clinton, who herself was defeated by Trump in the 2016 White House race, described that letter as "gracious" in a post on her Instagram page., external

    "Here’s how it’s done in America," she said. "Since the very beginning, American presidents have accepted the will of the people and participated in a peaceful transfer of power. That's what makes our democracy so unique, and so enduring."

    Clinton's post does not name Trump - but it's still a clear criticism of Trump's refusal to concede the election, and support a transition, so far.

    This Instagram post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.View original content on Instagram
    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    Skip instagram post

    Allow Instagram content?

    This article contains content provided by Instagram. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. You may want to read Meta’s Instagram cookie policy, external and privacy policy, external before accepting. To view this content choose ‘accept and continue’.

    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    End of instagram post
  4. WATCH: Biden says 'we have to come together'published at 22:27 Greenwich Mean Time 10 November 2020

    We covered President-elect Biden's press conference a little earlier, where he described President Trump's refusal to concede as "an embarrassment" that would "not help" Trump's legacy.

    Biden said the foreign leaders he had already spoken to were hopeful that America's democratic institutions would be viewed once again as strong and enduring after the transition.

    You can watch more from Biden here:

    Media caption,

    Joe Biden: 'Embarrassment' that Trump has not conceded election

  5. Technical error blamed for UK PM's tweet glitchpublished at 22:19 Greenwich Mean Time 10 November 2020

    Photoshopped version
    Image caption,

    The hidden text could be seen after the colours of the image were manipulated

    The UK government has blamed a "technical error" for a Boris Johnson tweet congratulating Joe Biden on his victory which also had the name "Trump" in the background.

    The "Trump" wording is not immediately obvious in the image in Johnson's tweet, external.

    However, the Guido Fawkes website, external found that by manipulating the colours of the image, the word "Trump" could be seen in the background, in a smaller font, in the message to Biden.

    The message also had the word "second term" buried in it, the website added.

    Government officials later admitted two separate messages had been prepared before the US election result was known, and the alternative had been "embedded" in the other by mistake.

    "As you'd expect, two statements were prepared in advance for the outcome of this closely contested election," a government spokesman said.

    "A technical error meant that parts of the alternative message were embedded in the background of the graphic."

    You can read our full story here.

  6. The end of the Fox News-Trump era?published at 22:08 Greenwich Mean Time 10 November 2020

    Trump shakes hands with Fox reporterImage source, Getty Images

    It's well known that throughout the Trump presidency, Fox News was Trump's outlet of choice. He's often phoned in to the station's programmes and Fox's opinion show hosts have been ardent Trump defenders.

    But has that relationship now soured?

    In recent months, Trump has remarked that Fox has changed.

    And then the outlet drew the ire of the president when it became the first to call Arizona for Biden - at 23:20 local time on election night, with just 73% of the vote in.

    (Note that the BBC still has not projected the result for Arizona, as we consider it too early.)

    Trump was reportedly enraged by the projection and had his staff call the Fox election desk to get them to roll back, according to the Washington Post, external.

    A few days later, Fox News ended up calling the presidency for Biden, just minutes after CNN led the way.

    And then on Monday, Fox cut away from a briefing by White House Press Secretary Kayleigh McEnany when she mentioned "illegal votes", without providing any evidence.

    However, it's also worth noting that even as the channel seems to have moved away from the president's good graces, many Fox opinion programme anchors have still backed the president and his unsubstantiated claims of voter fraud.

  7. More misleading claims about election night 'glitches'published at 21:58 Greenwich Mean Time 10 November 2020

    Jack Goodman
    BBC Reality Check

    Screenshot shows side-by-side comparison of computer glitchImage source, YouTube
    Image caption,

    YouTubers have been posting screenshots of the glitch as "evidence" of fraud

    Rumours that votes have somehow been stolen from Donald Trump continue to flourish on social media and the latest story centres around footage from CNN’s election night coverage.

    A short clip that has been widely shared on Twitter shows the vote tallies for both candidates in the swing state of Pennsylvania at the bottom of the screen.

    When Pennsylvania flashes back up seconds later, Joe Biden’s total has risen by close to 20,000 votes and exactly the same number has been subtracted from Donald Trump.

    The clip is genuine but CNN says it simply shows an error that was quickly fixed.

