Summary

  • Tim Davie, the BBC's director general, says he will not resign over the fallout from Gary Lineker being asked to step back from the Match of the Day programme

  • He also apologised for schedule changes, after several BBC TV and radio sports shows were pulled at the last minute, including Football Focus, Final Score and Fighting Talk

  • A large number of presenters and commentators are engaged in a boycott in support of Lineker, who is in a row with the BBC over impartiality

  • "As a keen sports fan I know to miss programming is a real blow and I’m sorry about that," said Davie

  • Flagship football programme Match of the Day will only last 20 minutes later this evening, with no commentary on the highlights

  • Lineker has been pulled off air for tweeting about the government's new migration law and comparing language around it to that of 1930s Germany

  • The BBC said the Match of the Day host - its highest-paid star - breached its guidelines on use of social media

  • Prime Minister Rishi Sunak has said the issue is for the BBC and Gary Lineker to resolve but he stands by his immigration plan

  1. Goodbye, for nowpublished at 19:56 Greenwich Mean Time 11 March 2023

    We're pausing our live coverage.

    You can read all about the impartiality row between Gary Lineker and the BBC in these stories:

    Today's live page was edited by Tiffany Wertheimer, Heather Sharp and Siobhan Toman. The writers were Doug Faulkner, Michael Sheils McNamee, Jaroslav Lukiv, Antoinette Radford, James McFadden, Sean Seddon, Phelan Chatterjee and Alexandra Binley.

  2. What's happened today?published at 19:51 Greenwich Mean Time 11 March 2023

    It has been a fast moving day as the fallout from the BBC asking Gary Lineker to step back from presenting Match of the Day continues.

    Here is what has happened:

    • BBC One will air highlights of today's games on Match of the Day but the show will only be 20 minutes long, with no commentary or punditry after pundits and commentators backed Lineker
    • There has been disruption across BBC sports output with Football Focus, Final Score and football coverage on 5 Live pulled from the air
    • BBC director general Tim Davie has apologised for the impact on sports coverage but said he would not resign over it
    • Prime Minister Rishi Sunak has spoken on the row for the first time, saying he hoped it would be resolved in a "timely manner" but was a matter for the BBC and Lineker
    • As the controversy continued Lineker watched his beloved Leicester City lose to Chelsea at the King Power stadium, where he was seen taking pictures with fans
    • Some football supporters have held up signs in support of the Match of the Day presenter while there was also a small protest outside the BBC office in Salford where it is filmed.

    Read more here.

  3. WATCH: BBC's director general on Gary Lineker rowpublished at 19:36 Greenwich Mean Time 11 March 2023

    If you want to watch the BBC's full interview with Tim Davie - conducted this evening by Nomia Iqbal in Washington DC - here it is below.

    Media caption,

    Gary Lineker: BBC director general Tim Davie's interview in full

  4. Would Lineker have been removed if he supported government's policy?published at 19:31 Greenwich Mean Time 11 March 2023

    That's the question the BBC's Nomia Iqbal put to the director general today.

    "If he'd replied to Suella Braverman to say 'I support your migrant policy, I back it, it's brilliant', he would be taking an opinion. Would you have removed him for that?" she asks Davie.

    "I'm not going to go through all the hypotheticals of the past," he responds.

    "We deal with these things on an ongoing basis. I think there are some questions coming from this period which has been difficult," he responds.

  5. Chairman's appointment not my responsibility - BBC bosspublished at 19:19 Greenwich Mean Time 11 March 2023

    In an interview in the US, Nomia Iqbal asks Tim Davie about BBC chairman Richard Sharp's position. He came under further scrutiny over claims he arranged a loan for the then-prime minister Boris Johnson.

    Davie says while he has "a lot of responsibilities in this job for thousands of people" the one thing he does not do is the appointment of the chair.

    "The way in which the board is hired and that role is a different thing to editorially me running the BBC, making those decisions and trying to be fair and getting a BBC that is truly impartial.

