Summary

  • PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR FULL TEXT COVERAGE

  • Scotland’s new Chief Constable, Phil Gormely appeared before the Public Audit Committee

  • Finance, constitution and economy ministers took the hot seat for portfolio questions

  • Labour led a debate calling on education spending to be protected in real terms over the next five years

  • Labour MSP Margaret McCulloch led a member’s debate marking International Day of Zero Tolerance for Female Genital Mutilation.

  1. International Day of Zero Tolerance for Female Genital Mutilation debatepublished at 17:08 Greenwich Mean Time 10 February 2016

    Scottish Labour MSP Margaret McCulloch uses her member's debate to highlight the International Day of Zero Tolerance for Female Genital Mutilation. 

  2. MSPs reject Labour call for education spending to be protectedpublished at 17:07 Greenwich Mean Time 10 February 2016

    MSP reject the Labour call for education spending to be protected in real terms over the next five years, in its motion, by voting for the Scottish government amendment. 

    Iain Gray

    In an extremely tight vote, 61 MSPs back the amended motion, with 60 MSPs voting against it.

    61 MSPs backed the amendment from the education secretary and 59 voted against, with one abstention.

    The Conservative and Lib Dem amendments both fell.

  3. SCRIT is progressive insists Mr Graypublished at 17:00 Greenwich Mean Time 10 February 2016

    Mr Gray says the Scottish government has cut hundreds of millions of pounds from local authorities, which pay for schools and teachers. 

    The Labour MSP says these cuts damage schools.

    Classroom - pupil with his hand up

    He calls on MSPs come together and make a promise that for the next five years they will use the powers of this parliament to protect education. 

    Scottish Labour's opportunity spokesperson says the argument that the SCRIT is not progressive is nonsense, just listen to the finance secretary who said it was progressive. 

    He concludes asking if MSPs will rise to the occasion and vote to protect Scotland's education system for the next five years.

  4. Labour MSP: 'We have to be prepared to stand up for education'published at 16:53 Greenwich Mean Time 10 February 2016

    Scottish Labour's opportunity spokesperson Iain Gray says education is the best chance of a better life, referring to his time teaching in Mozambique. 

    Mr Gray says Scotland should be willing to protect its education system as its very first priority.

    Scottish Labour's opportunity spokesperson Iain Gray

    The former Scottish Labour leader says we have to be prepared to stand up for education.

    He lambasts the Scottish government's record on education citing falling teacher numbers, increased class sizes and falling college place.

  5. Promising signs of closing the attainment gap, but much more to do - Ministerpublished at 16:44 Greenwich Mean Time 10 February 2016

    Mr Allan says there is much more to do in closing the attainment gap, but there are promising signs of progress.

    Labour MSP Alex Rowley says cutting classroom assistants increases pressure on teachers.

    Teacher teaching class

    The minister says yes there has been a huge work load on teachers, which is why he is tackling bureaucracy giving teachers time to teach.

    Mr Allan says the SNP's policies are focused on helping those from the most disadvantaged backgrounds.

  6. Minister says funding for education has increased by 1% in cash termspublished at 16:42 Greenwich Mean Time 10 February 2016

    Learning Minister Alasdair Allan says at times this debate has effectively been about reality and fantasy.

    Mr Allan says the reality of Scotland's education system is inspiring.

    Learning Minister Alasdair Allan

    The minister says funding for education has in fact increased by 1% in cash terms. 

    He says councils have indicated they are spending 3.3% more on education in cash terms.

  7. 'My goodness they know how to create problems'published at 16:38 Greenwich Mean Time 10 February 2016

    Scottish Conservative MSP Mary Scanlon says not only is the relationship with local authorities at an all time low, but the SNP has managed to have a battle with every single university in Scotland.

    Scottish universityImage source, PA

    Ms Scanlon says: "My goodness they know how to create problems."

  8. Spend to save policy should be adopted - Tory MSPpublished at 16:34 Greenwich Mean Time 10 February 2016

    Conservative MSP Mary Scanlon says she would like to look at a spend to save policy. 

    It's a policy to help close the attainment gap, she says.

    Conservative MSP Mary Scanlon

    Ms Scanlon says helping children with counselling in early school life can help to improve attainment, behaviour and attendance.

    She says school based councillors is being rolled out in England but in Scotland the government is not progressive enough.

  9. Lib Dem MSP says raising income tax by 1p is progressivepublished at 16:31 Greenwich Mean Time 10 February 2016

    Mr McArthur says the SNP have opted for savage cuts and blaming Westminster rather than using new tax powers and developing a pupil premium and reparing the damage to the college sector.

    Pupils
    Image caption,

    The Lib Dem MSP calls for a pupil premium funded by an income tax increases of 1p

    He insists raising income tax by 1p is progressive.

    The Lib Dem MSP says SNP Members solely want to focus on the earnings side and accuses them of "statistical chicanery". 

  10. Warnings about education from OECD says Lib Dempublished at 16:29 Greenwich Mean Time 10 February 2016

    Scottish Lib Dem education spokesperson Liam McArthur says there are many areas where Scotland's education is genuinely world class.

    However, Mr McArthur says the OECD report gave ample evidence of the warnings about education here. 

    Scottish Lib Dem education spokesperson Liam McArthur

    He criticises the attainment fund as an area based approach which ignores or underplays poverty and deprivation across the country.

    The Lib Dem MSP also speaks out against standardised testing in primary schools.

