Summary

  • The Conservative leader of Peterborough City Council, Wayne Fitzgerald, has lost a vote of no confidence this evening

  • A full council meeting took place at the Town Hall, where 32 voted in favour of the motion and 20 against

  • Mohammed Farooq, member of Peterborough First, was voted in as the new council leader.

  • Mr Fitzgerald said he expected to lose the vote, which was proposed by an alliance of Labour, Liberal Democrat and Green councillors

  • A number of Tory councillors have recently switched to the Peterborough First group at the unitary authority

  1. Thanks for joining uspublished at 22:15 Greenwich Mean Time 1 November 2023

    After hours of debate, councillors at Peterborough City Council have voted to remove the Conservative leader Wayne Fitzgerald.

    Peterborough First, under the leadership of Mohammed Farooq, a former Conservative councillor, will now run the council as a minority.

    We are ending our coverage here. Thank you for joining us tonight, we will bring you more reaction tomorrow.

  2. A tall order for new administrationpublished at 22:10 Greenwich Mean Time 1 November 2023

    Ben Schofield
    Political correspondent, BBC Look East

    Predictably, tonight brought discord and disorder.

    With a packed chamber and around 300 watching a live video feed, this may not have been Peterborough’s most positive spectacle.

    While some of his critics will welcome the end of councillor Wayne Fitzgerald’s term as leader, his party colleagues remained loyal and supportive.

    Despite that division, there was some agreement – that Peterborough is facing huge challenges and possible further government oversight or intervention.

    Peterborough First will now try to run the council as a minority administration. That’s a tall order with just 11 members out of a total of 60.

    Tonight they were able to rely on support from other opposition councillors – an informal and potentially unstable coalition.

    Peterborough City Council’s Improvement Panel has encouraged councillors to work more collaboratively. That means parties may have become more used to working together.

    But Mr Fitzgerald has made clear he and his group will not recognise the new administration.

    So tonight’s early fireworks may not be the last.

  3. Conservatives say defectors should face by-electionspublished at 22:09 Greenwich Mean Time 1 November 2023

    The Conservatives have issued a statement about the outcome of tonight's no confidence motion.

    "As the largest party on the council we believe the move has no legitimacy," say former leader Wayne Fitzgerald and former deputy leader Steve Allen.

    "Electors will obviously question how these councillors were able to present themselves for election under a party banner only to then defect to another self-styled political group without returning to the polls to seek approval of those who have elected them."

    They say those who defect should go before the electorate again.

    "As the largest political group on the City Council we restate our commitment to Peterborough and will continue to speak and work in the best interest of our City and its residents."

  4. New cabinet announcedpublished at 22:03 Greenwich Mean Time 1 November 2023

    Ben Schofield
    Political correspondent, BBC Look East

    Councillor Farooq has just announced his cabinet, saying it is "competent and experienced" and would "hit the ground running".

    The following councillors will join the cabinet:

    John Howard - Deputy Leader, with responsibility for finance, corporate services, legal and community

    Ray Bisby - children's services

    Peter Hiller - growth, housing and regeneration

    Saqib Farooq - Adults and health

    Gavin Elsey - Infrastructure, transport, climate and environment

  5. Conservatives will not recognise new administrationpublished at 22:01 Greenwich Mean Time 1 November 2023

    Former council leader Wayne Fitzgerald says his party will not recognise Mr Farooq's administration.

    "So forget about that," he tells him.

    He says he will campaign to get as many Peterborough First councillors out of the council "through the ballot box" because that's democracy.

    "Because what I care about is this city, and I'm passionate and I'm still going to do what I need to do and encourage my members to do that."

    Addressing Mr Farooq and his administration, he says: "You have no legitimacy to be in this council chamber, you were voted in as Conservatives."

    The conservative group including Wayne Fitzgerald sitting in the chamberImage source, Shariqua Ahmed/BBC
    Image caption,

    Wayne Fitzgerald says the Conservatives will work to oust Peterborough First councillors at the ballot box

  6. New leader wants to work with Conservativespublished at 21:50 Greenwich Mean Time 1 November 2023

    Mr Farooq says he hopes to work with Conservative colleagues.

    He says his party is "fully aware" of the council's financial picture and will put forward a long-term financial plan.

    He wants to "extend [a] hand of friendship to Conservative colleagues" and he adds that "with your help" the council will have stable leadership.

    Just prior to the leadership vote, Liberal Democrat leader Christian Hogg said he wanted to offer former leader Wayne Fitzgerald an "olive branch" and said that he hoped the Conservative leader could "come back into the fold" and work together "for a positive outcome for the council".

  7. New leader 'honoured and humbled'published at 21:41 Greenwich Mean Time 1 November 2023

    Ben Schofield
    Political correspondent, BBC Look East

    Mohammed Farooq has proposed a motion about his new cabinet during a short speech.

    He says he is "humbled and honoured" to have been voted in as leader "for our beautiful city of Peterborough".

    He adds that his group will work towards four priorities: growth and prosperity, protect the vulnerable, education, and the environment.

    At the same time Liberal Democrat councillors can be seen giving high fives to each other.

  8. Mohammed Farooq voted new leaderpublished at 21:39 Greenwich Mean Time 1 November 2023
    Breaking

    Mohammed FarooqImage source, Shariqua Ahmed/BBC

    The vote to install Mohammed Farooq, of Peterborough First, as leader of Peterborough City Council has passed.

    The results are as follows:

    For - 32

    Against - 19

    Abstentions - 2

  9. Motion to reinstate Wayne Fitzgerald failspublished at 21:36 Greenwich Mean Time 1 November 2023

    Amendment to the motion (to re-install Wayne Fitzgerald as leader). The results are as follows:

    For - 20

    Against - 32

    Abstentions - 1

  10. 'Debate has deteriorated'published at 21:35 Greenwich Mean Time 1 November 2023

    Ben Schofield
    Political correspondent, BBC Look East

    John Howard from Peterborough First says he would like to "apologise to the officers and the public watching" because the "debate has deteriorated and we deserve better".

