That's all from Holyrood live for Thursday 2 March 2017.

We'll be back on Tuesday.

Have a good weekend.

The government motion as amended is agreed to, with 62 MSPs for and with 61 against.

So it is defeat for the government.

Image source, Scottish Parliament

Image source, Scottish Parliament

Image source, Scottish Parliament

Image source, Scottish Parliament

The Lib Dem amendment is agreed to with 62 MSPs backing it and 61 against.

Looks like another defeat for the government. 

Image source, Scottish Parliament

The Labour amendment is not agreed to, with 62 MSPs agreeing to it and 61 against.

Image source, Scottish Parliament

The Tory amendment is agreed to unanimously.

Image source, Scottish Parliament

We now move to decision time. 

Labour MSP Elaine Smith asks if waiting up to 24 weeks for hip replacements is acceptable.

Public Health Minister Aileen Campbell says there is capacity in the Golden Jubilee and she says the government is making capacity to cope with demand.

The minister says the teams in the Scottish Patient Safety Programme are ambitious going forward.

She says the improvement approach is being spread beyond health and care.

Image source, Scie

Ms Campbell says we must be aware of consistent negativity on staff.

She says staffing has increased in the NHS.

Image source, Science Photo Library

Mr Sarwar asks if BMA chair Peter Bennie was right and the NHS staffing crisis will lead to a system breakdown.

Ms Campbell hits back saying the government is developing a workforce plan and it is aware there are challenges.

She says it was the SNP that pledged the most funding for the NHS in the last election.

Public Health Minister Aileen Campbell says "while we are not blind to the challenges" it is right to recognise the successes of this programme. 

Ms Cambell says there has been a lot of consensus in the chamber.

The public health minister says there has been a reduction in falls right across the country.

She says it is important to get the older community more active. 

Image source, What Matter To You

Mr Briggs says it is important for all parts of the health service to share the aims of the safety programme and to share best practice.

The Tory MSP says many patients can find hospitals a disorienting environment in the acute wards.

He points to the What Matters To You, external Boards at a patients bedside has helped to personalise care and relieve despair.

Mr Briggs says when the Royal College of GPs and the RCN say there is a crisis in staffing MSPs have a duty to raise the issue.

Tory MSP Miles Briggs says all of the members can support the aims of the Patient Safety Programme.

Mr Briggs says there are key issues around midwife recruitment.

The Tory MSP says technology will play a "huge role".

He says there is some very positive data in the report and parliament should pay tribute to all those who work in the NHS. 

Image source, Scottish Patient Safety Programme

The Scottish Patient Safety Programme (SPSP) is a unique national programme that aims to improve the safety and reliability of healthcare and reduce harm, whenever care is delivered. 

Click here to find out more.  , external

Labour MSP Colin Smyth says all member have acknowledged the successful impact of the Scottish Patient Safety Programme (SPSP).

He says: "It is important we build on the success of the programme."

Mr Smyth highlights the impact of deprivation and health inequalities.

Image source, bbc

He says there is not enough staff in the NHS for them to keep up with growing demand.

"We have a ticking time-bomb of GPs queueing up to retire."

He says: "Yes, it is a crisis."

In closing for his party, Lib Dem MSP Alex Cole-Hamilton says there are huge advances in patient safety because of this plan.

Mr Cole-Hamilton says all the amendments are similar and that is completely uncoordinated. 

The Lib Dem MSP say it is appropriate to bring up the "staffing crisis" in the NHS because this can present problems for staff safety as well as patient safety.

Mr Cole-Hamilton says he hopes the government will respond to his call for a national strategy for dementia patients and dementia wards.

He says "we are far from a step change in mental health."

Tory MSP Jeremy Balfour says the care provided by NHS staff is "fantastic" and just because his party comments on some of the government's policies does not mean they should be accused of "attacking front line staff".

SNP MSP Clare Haughey intervenes to ask Mr Balfour to reflect on the language used by his colleagues and says words like "crisis" has an affect on NHS staff. 

Mr Balfour says it has "nothing to do with the front line staff and all to do with the government and its lack of action".

SNP MSP Clare Haughey says when violence drops to a quarter of previous levels and self harm drops to a third, this is making a real difference in peoples lives.

"This should be applauded," she says.

Greens MSP Alison Johnstone says workforce shortages undermines NHS staff.

Ms Johnstone says many of scotland's neonatal units do not have enough nurses in post.

The Greens MSP says the Patient Safety Programme set ambitious goals and has surpassed most of them.

She says she is glad the Patient Safety Programme is moving into care homes and that we need to promote high standard of safety. 

"We should be proud of the staff that led this challenging work," she says.