    “For one brief moment, the Trump votes and Biden votes in Armstrong County, PA were transposed in the data feed that went to CNN and all NEP [National Election Pool] members. It was quickly fixed and the accurate report was restored,” according to a CNN source.

    “This is normal and occasionally happens throughout states on election nights.”

    One of the videos in circulation on Twitter now has 1.3 million views and has been shared tens of thousands of times, another version on YouTube claims “massive fraud”. Reports by pro-Trump news sites suggest it’s evidence that votes are being “swapped” between the two candidates.

  8. Details of Biden calls with Europe leaders releasedpublished at 21:44 Greenwich Mean Time 10 November 2020

    UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson talks on the phone to US President-elect Joe Biden. Photo: 10 November 2020Image source, Andrew Parsons/10 Downing Street
    Image caption,

    UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson talks on the phone to US President-elect Joe Biden

    As we reported earlier, Biden on Tuesday held separate phone talks with several European leaders.

    The US president-elect's transition team has now provided read-outs of those conversations:

    • Biden told French President Emmanuel Macron about his desire to strengthen ties with America's oldest ally. They also discussed the coronavirus outbreak, climate change and global economy among other issues
    • Speaking to German Chancellor Angela Merkel, Biden talked about revitalising the trans-Atlantic relationship, tackling Covid-19 and climate change
    • In phone talks with Irish Prime Minister Micheál Martin, Biden highlighted his desire to strengthen the enduring personal, cultural, and economic bilateral ties between the two countries. He also reaffirmed his support for the peace process in Northern Ireland
    • And during a conversation with UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson, Biden expressed his desire to strengthen the special relationship and re-double co-operation on key issues of mutual concern
  9. When will the terminator strike again?published at 21:37 Greenwich Mean Time 10 November 2020

    Tara McKelvey
    BBC News, Washington

    Trump fired Defence Secretary Mark Esper on Twitter, saying he was “terminated”. It is unusual to make such personnel changes during a presidential transition.

    So who’s next?

    Many here in Washington think it could be CIA Director Gina Haspel. Trump never had much time for her, and things got worse when she reportedly baulked at his request , externalto declassify documents relating to the Russia investigation. Describing it as a “Russia Hoax”, external, Trump wanted people to see for themselves what was in the material.

    Others say FBI Director Chris Wray is next, external: among other offences, Wray apparently did not fire people in the way the president wanted him to. Trump hoped Wray would get rid of some of the individuals who had investigated his campaign aides in 2016 during the Russia investigation.

    But everyone is vulnerable. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo once said, external he would remain in his job till the president “tweets me out of office”.

    Working for the president means a high level of uncertainty about one’s position. For some, the job also involves doomscrolling on Twitter and wondering when they will hear about the next sacking.

  10. Republican senator wins North Carolinapublished at 21:20 Greenwich Mean Time 10 November 2020

    Thom Tillis pictured at a Trump rally on 2 NovemberImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Thom Tillis pictured at a Trump rally on 2 November

    North Carolina Republican Senator Thom Tillis has narrowly held his Senate seat after his Democratic challenger conceded one week after the election.

    "I just called Senator Tillis to congratulate him on winning re-election to a second term in the US Senate and wished him and his family the best in their continued service in the months and years ahead,” Cal Cunningham said in a statement.

    "The voters have spoken and I respect their decision,” he added.

    The race became the most expensive in US Senate history, according to the Associated Press. Both campaigns and outside groups spent about $282m (£212m) in total.

    Cunningham out-fundraised his opponent but sank in the polls after an extramarital affair with a public relations consultant was revealed.

    With North Carolina settled, all eyes will now turn to Georgia, where the two senate seats currently held by Republicans will be decided in a runoff election. in January.

    If the Democrats win both seats - which won't be easy - they could still flip control of the Senate. That's because, in the event of a 50-50 tie, the vice-president is the tie-breaker, and Kamala Harris is due to take office in January.

  11. The late Smokin’ Joe Frazier did not vote in 2020published at 21:02 Greenwich Mean Time 10 November 2020

    Reality Check

    Joe Frazier trains with the punching bag in a gym in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, October 1973Image source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Joe Frazier, a boxing champion, died in 2011

    At a recent press conference in Philadelphia, Rudy Giuliani, President Trump’s lawyer, accused the Democratic-leaning city of having a long history of voter fraud.