    "We should be fighting for this in this world. Calmly, rationally fighting for a BBC that actually champions free speech."

  6. BBC director general says he's in 'listening mode'published at 19:12 Greenwich Mean Time 11 March 2023

    Tim Davie says he is listening to feedback about how editorial guidelines are applied to different BBC staff.

    He says there are questions about how they apply to freelancers within the organisation.

    When asked if he would remove other presenters like Lord Sugar, Chris Packham or Karren Brady who also give their opinions, he said: "the current guidelines as they exist today... do draw distinction between those people who are seen as pan-BBC figures... that are different to those appearing on programmes. We can debate that."

    “I am in listening mode. I want to make sure that going forward we have a workable solution.”

  7. BBC director general will not resign over Lineker rowpublished at 18:52 Greenwich Mean Time 11 March 2023
    Breaking

    Tim Davie, the BBC's director general, says he will not resign over the fallout from Gary Lineker being asked to step back from the Match of the Day programme over impartiality.

    Speaking to the BBC's Nomia Iqbal in the US, he was asked if he should resign over the crisis - he said he would not.

    Tim Davie and Nomia Iqbal
  8. 'Difficult day': Davie apologises over sport programmingpublished at 18:47 Greenwich Mean Time 11 March 2023
    Breaking

    Nomia Iqbal
    BBC News, Washington

    Tim Davie

    BBC director general Tim Davie says it has been a "difficult day" as he apologised for the disruption to BBC sports programming.

    "I’m sorry audiences have been affected and they haven’t got the programming," he told me, in an interview in Washington DC.

    "As a keen sports fan I know to miss programming is a real blow and I’m sorry about that. We are working very hard to resolve this situation and make sure we get output on air."

    He did not want to go into detail about discussions or if he had spoken to Lineker in last 24 hours.

    But he said: "Everyone wants to calmly resolve the situation. Gary Lineker’s the best in the business - that’s not for debate."

  9. Labour sees chance to weigh in and get on front footpublished at 18:38 Greenwich Mean Time 11 March 2023

    Damian Grammaticas
    Political correspondent

    While Rishi Sunak’s statement has softened the tone from the government, and ministers have gone quiet since Lineker was suspended, for Labour the opposite is true. They’ve been getting more vocal and more critical.

    Earlier in the week it was a tricky issue for them.

    The government was on the front foot. It was trying to attack Labour, which it wants to paint as weak on illegal immigration.

    Now Lineker has been suspended and there is an outcry Labour is weighing in.

    It’s an opportunity for Labour to try to get back on the front foot. It can do that by criticising the BBC for having "got this one badly wrong" and "caving" to Tory MPs.

    And it also gives Sir Keir Starmer an opening to criticise the whole small boats policy too. Earlier he said: "At the heart of this is the government’s failure on the asylum system. And rather than take responsibility for the mess they’ve made, the government is casting around to blame anybody else - Gary Lineker, the BBC, civil servants."

  10. Why is Rishi Sunak stepping in now to comment on Lineker?published at 18:33 Greenwich Mean Time 11 March 2023

    Damian Grammaticas
    Political correspondent

    Amid all the noise in this affair Rishi Sunak hadn’t before now uttered the words "Gary Lineker" as far as I can tell. So why now?

    Through the week a host of his top team had been all too happy to weigh in.

    Sunak’s Press Secretary (speaking on his behalf), Culture Secretary Lucy Frazer, immigration minister Robert Jenrick and Home Office minister Chris Philp all criticised Lineker’s comments.

    And Home Secretary Suella Braverman said: "I don’t think anything that is happening in the UK today can come close to what happened in the Holocaust."

    That’s a lot of ministers caring about an issue enough to address it. They didn’t explicitly call for action against Lineker, but criticised him roundly.

    The minute Lineker was suspended that dynamic changed. No ministers commenting, just an official line: "individual cases are a matter for the BBC."

    The government, it seems, was happy enough to weigh in while the issue gained momentum. It kept the story in the headlines.

