Summary

  • SpaceX launched its massive Starship rocket but loses contact after eight minutes of flight

  • The top part of the rocket successfully separated from the booster which then blew up. Contact was then lost with the upper-stage

  • Elon Musk's company still hailed it as a success and the rocket flew further than the first integrated flight test in April

  • This time the rocket reached space for the first time while in April the vehicle lost control and exploded four minutes after lift-off

  • Engineers at SpaceX - Musk's company - say they made "more than a thousand" changes to Starship's systems after the first launch

  • The mission plan was broadly the same as before: To send the top part of the two-stage vehicle - the Ship - nearly one full revolution of the Earth

  1. Starship goes further despite technical difficultiespublished at 15:39 Greenwich Mean Time 18 November 2023

    Marita Moloney
    Live reporter

    Mission control at Starbase will likely be still coming back down to Earth after what SpaceX hailed as an exciting launch of its uncrewed spacecraft Starship.

    The company hopes Starship will transform the economics of space, with the eventual goal to build a spacecraft that can take people and cargo back to the Moon later this decade - and ultimately to Mars.

    That dream is still alive for owner Elon Musk.

    This second test flight went further and higher than the maiden launch in April, but with some technical problems persisting, including the booster exploding and contact being lost with the upper-stage Ship eight minutes in.

    "If SpaceX engineers can make Starship work as designed, it will be revolutionary," our science correspondent says, and engineers will use today's test to continue working towards SpaceX's "multiplanetary" goal.

    Today's coverage was brought to you by our colleagues in the Science team Jonathan Amos and Rebecca Morelle, as well as Sam Hancock and myself.

    Want to learn more? You can read or watch how today's launch unfolded, as well as delving deeper into everything you need to know about Starship. Thanks for joining us.

  2. Analysis

    So how successful was this launch?published at 15:23 Greenwich Mean Time 18 November 2023

    Jonathan Amos
    Science correspondent

    There’s no doubt that SpaceX will consider this a great day. The major problems that beset April’s maiden flight were overcome.

    Starship made what appeared to be a clean getaway, all the engines on the first-stage booster worked on the way up hill, and the Ship made its separation on time at two minutes and 40 seconds, continuing onwards into space.

    And, yes, it got to space, about 140km up. So, SpaceX will take all this as a win.

    They’ll want to review why the Ship’s computers terminated its flight, and also why the booster tore itself apart shortly after separation. But these are questions for tomorrow.

    The SpaceX mega rocket Starship takes off from a test base Boca Chica, Texas,Image source, EPA

    SpaceX already has the next iterations of Starship lined up in Texas ready to make their test flights. These launches will come thick and fast now.

    Remember the words of Garrett Reisman, a former Nasa astronaut, SpaceX consultant, and professor of astronautical engineering at the University of Southern California.

    "I think the benefit of this rapid development approach is even though things don't look good at first, when things are blowing up - you learn so much and so quickly that you actually do converge on the correct solution much faster than if you try to get something 100% perfect the first time.

    "SpaceX does seem to get there in the end."

  3. How delays with Starship could slow Nasa’s return to the Moonpublished at 15:13 Greenwich Mean Time 18 November 2023

    Rebecca Morelle
    Science editor

    Human Landing SystemImage source, NASA
    Image caption,

    Starship will land humans on the Moon for the first time since 1972

    This SpaceX rocket is set to play a vital role in Nasa’s Artemis programme, which will return humans to the Moon.

    While the astronauts will begin their journey on Nasa’s rocket called the SLS, inside its capsule called Orion, they’ll then transfer into Starship, which will take them down to the lunar surface.

    But there’s a lot to do before this can happen.

    SpaceX will need to move beyond the testing phase to see a number of successful launches.

    They’ll also need to try out refuelling Starship in space - it will need to have extra fuel to make it all the way to the Moon. And then there’s developing and testing the technology that will ensure Starship can safely touch down - and lift off - from the lunar surface.

    Nasa has an ultra ambitious timeline for the Artemis project. It says it wants to have astronauts on the Moon by late 2025.

    But the US space agency has had plenty of delays of its own, and Starship is moving more slowly than was expected. So, it’s looking very likely that humanity’s return to the Moon will see that timeline slip in a major way.

