Summary

  • Reaction to the Lords defeat of government plans to cut tax credits

  • Government announces review, led by Lord Strathclyde, into workings of Parliament

  • Chancellor George Osborne says he will "lessen" impact of the cuts

  • He says government will "deal with" constitutional issue of Lords defeating measure backed by MPs

  • Peers backed a Labour motion, by 289 votes to 272, calling for full compensation for those affected

  1. Tuesday afternoon recappublished at 18:18

    Here's a round-up of today’s political developments so far:

  2. Government wins Lords electoral roll votepublished at 18:16

    Opposition peers in the House of Lords have failed in efforts to inflict another defeat on the government, this time over electoral registration.

    Peers rejected a Lib Dem attempt to block moves to accelerate the full switchover to individual registration by 257 votes to 246. 

    Read our full story.

  3. Tax credits: Osborne's optionspublished at 18:14

    Paul Gregg, professor of economic and social policy at Bath University, suggests the most sensible way for Chancellor George Osborne to soften the blow of the tax credit changes would be to increase the amount which people earn before the credits start to be withdrawn.

    Quote Message

    That means that the lower-income people get the maximum compensation from softening the blow. So you're compensating the hardest hit."

    He says this would be "relatively low cost". But it would mean George Osborne either has to slow down the pace of deficit reduction, or try to find the money from elsewhere, he adds.

  4. Tax credits system 'has become expensive'published at 18:12

    Professor Paul Gregg is a former special advisor to Gordon Brown at the Treasury and helped design tax credits.

    He tells BBC Radio 4's PM programme the system "has become very expensive", in part because it became a way of trying to "soften the blow" of the recession - with Labour putting extra money into tax credits.

    Falling wages over the last few years have also "increased the burden", he adds.

    Quote Message

    The system is expensive. It is quite sensible that the government would be looking to use a period of rising employment and wages to reduce the extent of the tax credits bill but it's the severity, speed and the focus of the tax credit cuts which makes people uncomfortable."

  5. Peer: We must address 'over-representation' in Lordspublished at 17;15

    Lord Cormack

    Back in the House of Lords, Conservative peer Lord Cormack addresses the number of Liberal Democrat peers who are eligible to sit in the upper chamber.

    The Lib Dems have tabled the motion to throw out the timetable to bring in individual voter registration.

    "You have 104 more members than you do in the elected House," Lord Cormack tells them.

    If the size of the Lords is to be addressed, the relative size of parties in the Commons should be kept in mind, he argues.

    Quote Message

    We must address the issue not only of under-representation but of over-representation."

  6. UK Steel 'has failed the country' - MPpublished at 17:16 Greenwich Mean Time 27 October 2015

    BBC Scotland Westminster correspondent tweets...

    This Twitter post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.View original content on Twitter
    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    Skip twitter post

    Allow Twitter content?

    This article contains content provided by Twitter. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. You may want to read Twitter’s cookie policy, external and privacy policy, external before accepting. To view this content choose ‘accept and continue’.

    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    End of twitter post
  7. Family courts must 'let the sunlight in' , says UKIPpublished at 17:00

    The UK Independence Party has launched a review, promised in its election manifesto, of Britain's family courts system. 

    It proposes more extensive use of Special Guardianship Orders, "particularly where a child is made a ward of an extended family member, such as a grandparent", and to "remove the current blanket ban on media reporting of placement and adoption proceedings".

    At a cross-party event in the Commons, the party's only MP Douglas Carswell, said "secrecy" within the system was "allowing social workers to ride roughshod over ordinary people and resulting in the unnecessary breakup of families and forced adoptions".

    Quote Message

    We feel very strongly that the secrecy in the family courts is leading to some outrageous injustices. It’s the big cartel courts and the legal profession and the social workers riding roughshod against ordinary people. We think common sense is needed to address this that means greater sensitivity and more openness in the family courts which this timely paper advocates.”

  8. UK steel industry 'bleeding to death', MPs toldpublished at 16:48

    Tata steel plant, ScunthorpeImage source, PA

    Gareth Stace, director of trade body UK Steel, has said the industry in Britain risks bleeding to death unless the government takes urgent action within weeks.

    He told the Business Select Committee that the situation was very grave, saying:

    Quote Message

    If we were a patient on the operating table, we're bleeding very quickly, and unless that bleeding is stopped very, very soon we're likely to die on that table."

