BBC Scotland political editor Brian Taylor advises caution in assuming whether or not the outcome of the EU referendum would result in a new vote on independence.

He told Jackie Bird: "The entire thing is in the mists of uncertainty on Thursday.

"On what the Scottish government might seek to do, I don't think they would regard another independence referendum as an absolutely guaranteed prospect in the event that Britain votes to leave but I think they try to set the treadmill in motion."

Asked about the possibility of a second independence referendum in Scotland following Brexit, Michael Forsyth says supporters of the UK in Scotland have a clear incentive to vote Leave.

He told Glenn Campbell: "If the argument is... if England votes to leave but Scotland votes to remain, then we should have another referendum.

"The simple message to anyone who wants to keep the Union is that you should vote Leave in Scotland."

Pro-European and SNP MP sets out the case for how a second Scottish independence referendum might happen.

Anti-European and former SNP deputy leader Jim Sillars says why he believes a second Scottish independence referendum would not happen in the event of Brexit.

Ms Dugdale said she opposed a second independence referendum for Scotland over the next five years, saying the result of the 2014 vote needed to be "respected".

The SNP MP, for the the Remain campaign, told the debate: "We have a skills gap in Scotland, it needs to be filled. We need more immigrants."

She added there was no reason why free movement should prevent the UK from doing its fair share of taking in refugees or having a sensible immigration policy.

"We are not all Nigel Farages," says Jim Sillars on the topic of immigration.

"What we need is a rational sensible adult discussion.

"Not so much a debate, but a discussion about immigration."

UKIP leader Nigel Farage posed next to a billboard showing a crowd of people who appear to be migrants or refugees, with the words "Breaking Point" in large letters.

But she said that a vote to Leave would not necessarily mean a better deal for farmers or fisherman.

She asked the audience: "Do you genuinely believe that a Tory government would want to give more money to farmers. Do you think they want to give more money to the NHS?"

The Scottish Labour leader also called Leave claims that 60% of laws came from Europe "scaremongering stories".

She said only 13% of UK laws even referenced the EU.

Michael Forsyth waves a £10 note at the audience and claims the UK gets £10 back for every £20 it sends to the EU.

The SNP MP said this was how the Norwegian prime minister had recently described her government.

She added that the UK could not predict what the terms of an agreement with Europe would be if they left the EU.

Douglas Fraser
Scotland business & economy editor

Exports and imports are at the heart of the European project. And in this referendum, a lot hinges on how they would be affected. 

In this piece, I tackle some of the key questions in the debate, including whether Scotland would be better or worse off economically if it left the EU.

Former Scottish Secretary and Tory peer Michael Forsyth plays down the chances of a major economic shock from Brexit.

"Despite all the scare mongering that's been going on, if you look at the markets today the pound is broadly where it was before the referendum was announced," he said.

The Remain campaigner told the audience that Scotland benefited from £16bn a year from Europe.

The Scottish Labour leader said the effect would be seen "almost instantly" as markets opened on Friday, if there was a vote to leave.

But she said she wanted to create a positive case to remain, rather than to scare people.

It's time: Reporting Scotland's live EU referendum debate on BBC One Scotland