    "There's a lot of ill-feeling and this chamber deserves better," he adds.

  11. Former leader says voters have been betrayedpublished at 21:23 Greenwich Mean Time 1 November 2023

    Ben Schofield
    Political correspondent, BBC Look East

    Wayne Fitzgerald pointing at Councillor Farooq across the chamberImage source, Shariqua Ahmed/BBC
    Image caption,

    Wayne Fitzgerald calls Mohammed Farooq a liar

    We're hearing from Wayne Fitzgerald for the first time since the no confidence motion was passed.

    He says he would like to "apologise to all those people who voted Conservative over the years who have been betrayed by those on my right".

    After calling Mr Farooq "a liar", he is asked by mayor Sandford to withdraw the comment, which he does.

    He adds that when he arrived in the chamber he thought it was Halloween because of a "freak show" on display but realised it had moved into "panto season".

    Mr Fitzgerald ends his remarks - after high tempered exchanges with some former Conservative members about their records in office - by saying: "I have nothing to be ashamed of. I have not been unelected."

  12. 'Opportunistic power grab'published at 21:13 Greenwich Mean Time 1 November 2023

    Conservative Steve Allen said the motion was nothing more than "an illegitimate power grab".

    It has been "dressed up with idealistic clap-trap. An administration of 'me first' masquerading as Peterborough First," he says.

    The motion was supported by a "disparate group of opportunistic opposition parties", he adds, who have no conviction or confidence to run an administration themselves.

  13. Mohammed Farooq proposed as the new council leaderpublished at 21:07 Greenwich Mean Time 1 November 2023

    Mohammed Farooq, member of Peterborough First, has been proposed as the new council leader.

    Despite just being voted out, the Conservative Steve Allen has just proposed Wayne Fitzgerald as a candidate for leader of the council.

    His proposal is met with cheers and applause from the Conservative group.

    Although it seems "a bit odd", constitutionally there is nothing to stop him, says mayor Nick Sandford.

    BBC
  14. What happens next?published at 20:56 Greenwich Mean Time 1 November 2023

    The council has passed the no confidence motion.

    It means that Conservative Wayne Fitzgerald is no longer leader of the council and the Conservative party will no longer form the administration.

    There are some procedural matters to be dealt with next.

    Shortly a new motion will be introduced to elect a new leader and administration.

  15. Motion carriedpublished at 20:52 Greenwich Mean Time 1 November 2023
    Breaking

    The vote has just happened.

    The results are as follows:

    32 in favour

    20 against

    1 abstention

  16. Peterborough First promise stabilitypublished at 20:51 Greenwich Mean Time 1 November 2023

    Summing up, Peterborough First's Chris Harper, who proposed the motion, says his group would "promise that we will put the citizens of Peterborough first, while we have collaboration, listening, transparency, stability and financial competence, and hope for the future of this city".

  17. Lib Dems approached by Peterborough First repeatedlypublished at 20:50 Greenwich Mean Time 1 November 2023

    Christian Hogg, in the light blue sweater, speaks during the debateImage source, Shariqua Ahmed/BBC
    Image caption,

    Christian Hogg, in the light blue sweater, says many things have led him to support the motion

    Liberal Democrat group leader Christian Hogg, one of the councillors who backed the no confidence motion, says Peterborough First made several approaches about taking control.

    He says in July there were a number of motions at a full council that were "very combative" from the administration.

    Under Peterborough First he says there appears to be more allowance for cross party working.

    Fellow Liberal Democrat Chris Wiggin says the "relationship with the administration has broken down".

    "Peterborough First have given me every indication that they will be different," he tells the chamber.

  18. Restraint needed says mayorpublished at 20:44 Greenwich Mean Time 1 November 2023

    Council chamber full of councillors mid debateImage source, Shariqua Ahmed/BBC

    Labour group leader Dennis Jones is speaking to the mayor and says councillors to his left are interrupting people talking. He says that includes Conservatives Wayne Fitzgerald, Steve Allen and Oliver Sainsbury.

    The mayor says it is a "very emotive issue" and that "people need to show restraint".

  19. Conservative councillor 'bamboozled' by motionpublished at 20:35 Greenwich Mean Time 1 November 2023

    Debate ongoing inside the chamberImage source, Shariqua Ahmed/BBC
    Image caption,

    Councillors are sharing their views on the motion

    Conservative Charles Fenner says the motion is "regrettable and wrong".

    A leader needs to be strong and tough, this is not the way to do it, he says.

    Mr Fenner warns that intervention from government "seems more likely" if the motion passes.

    Fellow Conservative Scott Warren says he is "bamboozled" by the motion.

  20. 'You should be ashamed of yourselves'published at 20:33 Greenwich Mean Time 1 November 2023

    Marco Cereste, a Conservative cabinet member responsible for things like planning, lists what he says are achievements in the city, including opening a new university, education improvements and creating new jobs.

    He says the motion is "the worst form of democracy" and asks members to "think twice" before voting for it. Those who support it, he concludes, should be "ashamed of yourselves".

    Councillor Marco Cereste speaking against the motionImage source, Shariqua Ahmed/BBC
    Image caption,

    Councillor Marco Cereste says the motion is "the worst form of democracy"

    Stephen Lane of Peterborough First says he is "100% against this motion".

    He says "cutting the cake differently will not serve up something better nor richer" and he fears "no good can come from this".

    Steve Allen, the deputy leader, says he does not recognise the "weaponization" mentioned in the no confidence motion and that the leader of the council has worked with opposition parties.