    But Nasa’s not totally reliant on SpaceX. It also has a contract with Blue Origin - Jeff Bezos’s rival company - to provide another lunar landing system.

  4. Watch: SpaceX rocket launches, separates and loses contactpublished at 14:57 Greenwich Mean Time 18 November 2023

    Elon Musk's company SpaceX launched Starship - the biggest and most powerful rocket ever built - for a second time from Starbase in Texas today.

    The top part of the rocket - the Ship - successfully separated from the booster, which then exploded. Contact with the Ship was later lost when computers terminated the flight.

    Here's how the launch unfolded, with reporting from the BBC's science correspondent Jonathan Amos:

  5. In pictures: Eager rocket watchers gather as Starship enters spacepublished at 14:44 Greenwich Mean Time 18 November 2023

    Just over an hour ago, we watched Elon Musk's huge Starship rocket take off for a second time from Starbase in Boca Chica, Texas.

    SpaceX has hailed the mission as a success, considering it got further than its first attempt in April to achieve new milestones. But the two segments of the rocket - the booster and the Ship - did eventually self-destruct over ocean waters.

    Here's some images from today's launch:

    A sizeable group of people watch the rocket lift off - many through binoculars - just after 07:00 local tie (13:00 GMT)Image source, Reuters
    Image caption,

    People gathered to watch the rocket lift off - many through binoculars - just after 07:00 local time (13:00 GMT) in Boca Chica, Texas

    People watch as SpaceX's next-generation Starship spacecraft lifts off from the company's Boca Chica launchpadImage source, Reuters
    Image caption,

    It was the second attempt to launch the rocket, and engineers made "more than a thousand" modifications for the second go

    Starship leaves behind a trail of exhaust gases on its journey to spaceImage source, Reuters
    Image caption,

    Starship left behind an exhaust plume (largely water and carbon dioxide) on its journey to space

    A ring of lights in the Texan sky after Starship's super heavy booster explodesImage source, Reuters
    Image caption,

    A few minutes into its flight, Starship's Super Heavy booster exploded in what SpaceX has called a "rapid unscheduled disassembly"

    Rocket takes off amid a huge cloud of smokeImage source, EPA
    Image caption,

    There were cheers at SpaceX's Starbase mission control when the rocket successfully lifted away. Engineers hailed it as an "incredibly successful day"

  6. 'Congratulations team SpaceX!' - Elon Muskpublished at 14:18 Greenwich Mean Time 18 November 2023

    SpaceX owner Elon Musk has congratulated his team following today's Starship rocket launch.

    The company also hailed an "exciting" second flight test, saying: "Starship successfully lifted off under the power of all 33 Raptor engines on the Super Heavy booster and made it through stage separation."

    It added, as we reported earlier, that the booster experienced "a rapid unscheduled disassembly shortly after stage separation while Starship's engines fired for several minutes on its way to space".

    Quote Message

    With a test like this, success comes from what we learn, and today’s test will help us improve Starship’s reliability as SpaceX seeks to make life multiplanetary."

  7. Nasa: 'An opportunity to learn - then fly again'published at 14:03 Greenwich Mean Time 18 November 2023

    Rocket flies through the skyImage source, Reuters

    Nasa chief Bill Nelson has tweeted to congratulate the SpaceX teams "who made progress on today’s flight test".

    "Spaceflight is a bold adventure demanding a can-do spirit and daring innovation. Today’s test is an opportunity to learn - then fly again," he said, external.

    Quote Message

    Together Nasa and SpaceX will return humanity to the Moon, Mars and beyond."

  8. Analysis

    Starship's computers command a terminationpublished at 13:52 Greenwich Mean Time 18 November 2023

    Jonathan Amos
    Science correspondent

    Up to a point, that was an incredibly successful launch.

    What we saw was the Starship rocket launch from Texas and get through the crucial staging - the separation of the two halves of the rocket.

    The top part, the Ship, carried on. It was supposed to continue on its powered ascent for about eight-and-a-half minutes.

    But just before that milestone, the computers on board basically destroyed the vehicle.

    Why? Because eventually the velocity of this vehicle - at about 140km above the Earth - would've taken it over Africa. If something was wrong, which clearly there was, then the computers would've destroyed the vehicle at the earliest opportunity so the debris came down over the Atlantic Ocean and not on land over Africa.

