Summary

  • The Equalities and Human Rights Committee takes evidence on destitution, asylum and immigration status in Scotland

  • Child fares on public transport and A&E waiting times are among the issues raised in general questions

  • Nicola Sturgeon is quizzed by opposition MSPs during first minister's questions

  • Scottish Lib Dem leader Willie Rennie leads this afternoon's member's debate on the future of Elmwood campus

  • The Scottish government delivers four ministerial statements on the mental health strategy, transvaginal mesh implants, unconventional oil and gas and the Enterprise and Skills Review

  1. Government will make recommendation following consultationpublished at 15:53 British Summer Time 30 March 2017

    Mr Wheelhouse says the consultation has been viewed as valuable by members of the public.

    The energy minister says the government are committed to providing all the results and making a recommendation on it when the consultation is over. 

  2. Unconventional oil and gas consultation ends on the 31st of May published at 15:52 British Summer Time 30 March 2017

    Energy Minister Paul Wheelhouse says it is clear to all no one study can give a conclusive vieww on fracking.

    Mr Wheelhouse says the reports do not recommend whether unconventional oil and gas should occur or not.

    He says the consultation will last for four months ending on the 31st of May.

  3. Consultation results will form a key part of the Energy Strategy - minister published at 15:51 British Summer Time 30 March 2017

    Paul Wheelhouse

    Mr Wheelhouse says results of the consultation on unconventional oil and gas will form a key part of the Energy Strategy. 

    The energy minister says the Scottish government has sought to build a comprehensive evidence base.

    He says there has been gaps in the evidence base.

    Mr Wheelhouse says the government and the public have had the opportunity to scrutinise published reports.

  4. Background: Scottish government to 'block' underground coal gasification published at 15:50 British Summer Time 30 March 2017

    Underground coal gasificationImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    Cluff Natural Resources had planned to extract gas from the estimated 335 million tonnes of coal under the Firth of Forth

    The Scottish government has said it "cannot support" underground coal gasification, after a new report raised environmental concerns.

    Energy minister Paul Wheelhouse told MSPs that the gas extraction technique "poses numerous and serious environmental risks".

    He said it would have "no place in Scotland's energy mix at this time".

    Green groups welcomed the news, but the Conservatives said they were "deeply disappointed".

    Mr Wheelhouse said separate reports on hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, would be published after the parliamentary recess, with a consultation on that technique to follow.

  5. Energy Minister says it is important to consult local communities published at 15:49 British Summer Time 30 March 2017

    Energy Minister Paul Wheelhouse says it is important to consult local communities.

    Mr Wheelhouse says the choices Scotland make about energy are amongst the most important decisions we face.

    He says the Scottish government is determined to achieve a low carbon economy through stable transition.

    The minister reiterates his previous statement under ground coal gassification should have no place in Scotland's energy mix.

  6. Government will continue with 'cautious approach' - ministerpublished at 15:48 British Summer Time 30 March 2017

    Energy Minister Paul Wheelhouse
    Image caption,

    Energy Minister Paul Wheelhouse

    Energy Minister Paul Wheelhouse says the government have continually presented impartial information on unconventional oil and gas to promote debate.

    Mr Wheelhouse says the government will maintain that position. 

    The energy minister says that the government will continue with its cautious, evidence led approach.

    He says there are those who will argue for extraction or a ban without concern for the opposing point of view. 

  7. Background: MSPs vote in favour of a fracking ban as SNP abstain published at 15:45 British Summer Time 30 March 2017

    
          Roseanna Cunningham led a debate on the environment at Holyrood
        Image source, bbc
    Image caption,

    Roseanna Cunningham led a debate on the environment at Holyrood

    Last June the Scottish Parliament voted to support an outright ban on fracking after SNP MSPs abstained.

    Labour tabled an amendment saying there "should" be a full ban as part of an environment debate headed by new cabinet secretary Roseanna Cunningham.

    After SNP members abstained, the motion was passed by 32 votes to 29.

    Energy Minister Paul Wheelhouse said there needed to be proper research and a public consultation before a decision was taken on fracking.