    He claimed that noted Philadelphia residents were voting long after they died.

    “Joe Frazier”, the world champion boxer who died in 2011, “is still voting here”, said Mr Giuliani.

    He went on to say that actor Will Smith’s late father “has voted here twice since he died.”

    We contacted the Philadelphia city government, and were told both claims were false.

    The city’s Law Department checked their voter files and found that “neither is registered nor active” and that Joe Frazier did not vote after he passed away.

    The case of Mr Smith Snr is a bit more complicated. We were told that ahead of elections in the city in 2016, he sent in an absentee ballot and then died one day prior to the election.

    According to the Philadelphia city government, the 2016 election code allowed these votes to be counted. There is no record of Smith Snr having voted after this.

    It’s not clear where this story came from originally, but an article about Mr Frazier and Mr Smith appeared in a pro-Trump blog on 6 November. The author claimed to have seen records not publicly accessible.

    [This post was amended after publication. The original statement the Philadelphia city government provided to us referred to a 2017 election. "It should have said 2016 ... Please understand that folks are very, very tired," they said when we queried it.]

  12. Trump will make first public appearance since Biden winpublished at 20:46 Greenwich Mean Time 10 November 2020

    Trump's visit to Arlington National Cemetery in May 2020 for Memorial DayImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Trump's visit to Arlington National Cemetery in May 2020 for Memorial Day

    Trump will tomorrow make his first public appearance since Biden's victory was projected on Saturday.

    He and his wife Melania will visit Arlington National Cemetery to mark Veterans Day and lay a wreath at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier. The event, which normally draws thousands, will not be open to the public this year due to the pandemic.

    Veterans Affairs Secretary Robert Wilkie is due to attend. His planned annual speech for Veterans Day was cancelled today, external after it was confirmed that he met face-to-face last week with Housing Secretary Ben Carson, who has tested positive for Covid-19. Wilkie tested negative for the virus on Monday.

    Trump held no public events on Monday or Tuesday. He was pictured golfing on Saturday when the news of Biden's victory was announced and returned to the Virginia golf club on Sunday.

    His last public remarks were on Thursday, when he delivered a post-election briefing from the White House. He has been on Twitter frequently since then, tweeting today: "WE WILL WIN!"

  13. Parler 'free speech' app tops charts after pollpublished at 20:36 Greenwich Mean Time 10 November 2020

    Parler logo. File photoImage source, Getty Images

    Twitter alternative Parler has become the most-downloaded app in the US as conservatives flock to the self-styled "free speech" app after the US election.

    It follows a clampdown on the spread of election misinformation by Twitter and Facebook in recent days.

    Owner Dan Bongino said over the weekend the service was adding "thousands to users per minute".

    But the sudden boom also caused technical issues for users - some reported problems registering and a slowdown of the app as its servers attempted to deal with the influx.

    Launched in 2018, Parler has proved particularly popular among Trump supporters and right-wing conservatives. Such groups have frequently accused Twitter and Facebook of unfairly censoring their views.

    Read our full story here

  14. WATCH: Harris' ancestral Indian village celebratespublished at 20:20 Greenwich Mean Time 10 November 2020

    US Vice-President-elect Kamala Harris' ancestral Indian village has been celebrating her election victory.

    Thulasendrapuram, in the southern Indian state of Tamil Nadu, was the home of Ms Harris' maternal grandfather.

    People lit firecrackers and walked with pictures of Harris, who visited the village in her childhood.

    Ms Harris will be the first South Asian-American and first black vice president of the United States.

    Media caption,

    US election: Kamala Harris' ancestral Indian village celebrate vice-president-elect

  15. Biden: Trump's refusal to concede 'an embarrassment'published at 20:00 Greenwich Mean Time 10 November 2020

    Biden is asked after his address what message Trump is sending by not conceding that he lost the race.

    "I think it's just an embarrassment quite frankly," Biden says. "How can I say this tactfully?" he pauses, adding: "I think it will not help the president's legacy."

    "I know from my discussions with foreign leaders thus far that they are hopeful the United States' democratic institutions are viewed once again as being strong," he continues.

    "I think at the end of the day it's all gonna come to fruition on 20 January," he says, adding that Republican senators will soon come to recognise his victory.