    Number 10 wants people to see it’s pushing ahead with its new legislation on small boats. If the plan causes some outrage, from Downing Street’s viewpoint, that’s not necessarily a bad thing.

    It helps create the impression this is a tough approach, pushing boundaries. Which might translate into support among its target voters.

    But the minute Gary Lineker was suspended it became a bit more tricky. Now, if you are in Number 10, you don’t want to be dragged into the row any further.

    He’s popular, there’s a backlash growing as his colleagues rally behind him. And there’s already lots of criticism about the Conservatives putting pressure on the BBC.

    If this ends with Lineker leaving the BBC you want as much distance from that decision as possible.

    Hence time for a prime ministerial comment.

    Time to soften the tone, praise Lineker - he’s "a great footballer and is a talented presenter". Time to say the PM "hopes" this can be "resolved" but it’s for the BBC "not the government".

    An effort to extricate the PM in case there’s fall out.

  11. MotD to be 20 minutes long with no commentarypublished at 18:26 Greenwich Mean Time 11 March 2023
    Breaking

    BBC One will broadcast a much-reduced episode of Match of the Day this evening, the BBC's sport editor Dan Roan says.

    There will be no commentary on the highlights.

    It is currently scheduled to begin at 22:20 GMT.

  12. What is the government's policy Lineker was responding to?published at 18:18 Greenwich Mean Time 11 March 2023

    If you're wondering what exactly it was that Lineker was responding to in his tweet, here's some of the powers the government's new Illegal Migration Bill includes:

    • The bill would allow the UK government to detain and remove asylum seekers arriving via illegal routes. They can be sent to Rwanda or a "safe" third country. This will take legal precedence over someone's right to claim asylum
    • Once removed, asylum seekers will be blocked from returning or seeking British citizenship in the future
    • Those found to have entered illegally won't be granted bail and won't be able to seek judicial review for the first 28 days of their detention
    • Children, those medically unfit to fly or those at risk of serious harm in the country they would be sent to will be able to delay their removal
    • Any other asylum claims will be heard remotely after removal from the UK
    • The law will also create a cap on refugees settled "through safe and legal routes", set annually by Parliament

    Labour called the legislation a "con that risks making the chaos worse", but Ms Braverman told MPs it was time to stop the UK "being taken for a ride".

    Read more about the Illegal Migration Bill here.

  13. Sunak says Lineker row not matter for the governmentpublished at 18:02 Greenwich Mean Time 11 March 2023

    Prime Minister Rishi Sunak has defended his government's proposed immigration bill.

    He described Lineker as a "great footballer and talented presenter" but said "we need to break this cycle of misery once and for all and the policy we set out this week I believe aims to do just that."

    He said he hoped the row between Lineker and the BBC was resolved "in a timely manner", but added that it was not a matter for the government.

    The prime minister said while he acknowledged not everyone would agree with his policy, he believed what he was doing was "fair and right".

    Sunak said the bill - which would see anyone who seeks asylum in the UK via illegal routes removed from the country and blocked from returning in the future - was "the compassionate thing to do".

  14. Small protest outside MotD headquarterspublished at 17:38 Greenwich Mean Time 11 March 2023

    There has been a small protest outside the BBC's offices in Salford, where Match of the Day and much of BBC Sport's output is made.

    About a dozen people from Greater Manchester Stand Up to Racism took part, with a banner being held up saying "Reinstate Gary Lineker" and other signs saying "Refugees welcome here".

    Protesters call for Gary Lineker to be reinstated outside BBC Sport's offices
  15. BBC's Lineker response a 'massive misstep' - unionpublished at 17:17 Greenwich Mean Time 11 March 2023

    The BBC's handling of the Gary Lineker row will "likely prove disastrous for its reputation", the broadcasting union says.

    Philippa Childs, the head of Bectu, says the BBC's response is "hugely disappointing" and the strength of feeling from staff and members of the public should indicate it was a "massive misstep".

