Summary

  • PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR LIVE TEXT COVERAGE

  • The Health Committee took evidence from the health secretary and campaigners on the controversial Penrose Inquiry into blood contaminations

  • The 50% increase in households requesting financial assistance to pay fuel and heating bills and the productivity of the Laggan and Tormore fields west of Shetland were raised in topical questions

  • MSPs debated the Transplantation (Authorisation of Removal of Organs etc.) (Scotland) Bill for the first time, before being asked to pass its general principles

  • The Public Audit Committee led a debate on audits of North Glasgow College in 2012-13 and Coatbridge College in 2013-14 and on an overview of Scotland's Colleges in 2015

  • Lib Dem MSP Tavish Scott led a member's debate on broadband and mobile phone coverage in rural and island communities

  1. Video stories of victims to be told at Holyroodpublished at 10:19 Greenwich Mean Time 9 February 2016

    Philip Dolan from the Scottish Infected Blood Forum says he hopes MSPs will come to the Scottish Parliament tomorrow night where video stories of the victims will be told.

  2. People need support with the stigma - Hepatitis C Trustpublished at 10:18 Greenwich Mean Time 9 February 2016

    Petra Wright from the Hepatitis C Trust says a number of people die during stage one of this disease and they are unable to work and got no financial support.

    Petra Wright

    People also need support with small things like the stigma attached to this condition because sufferers are keeping it a secret, She says.  

  3. 'The widows in this story have been treated shoddily'published at 10:15 Greenwich Mean Time 9 February 2016

    Bill Wright from Haemophilia Scotland says there are families where it is likely the infected partner will die and he emotionally highlights the need for partners and widows left behind to be supported. 

    "The widows in this story have been treated shoddily."

    Bill Wright from Haemophilia Scotland

    Mr Wright stresses that those who have lost loved ones should not have to wait another 17 years for justice.

    "We need government to move on this and to make an early announcement" so that partners know there will be sound financial support for those left behind.

  4. 'The big thing for many people is financial recognition'published at 10:14 Greenwich Mean Time 9 February 2016

    Bill Wright from Haemophilia Scotland says for many people it is not about money.

    Mr Wright says the apologies from the first minister, the health secretary and the Scottish National Blood Transfusion meant a lot.

    Blood transfusion

    However, "the big thing for many people is financial recognition". 

    Going down the legal route will take years and years, "we want to get money to people as soon as possible", he says. 

  5. How could a rightful closure be achieved?published at 10:09 Greenwich Mean Time 9 February 2016

    SNP MSP Richard Lyle says people want closure on this now and asks the witness how this would best be achieved.

    SNP MSP Richard Lyle
  6. Background: Hillsborough disaster and its aftermathpublished at 10:03 Greenwich Mean Time 9 February 2016

    Although it remains the name of the ground of one of England's famous old football clubs, since 1989 the word Hillsborough has more strongly evoked Britain's worst sporting disaster.

    On 15 April 1989, at the start of an FA Cup semi-final, a crush on the steel-fenced terraces of Sheffield Wednesday's stadium resulted in the death of 96 Liverpool fans and left hundreds more injured.  

    Hillsborough 1989
    Image caption,

    The scene of the disaster on 15 April 1989.

    The inquiry into the disaster, led by Lord Justice Taylor, established the main cause as a failure of police crowd control.

    Despite the Taylor Report, which was also critical of Sheffield Wednesday Football Club and Sheffield City Council, on 14 August 1990 the director of public prosecutions decided not to bring criminal charges against any individual, group or body on the grounds of insufficient evidence.  

  7. Parallels between the Penrose Inquiry and the Taylor Inquiry into Hillsborough - Mr Wrightpublished at 10:01 Greenwich Mean Time 9 February 2016

    Bill Wright from Haemophilia Scotland says there are a lot of parallels between the Penrose Inquiry and the Taylor Inquiry into Hillsborough. 

    Hillsborough disaster 1989
    Image caption,

    Hillsborough disaster 1989

    Mr Wright says Lord Penrose was defensive in his approach.

    He says the inquiry system needs to be looked at the Penrose Inquiry must be followed up.

  8. Background: Contaminated blood: Victims 'should have compensation doubled'published at 09:55 Greenwich Mean Time 9 February 2016

    People infected by contaminated NHS blood products should have their compensation nearly doubled, a report to the Scottish government has recommended.

    It said those infected with HIV, or who developed advanced Hepatitis C, should get £27,000 per year - the equivalent of the average Scottish salary.

    They are currently offered £15,000.

    The Scottish government said it had yet to decide whether to implement the new proposals.

    bloodImage source, SPL

    Campaigners have been split over the level of payouts, with some saying more money should be found.

    The move follows the publication of the findings of the Penrose Inquiry, external into the contamination of blood supplies in the 1970s and 80s.

    Financial support is targeted at people who were infected by their NHS treatment, including haemophiliacs and people who have had blood transfusions.

    Many went on to suffer conditions such as liver disease.

    The Department of Health recently estimated the number of victims was 30,000 UK-wide.

  9. Absolutely there should have been blame apportioned - Mr Dolanpublished at 09:55 Greenwich Mean Time 9 February 2016

    Philip Dolan agrees, absolutely there should have been blame apportioned. 

    Blood transfusion

    Mr Dolan says a lot of the members of the Scottish Infected Blood Forum got Hepatitis C from blood transfusions.   

