Summary

  • The Justice Committee takes evidence on the role of the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service

  • Air pollution and the Scottish Ambulance Service are raised during topical questions

  • The government lead a debate on protecting Scotland's interests in negotiating our future relationship with Europe, following Theresa May's statement.

  • SNP MSP Stewart Stevenson leads this evening's member's debate entitled 'A Sea of Opportunity'

  1. Crown Office agent highlights need for 'significant change, indeed system change'published at 10:32 Greenwich Mean Time 17 January 2017

    Ms Mitchell says the staff feedback says 44% of the staff find the workload is unacceptable, which is 2% above the civil service average.

    Crown Office Agent David Harvie
    Image caption,

    Crown Office Agent David Harvie

    Crown Agent David Harvie says his letter highilghts the need for significant change, indeed system change in its entirety.

    Mr Harvie says the second purpose of the letter was to seek to give reassurance that many of the issues had been recognised.

    He says the evidence before the committee had led to new issues being identified.

  2. Committee convener asks if the Lord Advocate is taking advantage of his staffpublished at 10:25 Greenwich Mean Time 17 January 2017

    Committee convener Margaret Mitchell says her initial reaction to the Crown Office agent's submission is that it is not listening to staff concerns.

    The Conservative MSP asks if the Lord Advocate is taking advantage of the very dedicated, hard working workforce, with 40% saying they don't wish to stay in the service.

    Lord Advocate and Tory MSP Margaret Mitchell

    She says some of the staff have been scared of coming forward.

    Mr Wolffe says he has been very clear that the greatest resource of its service is its staff.

    The Lord Advocate says it is encouraging to see the proportion of staff who wish to stay is considerably higher than the civil service average.

  3. Postpublished at 10:18 Greenwich Mean Time 17 January 2017

    This X post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.View original content on X
    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    Skip X post

    Allow X content?

    This article contains content provided by X. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. You may want to read X’s cookie policy, external and privacy policy, external before accepting. To view this content choose ‘accept and continue’.

    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    End of X post
  4. 'There is that risk, but I don't think it is a significant risk'published at 10:18 Greenwich Mean Time 17 January 2017

    Mr Ross asks about the £750,000 being taken from non staff costs and asks where that 50% of the £1.5m cut from the Scottish government will come from.

    Mr Harvie says there have been savings made in expert witness costs and he is seeking to focus on pathology.

    The Tory MSP says a saving of £1.5m must be made this year and asks if there is a danger more cuts will have to be made in staffing.

    Mr Harvie asks: "There is that risk, but I don't think it is a significant risk."

  5. Crown Office facing 30 job lossespublished at 10:17 Greenwich Mean Time 17 January 2017

    Tory MSP Douglas Ross asks about job losses at the Crown Office.

    David Harvie from the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service says the £750,000 cut will lead to about 30 job losses.

    David Harvie from the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service

    Mr Ross asks if all the fat that can be cut has been cut at senior levels and will budget cuts lead to lower level job losses.

    Mr Harvie says it has become increasingly challenging but intelligent choices can be made.

    He says he will seek to protect frontline staff.

  6. Tory MSP ask if there will be an 'overhaul of the justice system'published at 10:14 Greenwich Mean Time 17 January 2017

    Mr Ross says he has some concerns that nothing is a priority for the Lord Advocate

    The Tory MSPs says he was quite disappointed that a large bulk of the Crown Office response is that the evidence of problems is wrong.

    Lord Advocate and Tory MSP Douglas Ross

    He asks if there will be an overhaul of the justice system as witness after witness has said is required.

    Mr Wolffe says that is an unfair reading of the Crown Office agent's response.

    The Lord Advocate says he acknowledges the challenges COPFS faces.

    He says there are challenges and the Crown Office recognises those.

  7. Lord Advocate says there are a number of challenges the COPFS facespublished at 10:08 Greenwich Mean Time 17 January 2017

    Tory MSP Douglas Ross asks what the biggest failing is the Lord Advocate has identified in the COPFS.

    Mr Wolffe says he hopes Mr Ross will forgive him if he does not identify one issue that is the biggest failing.

    He says there are a number of challenges the service faces.

  8. Lord Advocate and Solicitor General both members of the governmentpublished at 10:06 Greenwich Mean Time 17 January 2017

    SNP MSP Stewart Stevenson asks the Lord Advocate to "lighten his personal darkness" about his role.

    Lord Advocate James Wolffe says he and the Solicitor General are members of the government.

    Lord Advocate James Wolffe
    Image caption,

    Lord Advocate James Wolffe

    Mr Wolffe says by statute he is required to have retained functions, referring to functions long before devolution that go back centuries.