    "Our thoughts are with all BBC staff at what we know is an incredibly challenging time, and we are here to support our members however we can," she says. "We fully understand the depth of feeling and why some freelancers will elect to not work on BBC sport programmes today or choose to join protests."

    She also refers to the controversy involving BBC chairman Richard Sharp and says many will be "rightly confused why those at the highest levels of the corporation are apparently immune to the stringent guidelines applied to everyone else".

  16. LISTEN: Personally, today I found it very difficult - Ian Dennispublished at 17:06 Greenwich Mean Time 11 March 2023

    Media caption,

    Gary Lineker: Ian Dennis commentates on BBC 5 Live

  17. Fresh calls for BBC chair to resign amid Lineker impartiality rowpublished at 16:54 Greenwich Mean Time 11 March 2023

    Richard Sharp
    Image caption,

    BBC chairman Richard Sharp

    BBC chairman Richard Sharp is facing fresh calls to resign amid the Gary Lineker impartiality row.

    His appointment in that role has come under scrutiny after The Sunday Times alleged Sharp had helped to arrange an £800,000 loan for then-prime minister Boris Johnson, while he was in consideration for the BBC board position.

    Sharp denies a conflict of interest and says he simply connected people, but he has been criticised in a report from MPs, and his appointment is under investigation by the independent office of public appointments.

    Earlier, former BBC director general Greg Dyke said the ongoing controversy around Sharp - who he said he liked - helped fuel perceptions that the organisation was failing to stand up to government pressure.

    Making the comparison to Lineker, Labour's shadow culture secretary Lucy Powell told BBC Breakfast the "same cries of impartiality were completely absent" when Sharp "failed to disclose" his relationship with Johnson.

    Liberal Democrat leader Ed Davey is calling for Sharp to resign, saying there had been a "failure at the very top of the BBC" and calling his position "untenable".

    However, BBC culture and media editor Katie Razzall makes the point that the BBC has no say in the chairman's appointment - it is a political appointment - and is now being investigated.

    As a board member Sharp does not have a say in editorial matters, she adds.

    Here's some more on Richard Sharp.

  18. Wales football programme replaced with classical concertpublished at 16:39 Greenwich Mean Time 11 March 2023

    BBC Radio Wales's Call Rob Phillips programme won't be going to air this evening as a result of the BBC's limited sport programming.

    In its place will be a replay of a classical concert celebrating 100 years of the BBC in Wales.

    A BBC spokesperson said "we are sorry for these changes which we recognise will be disappointing for BBC sport fans".

  19. Jermain Defoe won't appear on Sunday's Match of the Daypublished at 16:26 Greenwich Mean Time 11 March 2023

    Jermain DefoeImage source, Getty Images

    Pundit and former Tottenham striker Jermain Defoe says he won't appear on Sunday evening's Match of the Day 2 programme.

    Defoe tweeted: "It's always such a privilege to work with BBC MOTD. But tomorrow I have taken the decision to stand down from my punditry duties."

  20. When BBC News reports on the BBCpublished at 16:20 Greenwich Mean Time 11 March 2023

    It can look a bit complicated when BBC News is covering a story about the BBC. As Scott Bryan, who has a podcast on Radio 5 Live, highlighted on Twitter.

    This Twitter post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.View original content on Twitter
    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    Skip twitter post

    Allow Twitter content?

    This article contains content provided by Twitter. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. You may want to read Twitter’s cookie policy, external and privacy policy, external before accepting. To view this content choose ‘accept and continue’.

    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    End of twitter post

    But with stories like today's, BBC News journalists treat the BBC in the same way as any other organisation the news service reports on.

    And like with any other organisation, BBC News has to ask BBC management or BBC services for responses and contact the BBC Press Office for official statements.

    Occasionally BBC journalists approach senior managers for unplanned interviews - known as "doorsteps" in the news business - like the one yesterday by Nomia Iqbal, who grabbed a few words from the BBC Director General Tim Davie when he was in the US.