    Mr Stace said that within the last few months, almost a fifth of the work force had lost their jobs, or was under threat of losing them.

    He said the government needed to take action within weeks in five key areas - chief among them, the cost of energy which, he said, was double that paid by the steel sector in France and Germany.

  9. Ken Clarke: Defeat on tax credits is 'real potatoes'published at 16:44

    The World at One
    BBC Radio 4

    Former Conservative Chancellor Ken Clarke said peers have "just cheerily put on hold" £4.5bn of tax credit savings.

    Media caption,

    Peers have "just cheerily put on hold" £4.5bn of tax credit savings says Ken Clarke MP.

  10. Tory peer: 'Absolutely insane' to create more peerspublished at 16:40

    The World at One
    BBC Radio 4

    Conservative peer and former cabinet minister Lord Forsyth told BBC Radio 4's World at One programme earlier the idea of flooding the House of Lords with Tory peers following yesterday's tax credits defeat would be "absolutely insane".

    Media caption,

    Idea of flooding House of Lords with Tory peers "absolutely insane" says Lord Forsyth.

  11. Warnings over health of UK steel industrypublished at 16:23

    BBC Scotland Westminster correspondent tweets...

    This Twitter post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.View original content on Twitter
    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    Skip twitter post

    Allow Twitter content?

    This article contains content provided by Twitter. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. You may want to read Twitter’s cookie policy, external and privacy policy, external before accepting. To view this content choose ‘accept and continue’.

    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    End of twitter post
  12. 'No-one will be robbed of the right to vote' - Tory peerpublished at 16:11 Greenwich Mean Time 27 October 2015

    House of Lords
    Parliament

    Labour spokesman Lord Kennedy of Southwark has moved an amendment to Lord Tyler's motion to reject the order on the grounds it "goes against" the recommendations of the Electoral Commission.

    Labour backs individual electoral registration but opposes the government's move to bring implementation forward to "a mere six weeks away".

    Lord Kennedy told peers the government is making "a rash decision".

    But Conservative Lord Lexden insisted: "No-one will be robbed of the right to vote by this order."

    He said online registration will make the process easier and "the young will be well-represented, as they should be".

  13. Peers debate electoral registration changespublished at 16:10

    House of Lords
    Parliament

    Lord Tyler

    The House of Lords is debating a motion to reject the transitional timetable to move to individual voter registration.

    Lord Tyler, who tabled the motion, claimed the order meant "up to 1.9 million people who are currently on the register, and were on it at the general election in May, will be dropped off it at a stroke".

    He said the government seemed "prepared to risk legal challenges" to forthcoming elections in Scotland, Wales and London.

  14. Justice Committee discuss new court fees and chargespublished at 16:08

    Izin Akhabau
    Political reporter

    Quote Message

    If it’s a penalty which is appropriate, proportionate and imposed when people can afford it, we’ve never opposed that."

    Frances Crook, Chief Executive, Howard League for Penal Reform

    Earlier today, the Commons Justice Committee discussed fees and charges in the court system. Recent reforms mean that anybody convicted of a criminal offence faces a mandatory charge, and civil offences carry enhanced charges.

    Frances Crook, Chief Executive of the Howard League for Penal Reform argued that this was unfair in some cases; such as people in court for begging, which is a criminal offence. She cited the case of a 19-year-old, arrested for begging, calling it "medieval". 

    Questions are also being raised over what the abolition of fees and charges in the court system would mean, and how else savings can be made in the running of the courts system.

    Penelope Gibbs from Transform Justice suggested the government should reform its current prosecution system entirely, rather than chasing "piecemeal" reforms. She cited initiatives such as Operation Turning Point, which has been trialled in Birmingham.

    However, there is some support for the court charges, with figures from a Magistrates Association survey saying 56% of 960 magistrates being in favour of court charges on principle, and Crook suggested that charges were fine as long as judges could exercise discretion.

    You can watch the whole meeting here, external

    Giving evidence were Frances Crook, Chief Executive, Howard League for Penal Reform, Phil Bowen, Director, The Centre for Justice Innovation, Ben Summerskill, Director, The Criminal Justice Alliance, and Penelope Gibbs, Transform Justice; Richard Monkhouse, Chairman, and Malcom Richardson, Deputy Chairman, Magistrates’ Association

  15. EU migrant crisis (part 2)published at 16:00

    Alex Forsyth
    Political correspondent

    Martin SchulzImage source, EPA

    On Sunday an emergency summit was called to address the migrant situation in the Western Balkans.