    He says his role as head of prosecutions services is independent.

  9. And we're off........published at 10:01 Greenwich Mean Time 17 January 2017

    The Justice Committee, external continues its Inquiry into the role and purpose of the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service:

    Crown office sign

    Committee convener Margaret Mitchell introduces 

    • Rt Hon James Wolffe QC, Lord Advocate
    • David Harvie from the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service 
  10. 'Professionalism of those working in COPFS front line not in question'published at 09:51 Greenwich Mean Time 17 January 2017

    Margaret Mitchell
    Quote Message

    "The professionalism of those working in the COPFS front line is not in question, but we want to ensure that the system around them works just as well as they do and that there is an acceptance by leadership that there are challenges to confront."

    Margaret Mitchell MSP, Justice Committee Convener

  11. Background: Concerns raised with the effectiveness and efficiency of COPFSpublished at 09:46 Greenwich Mean Time 17 January 2017

    Holyrood’s Justice Committee is to conclude its five month investigation into the effectiveness and efficiency of the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS) by questioning Lord Advocate, James Wolffe. 

    Police with suspect

    During its inquiry the Committee has heard from a wide range of organisations including COPFS employees and unions, victims’ groups, representatives of people in the criminal justice system, lawyers, environmentalists and police.

    Concerns raised throughout the inquiry include:

    • the Crown Office’s prosecution policies and working practices
    • the support offered to victims and witnesses
    • the resources available to the COPFS
    • the efficiency of criminal trials
    • possible reforms to improve the service
  12. 'Serious concerns' raised over amount of time wasted through trialspublished at 09:44 Greenwich Mean Time 17 January 2017

    Quote Message

    “The Justice Committee’s inquiry has unearthed some serious concerns about the COPFS. From the amount of time wasted through trials not proceeding on schedule, to the workload of prosecutors and the support offered to the victims and witnesses who appear at court.

    Margaret Mitchell MSP, Justice Committee Convener

  13. Background: Crown Office has adequate resources to fulfill its role says Lord Advocatepublished at 09:41 Greenwich Mean Time 17 January 2017

    Mr Wolffe previously appeared at Holyrood to give evidence about the draft budget, at which point he argued the Crown Office had adequate resources to fulfill its role.

    Crown Office

    Crown Agent David Harvie, the professional head of the service who is also appearing before the committee, submitted written evidence, external voicing appreciation for the "keen interest" members had taken.

    He said: "The committee's inquiry, and the evidence which it has heard, have provided us with an opportunity to reflect on our current plans, to build on the good work which has been done before, and to take on board the comments and views of those with whom we work and those we serve."

  14. Lord Advocate expected to address 'legitimate concerns'published at 09:39 Greenwich Mean Time 17 January 2017

    Quote Message

    "The justice committee will publish its conclusions in due course, but we hope that the Lord Advocate will have listened to the legitimate concerns raised so far. We are looking for him to address some of the evidence we have heard.

    Margaret Mitchell MSP, Justice Committee Convener

  15. Background: MSPs to quiz Lord Advocate over Crown Office 'concerns'published at 09:37 Greenwich Mean Time 17 January 2017

    MSPs are to question Scotland's Lord Advocate over "serious concerns" about the country's prosecution system.

    Holyrood's justice committee has been holding an inquiry into the role of the Crown Office.

    James Wolffe
    Image caption,

    James Wolffe has argued that the Crown Office has adequate funding from the government

    Members will put issues raised by previous witnesses about resources and victim support to the Lord Advocate, James Wolffe QC, on Tuesday morning.

    Convener Margaret Mitchell said she hoped Mr Wolffe had listened to the "legitimate concerns" raised so far.

    The committee has taken evidence from Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS) employees and unions, victims' groups, lawyers and the police so far, across a five-month inquiry.

  16. Good morning and welcome to Holyrood Livepublished at 18:38 Greenwich Mean Time 16 January 2017

    Good morning and welcome to Holyrood Live's coverage of the Scottish Parliament on Tuesday 17 January 2017.

    This morning we will bring you full and extensive coverage of the Justice Committee as it continues its inquiry into the role and purpose of the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service.

    Prison, exhaust, EU, Scottish and Union flags, fishermanImage source, BBC/Getty

    This afternoon in the chamber, we begin with topical questions on air pollution and the Scottish Ambulance Service.

    The government will then lead a debate on protecting Scotland's interests in negotiating our future relationship with Europe. 

    Following decision time, SNP MSP Stewart Stevenson will lead this evening's member's debate entitled: 'A Sea of Opportunity'.