  11. Rebate scheme must be explained - SNP MSPpublished at 16:25 Greenwich Mean Time 10 February 2016

    SNP MSP Mark McDonald says there has been an element of double standards in this debate.

    Mr McDonald says if Labour want to throw stones they should step out of their glass houses before doing so.

    Mark McDonald SNP MSP

    The SNP MSP says in his constituency schools have merged to move pupils from buildings that were not fit for purpose to state-of-the-art learning facilities.

    He says he welcomes the promise from the minister to review how schools deliver education for children with additional learning needs.

    Mr McDonald ends by saying Labour should layout how the rebate scheme will work. 

  12. SNP MSP not prepared to ask those on lower incomes to pay more taxpublished at 16:12 Greenwich Mean Time 10 February 2016

    SNP MSP Stuart McMillan says one of the biggest challenges is parents who don't really see university as something for them or their family.

    Scottish Labour leader Kezia Dugdale asks Mr McMillan if he would be prepared to pay a bit more tax.

    SNP MSP Stuart McMillan

    Mr McMillan says he is prepared to pay more tax, but he is not prepared to ask those on lower incomes to pay more tax.

    He says education under the Scottish government is progressing and moving forward and Labour's sums do not add up. 

  13. Background: OECD negatives on Curriculum for Excellencepublished at 15:52 Greenwich Mean Time 10 February 2016

    The OECD review also highlighted some "problems and challenges", including:

    • a fifth of schools are rated only "satisfactory" and one in 10 is "weak or unsatisfactory" 
    • there have been declining relative and absolute achievement levels in maths 
    • recent data suggests there are smaller relative numbers of top reading performers among primary and secondary students - and large numbers of low performers in secondary schools 
    • positive attitudes to school drop off sharply at secondary level  
  14. Point of order raisedpublished at 15:46 Greenwich Mean Time 10 February 2016

    Labour MSP Drew Smith asks if it is in order to repeatedly call others hypocrites and refuse to engage in debate, citing SNP MSP Joan McAlpine.

    Labour MSP Drew Smith

    Deputy Presiding Officer John Scott says that is not a point of order, but says there is some time for members to take interventions if they wish.

  15. Raising tax is not the way to tackle educational attainment - SNP MSPpublished at 15:46 Greenwich Mean Time 10 February 2016

    SNP MSP Joan McAlpine says taxing postal workers, nurses and others more doesn't seem to be the way to tackle educational attainment to her.

    Ms McAlpine says it is important to look at the budget as a whole because things such as health and housing are being protected by Westminster Tory cuts. 

    SNP MSP Joan McAlpine

    The SNP MSP says the government would like to protect every area but you cannot when your budget is being cut by 12.5%.

    She closes by saying Labour are displaying hypocrisy because some local governments are handing back funds. 

  16. 'End the scaremongering' saysLabour MSPpublished at 15:39 Greenwich Mean Time 10 February 2016

    Ms Lamont asks why the SNP have moved so quickly to rubbish Labour's proposal.

    "As a young school teacher, I was blessed to get a job straight away", she says.

    Teacher with children in a classroom

    The Labour MSP says she was employed during the height of Thatcherism and tax hikes and that should put Labour's one pence tax increase request into perspective. 

    She closes by asking for the motion to be supported and asking for an end to the scaremongering. 

  17. Low paid earners being used as a 'human shield' - Labour MSPpublished at 15:35 Greenwich Mean Time 10 February 2016

    Labour MSP Johann Lamont says SNP MSP George Adam probably does not consider himself a Tory but the speech he has just given reflects one.

    The former teacher says that the squabbling in the chamber today is something school children would be ashamed of.

    Labour MSP Johann Lamont

    Ms Lamont says there is something distasteful about persuading those on low incomes to be against measures that would help education.

    It's like using low earners as a "human shield", she says. 

  18. Background: OECD positives on Curriculum for Excellencepublished at 15:34 Greenwich Mean Time 10 February 2016

    The review of the Curriculum for Excellence (CfE) was undertaken by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). 

    The OECD review, commissioned by the Scottish government, focused on the "broad general education" element of the curriculum up the age of 15 and found "much to be positive about", including: 

    • levels of academic achievement are above international averages in science and reading and close to average in maths 
    • achievement levels are spread relatively equally 
    • Scottish schools do very well on measures of social inclusion and mix. Immigrant children generally perform better than their non-immigrant peers 
    • a large majority of students feel positive about their school and teachers 
    • nine in 10 school leavers enter a "positive follow-up destination" and two thirds stay in education 
  19. SNP MSP says there are 'clear upward trends in attainment and positive destinations'published at 15:27 Greenwich Mean Time 10 February 2016

    SNP MSP George Adam says the Scottish government has put the work on attainment at the top of the agenda.

    SNP MSP George Adam

    Mr Adam says there are clear upward trends in attainment and positive destinations.

    This is not an education system in decline, but one that strives to do better he says. 

  20. Background: Lib Dems propose Scottish income tax rise to fund educationpublished at 15:26 Greenwich Mean Time 10 February 2016

    The Scottish Liberal Democrats have proposed increasing income tax rates by 1p to raise extra funds for schools. 

    Classroom
    Image caption,

    The Liberal Democrats have proposed spending the money raised by the tax hike on education

    The party said the change to rates would raise £475m a year, which it would put towards Scottish education.

    It would be spent on a "pupil premium" to fund children from more deprived backgrounds, early learning, childcare and college provision, and giving money to councils for schools.