  10. No blame or liabilitypublished at 09:53 Greenwich Mean Time 9 February 2016

    SNP MSP Richard Lyle asks if it was a witness that the Penrose Inquiry did not apportion blame or liability. 

  11. Mr Dolan says some of the expert evidence was questionablepublished at 09:52 Greenwich Mean Time 9 February 2016

    Philip Dolan MBE from the Scottish Infected Blood Forum again stresses that he feels not enough victims gave evidence to the inquiry. 

    Philip Dolan MBE from the Scottish Infected Blood Forum

    Mr Dolan says some of the expert evidence was questionable.

    "It was a waste of £12m."

  12. One single recommendation from the Penrose Inquiry is 'extremely odd' - Haemophilia Scotlandpublished at 09:49 Greenwich Mean Time 9 February 2016

    Bill Wright from Haemophilia Scotland says Crown immunity was used as a "savage tool" to prevent people getting to the truth.

    Bill Wright from Haemophilia Scotland

    Mr Wright says no evidence was taken from Dr David Owen.

    He says there was not a great deal of judgement exercised in the Penrose Inquiry and one single recommendation is "extremely odd".

  13. Background: Penrose Inquiry responsepublished at 09:46 Greenwich Mean Time 9 February 2016

    There was an angry response to the report, external from victims and relatives who had gathered at the National Museum in Edinburgh to see its publication after a six-year wait, with shouts of "whitewash" after its conclusions were read out.

    Victims of Scotland's blood contamination scandal shout "whitewash"Image source, bbc
    Image caption,

    Victims of Scotland's blood contamination scandal shouted "whitewash" at the inquiry's news conference

    The contaminated blood scandal has been described as the worst treatment disaster in the history of the NHS, and was responsible for the deaths of hundreds of people, many of whom had been haemophilia patients.  

  14. 'Time is short for people with Hepatitis C.'published at 09:46 Greenwich Mean Time 9 February 2016

    Petra Wright from the Hepatitis C Trust says victims have been waiting 30 years and 17 years since the inquiry process started.

    Petra Wright from the Hepatitis C Trust

    Ms Wright says she suffers from Hepatitis C and to finally get one recommendation which has not been implemented after a year is not good enough. 

    "Time is short for people with Hepatitis C."

  15. Philip Dolan says 'many people wanted to give their story, but were not heard'published at 09:43 Greenwich Mean Time 9 February 2016

    Philip Dolan from the Scottish Infected Blood Forum says he has been haunting this place since 1999.

    Mr Dolan says "many people wanted to give their story, but were not heard". 

    Only six of the victims were called, he says.

    Philip Dolan from the Scottish Infected Blood Forum

    Mr Dolan, who has haemophilia and Hepatitis C, says the appeal about Lord Penrose's decision was heard by himself, which goes against natural justice.

    He says Lord Penrose was told that Mr Dolan had the Sword of Damocles hanging over him in relation to his Hepatitis C, he replied "you mean a feather duster".

  16. People died in the time it took for the Penrose Inquiry to report - Witnesspublished at 09:38 Greenwich Mean Time 9 February 2016

    Mr Wright says that people died in the time it took for the Penrose Inquiry to report and it only made one recommendation. 

  17. Background: Reaction from Haemophilia Scotlandpublished at 09:37 Greenwich Mean Time 9 February 2016

    Bill Wright, from Haemophilia Scotland said of the report: "It's not about broken processes, it's about broken lives" and said it was the time for an apology.

    Mr Wright added: "At first sight the report appears to disorganised and impenetrable. Worse still it might appear on first reading to be a whitewash with frankly some of the chairman's assertions seemingly barely rational.

    "Look a bit deeper and there is a narrative setting out the case that cannot be avoided by the government and its moral responsibility."

    Blood

    He said there needed to be an "official apology", better compensation and a review of the report.

    The inquiry's remit was to investigate how the NHS collected, treated and supplied blood.

    Lord Penrose also scrutinised what patients were told, how they were monitored and why patients became infected.

  18. Penrose Inquiry a 'whitewash'published at 09:37 Greenwich Mean Time 9 February 2016

    Bill Wright from Haemophilia Scotland says the common term used for the six year long Penrose Inquiry was a "whitewash".

    Bill Wright from Haemophilia Scotland

    Mr Wright says the it has brought the whole inquiry system into dispute.

  19. Question about effectiveness of the Penrose Inquirypublished at 09:35 Greenwich Mean Time 9 February 2016

    SNP MSP Richard Lyle begins by outlining the timeline that led to the Penrose Inquiry.

    SNP MSP Richard Lyle

    Mr Lyle says this has taken 17 years to get to this position and he highlights criticism of the inquiry.

  20. Background: Penrose Inquirypublished at 09:32 Greenwich Mean Time 9 February 2016

    Last year Prime Minister David Cameron apologised on behalf of the British government to victims of the contaminated blood scandal.

    It came after a Scottish inquiry described the saga as "the stuff of nightmares".

    Thousands of people were infected with Hepatitis C and HIV through NHS blood products in the 1970s and 80s.

    Blood

    But the inquiry concluded few matters could have been done differently.

    And it made only a single recommendation - that anyone in Scotland who had a blood transfusion before 1991 should be tested for Hepatitis C if they have not already done so.