    
          Fracking involves using a high-pressure water mixture to penetrate rock in order to release gas
        Image source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Fracking involves using a high-pressure water mixture to penetrate rock in order to release gas

    Scottish Labour said it would be "outrageous" if the SNP "ignored" the result of the vote.

    The amendment is not a binding policy, but represents a defeat for the SNP, which  supports a moratorium on fracking  but stops short of backing a full ban.

    The SNP's manifesto for the Holyrood election committed to there being no fracking in Scotland "unless it can be proven beyond doubt that there is no risk to health, communities or the environment".

    Labour, the Lib Dems and the Greens favour an immediate and outright ban, while First Minister Nicola Sturgeon has said she was "highly sceptical" about the technique.

    Read more here.

  8. Background: Scottish fracking consultation launchedpublished at 15:44 British Summer Time 30 March 2017

    FrackingImage source, PA

    In January the Scottish government launched a public consultation on whether unconventional oil and gas extraction (UOG) should be allowed in the country.

    A moratorium on UOG, which includes hydraulic fracking, has been in place since January 2015.

    Since then, the government has been examining the evidence before deciding whether or not a full ban should be put in place.

    A final decision is  expected to be made later this year .

    The public consultation, which has seen the creation of a  dedicated website, external , follows the publication in November of six reports examining the potential economic, health and environmental impact of fracking.

    Read more here.

  9. Fracking statementpublished at 15:44 British Summer Time 30 March 2017

    Energy Minister Paul Wheelhouse will now give a ministerial statement on unconventional oil and gas.

  10. Former health secretary 'disturbed and disappointed'published at 15:44 British Summer Time 30 March 2017

    Alex Neil

    SNP MSP Alex Neil says, as the former health secretary who set up the review, he is "disturbed and disappointed" with the way it has ended.

    Mr Neil says he would welcome a formal review. 

    The SNP MSP says if we lose the trust of those involved in a review it will not be worth the paper it is written on.

    Ms Robison says she recognises that lessons must be learned from this. 

  11. Fully informed mesh implant procedures not banned says minister published at 15:41 British Summer Time 30 March 2017

    Health Secretary Shona RobisonImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    Health Secretary Shona Robison

    Lib Dem MSP Mike Rumbles asks about the precautionary principle and asks how many health boards ignored the call for a suspension and how many procedures have taken place.

    Health Secretary Shona Robison says because this was not a banned procedure, if a woman wanted to go ahead having had the risks explained, there was nothing to stop that if it was fully informed.

  12. This has "resulted in women losing their livelihood and ruining their relationships' - Greens MSP published at 15:40 British Summer Time 30 March 2017

    Greens MSP Alison Johnstone
    Image caption,

    Greens MSP Alison Johnstone

    Greens MSP Alison Johnstone says this has "resulted in women losing their livelihood and ruining their relationships".

    Ms Johnstone says some women have been unable to pick up their children.

    The Greens MSP asks what support is in place for them.

    Ms Robison says all women going through this procedure must be informed of all the risks and publication must clearly outline the risks.

    The health secretary says she would expect support to continue to be available to those affected.

  13. Robison says government cannot ban mesh implants that is the responsibility of the MHRA published at 15:28 British Summer Time 30 March 2017

    Health Secretary Shona RobisonImage source, bbc
    Image caption,

    Health Secretary Shona Robison

    Health Secretary Shona Robison also pays tribute to Neil Findlay and the work he has done in pursuing this issue and the support he has given to the women affected.

    Ms Robison says she is sure there will be a chance to debate this issue in future.

    The time gap was due to reports being published which were incorporated into the final report, she says.

    The minister says she has contacted Ms McIlroy and Ms Holmes about the missing aspect of the report.

    She says the government cannot ban mesh implants that is the responsibility of the MHRA.

  14. Review a 'cover up' and it will not be accepted says Labour MSP published at 15:27 British Summer Time 30 March 2017

    Labour MSP Neil Findlay
    Image caption,

    Labour MSP Neil Findlay

    Labour MSP Neil Findlay says the mesh survivors and their families are furious at this report.

