I spoke to passengers in Manchester. The first six said HS2 wouldn't make a differencepublished at 15:33 British Summer Time 4 October 2023
Judith Moritz
Reporting from Manchester Piccadilly
![Striking workers hold up a sign reading "unity is strength"](https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/ace/standard/640/cpsprodpb/vivo/live/images/2023/10/4/bc17a71e-cd0b-4c17-8bb5-df6b37797dd2.jpg.webp)
There's another train strike today, with drivers from the Aslef union on the picket line outside Manchester Piccadilly station
Just a stone’s throw from the Conservative conference, the mood at Manchester Piccadilly station is one of weary resignation.
The passengers I've spoken to are struggling to travel on yet another strike day, and the news about HS2 is hardly a surprise. "Trains? Don’t get me started!" is the common reaction when I ask for views.
But when you probe for more detail, much like the train schedules, things aren't so straightforward.
The first six passengers I met told me that HS2 wouldn't make a difference to their lives. Travel to London wasn't on their agenda. But travel across the local area, over the Pennines, and in and out of Manchester airport, was a priority.
Local business, civic and political leaders have slated the decision to cancel the new line.
And some of the passengers I’ve met have echoed those sentiments, saying it will only serve to reinforce the North/South divide. But others are clearly more bothered about local services, and the desperate need for improved links between northern towns and cities.
Most folk here are still unclear about how much of what’s been announced today is genuinely new. But there’s one thing everyone seems to agree on - train travel is a mess, and improvements can’t come quickly enough.