    European Parliament President Martin Schulz said he left the talks - described as challenging - feeling “deeply worried”.  He told the European Parliament:

    Quote Message

    Promises are being made and they’re not delivered upon. Governments of the right and of the left sometimes think national interests are more important than community solutions. What suffers are the refugees and the cohesion of the European Union."

    Jean-Claude JunckerImage source, AFP/Getty Images

    European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker said the need for a meeting to encourage discussion between member states showed the EU was "not in good shape".

    He said last week countries were “finger pointing” at each other which was the “politics of panic” which would “damage European solidarity”.

    He urged member states to deliver on commitments made in dealing with the migrant crisis.

  16. Migrant crisis 'threatens EU cohesion'published at 16:00

    Alex Forsyth
    Political correspondent

    MigrantsImage source, Reuters

    EU leaders have warned the migrant crisis could threaten the cohesion of the European Union and cause “tectonic changes” in Europe’s political landscape.

    Addressing the European Parliament in Strasbourg, European Council President Donald Tusk said the crisis was the biggest the EU had faced for a decade.

    Quote Message

    This challenge has the potential to change the EU we have built, the potential to destroy achievements such as border-free travel between Schengen countries and cause tectonic changes in the European political landscape. These are not changes for the better.”

    Mr Tusk said these were "extraordinary  times” that required "extraordinary measures, extraordinary sacrifices and extraordinary solidarity” and said he did not want to think of the alternative if member states and European institutions failed to handle the crisis together with unity.

  17. Watch: 'Very serious constitutional problems'published at 15:58

    The Daily Politics

    The constitutional issues raised by Monday's votes in the House of Lords on tax credit cuts are explored by Liberal Democrat peer Paul Tyler and the constitutional expert Vernon Bogdanor.

    They spoke to Jo Coburn, and guest Toby Young, about the fallout from the vote, and how the government might act after it lost a vote on welfare changes. 

    Media caption,

    Constitutional issues raised by Lords vote on tax credits

  18. Watch: This is quite without precedence, says Tory MPpublished at 15:57

    The Daily Politics

    A Conservative MP defended government plans for tax credits, saying it was a "crazy situation" where spending on them had risen from £6bn to £30bn, while in-work poverty was rising.

    Oliver Dowden, who was once David Cameron's deputy chief of staff, said a lack of action would mean cuts to health and education spending, or higher taxes.

    And he spoke to Jo Coburn on the Daily Politics about the "legitimacy" of Lib Dems using their 100 peers to "overturn something that has been introduced by a majority government, and which was promised and clearly signalled during the election campaign.”

    Media caption,

    Tax credit cuts: Dowden on Lib Dems and peers

  19. Minister's CSR/CSI confusionpublished at 15:45

    This Twitter post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.View original content on Twitter
    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    Skip twitter post

    Allow Twitter content?

    This article contains content provided by Twitter. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. You may want to read Twitter’s cookie policy, external and privacy policy, external before accepting. To view this content choose ‘accept and continue’.

    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    End of twitter post

    A government minister has been corrected by colleagues in the House of Lords after appearing to confuse the government's internal budget procedure with the American TV series "Crime Scene Investigation".

    Internet Security Minister Lady Shields was asked by Labour about the government's Comprehensive Spending Review - widely known in Westminster as the "CSR".

    The Anglo-American technology executive - who was appointed to the Lords last year - asked peers: "I'm sorry, I'm not familiar with... What is CSI?"

    Labour's culture spokesman, Lord Stevenson of Balmacara, explained to Baroness Shields: "The CSR is forthcoming and will be involving public expenditure for the whole of the public sector." A number of peers then mouthed at her the words "Comprehensive Spending Review".

    The minister replied: "Thank you for bringing the Comprehensive Spending Review to my attention and we'll look into it."

    Lady Shields was appointed as a minister in May this year, having previously acted as a "digital adviser" to David Cameron.

  20. George Osborne: I've always backed elected Lordspublished at 15:35

    House of Lords

    In his interview with BBC economics editor Robert Peston, George Osborne said he had always supported and voted in favour of an elected House of Lords. But he said there wasn't a Commons majority in favour of it.

    He added that the Lords, while it existed in its current form, should "respect" the constitutional convention that says the elected Commons votes on financial matters and the unelected Lords doesn't.