Two men on trial for murder 'over black £135 woolly hat'published at 14:35 Greenwich Mean Time 10 November 2020
Two men have gone on trial in Carlisle accused of murdering a man in a row over a £135 woolly beanie hat.
Blair Dixon and Alfonso Bitton each deny murdering 37-year-old John Cingelis (pictured), who was stabbed in the chest, and also deny intentionally wounding his pal Barry Cartwright, who was stabbed in his upper arm.
Carlisle Crown Court heard Mr Dixon and Mr Bitton, both 25 and at the time staying at Eldon Drive, Harraby, are said to have visited the nearby Brantwood Avenue home of Mr Cingelis and his housemate Mr Cartwright, chatting over drinks with them and two women before leaving on good terms.
But a few hours later they returned to claim the black Canada Goose beanie belonging to Mr Dixon and an altercation took place that ended with Mr Cingelis fatally wounded and Mr Cartwright injured.
Mr Dixon does admit possessing a knife, but the prosecution case is that Mr Bitton was equally responsible for what happened.
The court heard the hat was later found at another house where Mr Dixon had left it. The trial continues.