  9. What's just happened?published at 13:39 Greenwich Mean Time 18 November 2023

    Rebecca Morelle
    Science editor

    SpaceX's next-generation Starship spacecraft lifts off from launchpad, near BrownsvilleImage source, Reuters

    It was a spectacular launch for the world's biggest and most powerful rocket.

    It was all looking good as it blasted skywards into the blue Texan sky.

    The second test flight got further than the first – the two parts of the rocket separated as planned.

    But then things started to go awry – the bottom booster exploded after it detached – not too big a problem, as it had already done its job of sending the upper-stage skywards.

    But then a few minutes later the news came through that the top part of the rocket - the Ship - had been lost, too.

    So is this a success or failure?

    Well, losing a rocket would usually be seen as “not nominal”, which in space lingo means not ideal, but SpaceX has a different philosophy.

    They’ll be analysing all of the data from this – learning what went wrong – then they’ll have another go.

  10. 'Incredibly successful day' despite contact loss, says SpaceXpublished at 13:33 Greenwich Mean Time 18 November 2023

    Today was hailed as incredibly successful by SpaceX engineers, despite the Super Heavy booster experiencing what is known as "a rapid unscheduled disassembly".

    SpaceX has insisted that explosions during the early stages of rocket development are welcome and help inform design choices faster than ground tests.

    The second launch was more successful than the company's first attempt in April, and any data gathered from today will be used to influence future modifications to the rocket.

  11. SpaceX ends stream and says data lostpublished at 13:18 Greenwich Mean Time 18 November 2023
    Breaking

    A SpaceX engineer has said in the last few minutes that the team has lost the data from the second stage of this flight.

    "We have lost the data from the second stage... we think we may have lost the second stage," SpaceX's livestream host John Insprucker said.

    The team has now signed off on its live feed of the launch. It's unclear what this means for the rocket's flight.

  12. Postpublished at 13:14 Greenwich Mean Time 18 November 2023

    The next stage in this launch is re-entry, but it's not clear what kind of images we're going to see of this, SpaceX engineers say.

  13. 'What a successful day this has been so far'published at 13:13 Greenwich Mean Time 18 November 2023

    It's now coming up on the projected time that the Ship would shut off its engines, mission control says.

    "What a successful day this has been so far," an engineer speaking on SpaceX's live feed says.

  14. Key separation stage comes off for SpaceXpublished at 13:07 Greenwich Mean Time 18 November 2023
    Breaking

    Stage separation has now happened, with the Ship segment still in flight with all six of its engines firing.

    But the Super Heavy booster exploded, which wasn't the plan for SpaceX engineers.

    Super Heavy booster explodesImage source, Reuters
    Image caption,

    The Super Heavy booster explodes a few minutes into Starship's launch

  15. Postpublished at 13:05 Greenwich Mean Time 18 November 2023

    There are cheers at the SpaceX centre in Texas, where dozens of staff are gathered - watching on as the mammoth rocket's second flight gets under way.

  16. SpaceX’s Starship lifts off for a second timepublished at 13:03 Greenwich Mean Time 18 November 2023
    Breaking

    Rocket launchesImage source, SpaceX

    The most powerful rocket ever developed has left the launch pad in Texas for the second time, with a massive roar as 33 engines on the Super Heavy booster power it skywards.

  17. Postpublished at 13:01 Greenwich Mean Time 18 November 2023

    A planned hold is now taking place at t-minus 40 seconds until lift-off.

    "Teams are using this time for final checks. All systems continue to look good for today’s flight test," SpaceX says on X.

    We're waiting to see whether it will lift off in the next few seconds.

  18. Minute to launchpublished at 12:59 Greenwich Mean Time 18 November 2023

    The SpaceX live feed has a countdown to the launch. It's now one minute until the launch. We're of course all waiting to see if it happens.

  19. Launch is looking goodpublished at 12:59 Greenwich Mean Time 18 November 2023

    "Propellant loading complete. Starship is fully loaded with more than 4,500 metric tons (10 million pounds) of propellant," SpaceX has just posted on X.

  20. Postpublished at 12:56 Greenwich Mean Time 18 November 2023

    SpaceX's rocket systemImage source, .