  16. Biden: World leaders know 'America's back'published at 19:57 Greenwich Mean Time 10 November 2020

    U.S. President-elect Joe Biden smiles as he talks about protecting the Affordable Care Act (ACA) while speaking to reporters about his "plan to expand affordable health care" during an appearance in Wilmington, Delaware, US, November 10, 2020.Image source, Reuters

    Biden is asked what his plan is if the Trump administration does not co-operate with a transition of power for now.

    "It would be nice to have it but it's not critical," he says, adding that no legal action is planned by his team at the moment. The Trump administration has not approved the process of handing over the reins of government, meaning the Biden team has not yet been able to move in or begin examining sensitive information.

    "We're going to do exactly what we're doing if he had conceded," he continues.

    Asked about his message to Trump if he is listening right now, Biden says with a grin: "Mr President, I look forward to speaking with you."

    He says he has not yet had a chance to speak with Republican Senate Leader Mitch McConnell, who he worked with for decades in Washington before joining the White House under Obama.

    Biden adds that he has already spoken to six world leaders to let "them know America's back".

    "We're going to be back in the game," he says, calling the conversations "very fulsome [and] energetic".

  17. 'Americans should be proud of Obamacare'published at 19:50 Greenwich Mean Time 10 November 2020

    "Obamacare is the law that every American should be proud of," says Biden about the law that is loathed by conservatives. He goes on to tout the effects of the law on the American economy and society.

    "It's why people with pre-existing conditions are protected in this country. It's a law that delivered vital coverage to 20 million Americans who did not have coverage. It's a law that reduced prescription drug cost for nearly 12 million seniors."

    He adds: "If you're sick, if you struggling, if you're worried about how you're going to get going or go through the day, we will not abandon you.

    "That is a promise. We will not leave you to face these challenges alone," he adds.

  18. Biden - removing Obamacare 'cruel and divisive'published at 19:43 Greenwich Mean Time 10 November 2020

    Biden and HarrisImage source, Reuters

    Biden begins his speech by blaming "far right ideologues" for trying to "strip healthcare access away from the American people".

    "I'm not naive to the fact that healthcare is an issue that has divided the American people in the past," he acknowledges, adding that the healthcare act known as Obamacare is still quite popular.

    He says 58% of Americans support keeping it in place, while 38% support removing it.

    He says that the law he and President Obama helped pass has allowed Americans to think less about the costs of their treatment "and has spared countless families from financial ruin".

    "The Affordable Care Act was developed to bring a stop to that inhumanity," he says, calling removing it "cruel and needlessly divisive".

    Read more about how the law affects Americans: The lives that can be shaped by the Supreme Court

  19. Biden and Harris kick off speech on Obamacarepublished at 19:36 Greenwich Mean Time 10 November 2020

    Kamala HarrisImage source, CBS

    Harris is now speaking live from Delaware about the Affordable Care Act, also known as Obamacare, the signature healthcare reform law that extended healthcare coverage to millions of Americans.

    Her address comes as the Supreme Court hears arguments in a case that could see the healthcare law dismantled. The suit, brought by 18 Republican states, aims to rule the law unconstitutional.

    According to the Urban Institute think tank, over 20 million Americans could lose their healthcare coverage if Obamacare is overturned.

    "Each and every vote for Biden was a vote to expand the healthcare act, not take it away during a global pandemic," Harris says.

    Biden is speaking next.

  20. Top US diplomat: 'We'll transition to second Trump term'published at 19:28 Greenwich Mean Time 10 November 2020

    PompeoImage source, Reuters

    Secretary of State Mike Pompeo has drawn scrutiny after refusing to answer questions during a press conference about a transition of power.

    *There will be a smooth transition to a second Trump administration," he said, when asked about how the process was going.

    He continued: "The world should have every confidence that the transition necessary to make sure the state department is functional today, successful today and successful with the president who is in office on 20 January - a minute after noon - will also be successful."

    Critics argue that the top US diplomat's words sound somewhat different to statements he has made about other countries' elections - he has urged leaders to accept election results and commit to the democratic process.

    Yesterday, Pompeo had this to say about Myamar's elections: "The United States will continue to closely monitor the electoral process. We call on all relevant authorities to ensure tabulation of votes and resolution of complaints is undertaken in a transparent and credible manner.”