    He says it is scanadalous that a few minutes have been dedicated to it and calls for a full debate.

    He asks why mesh survivors have been "betrayed" and asks why mesh operations are continuing when there are safer alternatives.

    He calls it a "cover up" and a "stitch up" and says this "whitewash" will not be accepted. 

  15. Health secretary admits mesh implant campaigners unhappy with Review report published at 15:24 British Summer Time 30 March 2017

    Shona RobisonImage source, bbc

    Ms Robison says she recognises Jackson Carlaw's tenacity on this issue.

    The health secretary says he is in no small part why the suspension of mesh implants and the review were put in place.

    She says she recognises the physical challenges of the women campaigners and says she hopes she has highlighted the achievements of the report.

    Ms Robison says she is not going to pretend the campaigners are happy with the report, admitting they are not. 

    She says the CMO will have to be satisfied all the safeguards in the report will have to be in place before any board offers these procedures

  16. 'One of the great health scandals'published at 15:23 British Summer Time 30 March 2017

    Tory MSP Jackson Carlaw says it was his privilege to sit on the Public Petitions Committee when Ms McIlroy and Ms Holmes first gave evidence. 

    Mr Carlaw says it is now considered "one of the great health scandals".

    The Tory MSP says the women dismissed as delusional to begin with.

    Tory MSP Jackson Carlaw
    Image caption,

    Tory MSP Jackson Carlaw

    He says he took pride when the then Health Secretary Alex Neil temporarily banned mesh.

    He asks if there will be a suspension on mesh operations until the Health Committee can properly review the statement.

    Mr Carlaw says the review has been a "whitewash". 

  17. Health boards will be fully expected to implement the conclusions set out by the Review published at 15:21 British Summer Time 30 March 2017

    The health minister says health boards will be fully expected to implement the conclusions set out by the Review, 

    Ms Robison says: 

    • further safeguards will be put in place PRIOR to any procedures using mesh being reintroduced routinely in individual health boards 
    • an Oversight Group will now be formed to work with Health Boards to ensure that the national aspects of the Independent Review’s conclusions are taken forward   
    • Scottish government officials are exploring a pilot of a specific mesh registry, in collaboration with colleagues elsewhere in the UK; again, this is something requested by women affected by mesh
  18. Measures in review due to all women affected by mesh implants published at 15:18 British Summer Time 30 March 2017

    Ms Robison says it is thanks to Ms McIIroy and Ms Holmes, along with those of many of the women affected – have led to other key achievements outside of the Independent Review:

    •  a helpline has been established where any woman affected by this issue can seek expert advice;
    • a patient information and consent leaflet has been developed, that is designed to help those suffering from stress urinary incontinence to make a careful, properly informed decision about their treatment; and, of course,
    • it was through their campaign, that the Scottish Government initially requested that these procedures be suspended
  19. The review has been challenged by the resignation of three valuable member published at 15:16 British Summer Time 30 March 2017

    Ms Robison says the review has been challenged by the resignation of three valuable members who said evidence had been ignored, hidden or deleted.

    She says the chair has confirmed all evidence has been published either in the report or on the website.

    Shona Robison

    The health minister says: 

    "What is clear from the Report is that, in the past, there have been serious issues around mesh procedures, and members will note that it makes two very clear recommendations in relation to the circumstances they can be offered in the future:

    • one is that, when women are treated for stress urinary incontinence, all appropriate options – both mesh and non-mesh – can  be offered, and crucially women must be given full  information to make an informed choice.
    • the second is that mesh procedures must not be offered routinely in the case of pelvic organ prolapse."
  20. Challenges of review is something the government needs to consider - minister published at 15:14 British Summer Time 30 March 2017

    Health Secretary Shona Robison says the difficulties and challenges in bringing this independent review is something the government needs to consider.

    Ms Robison says the government have placed a great deal of importance on this.

    The health secretary says she has always supported a delay to the procedure but women could press ahead with the operation is she is aware of the risk.

    She says that health boards have declined to ban mesh.